Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-20-2011 Planning Commission Packet PLANNING COMMISSION — AGENDA REGULAR MEETING 7:00 P.M. January 20, 2011 I. CALL TO ORDER: II. ROLL CALL: Declaration of Quorum III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: December 16, 2010 IV. OLD BUSINESS: A. Comprehensive Land Use Designation change from Low-Density Plan Amendment Residential to Mixed Residential (3300 block of Wernett Road) (Vinh Pham) (MF# CPA 10-001) B. Comprehensive Land Use Designation change from High-Density Plan Amendment Residential to Industrial (Corner of Pearl Street and 4th Avenue) (Terry Brown) (MF# CPA 10-002) C. Comprehensive Urban Growth Area Expansion (Road 52 & Plan Amendment Powerline Road) (Farm 2005 LLC) (MF# CPA10-003) D. Comprehensive Land Use Designation change from Low-Density Plan Amendment Residential to Mixed Residential (Corner of Charles Avenue and Clark Street) (Beacon Development) (MF# CPA 10-004) V. PUBLIC HEARINGS: A. Special Permit Rezone four parcels from Residential Transition to C-1 (Retail Business) Zone (Northeast corner of "A" Street and Heritage Boulevard) (Howard Rowell) (MF# Z 10-004) VI. OTHER BUSINESS: A. Comprehensive Parks and Recreation Comprehensive Plan Update Plan Update (MF# INFO 10-101 VII. ADJOURNMENT: REGULAR MEETING December 16, 2010 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING CALL TO ORDER: The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. by Chairman Cruz. POSITION MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT No. 1 Vacant No. 2 James Hay No. 3 Andy Anderson No. 4 Alecia Greenaway No. 5 Joe Cruz No. e Kurt Lukin s No. 7 Vacant No. 8 Jana Kempf No. 9 Lisa Gemig APPEARANCE OF FAIRNESS: Chairman Cruz read a statement about the appearance of fairness for hearings on land use matters. Chairman Cruz asked if any Commission member had anything to declare. Commissioner Anderson recused himself from the application for CPA 10-002. Commissioner Lukins identified himself as owning a home within the vicinity of the applications for SP 10-024 & CPA 10-002. No other declarations were made. Chairman Cruz then asked the audience if there were any objections based on conflict of interest or appearance of fairness questions regarding any of the items to be discussed this evening. There were no objections. ADMINISTERING THE OATH: Chairman Cruz explained that State law requires testimony in quasi-judicial hearings such as held by the Planning Commission be given under oath or affirmation. Chairman Cruz swore in all those desiring to speak. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Commissioner Hay moved to adopt the October 21St minutes & the November 16th minutes. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Anderson. The motion passed unanimously. -1 - OLD BUSINESS: Chairman Cruz explained that at the November meeting a quorum was not present, however the members that were present developed a record for Items "A" and "B" listed under New Business on the agenda. The Chairman further explained that those members not present at the November meeting had an opportunity review the record by either listening to the recorded audio or audio and video record of the hearings. Items "A" and "B" are continued hearings from the November meeting. NEW BUSINESS: A. Special Permit Location of new Middle School in an R-S-1 District. (Rd 52 & Powerline Rd.) (Renewal of a previously approved Special Permit) (Pasco School District) (MF# SP 10-024) Chairman Cruz read the master file number and explained the item was a continuation of a hearing held in November. Chairman Cruz reopened the hearing and asked for comments from staff. Dave McDonald, City Planner, stated an explanation of the proposal was provided at the November meeting and explained the report was essentially the same as the original report of two ,years ago. The only real changes to the report were removal of conditions relating to the completion of Road 52 and utility improvements. Commissioner Cruz closed the public hearing following three calls for comments. Commissioner Lukins moved, seconded by Commissioner Kempf, to adopt findings of fact and conclusions therefrom as contained in the December 16, 2010 staff report. The motion passed unanimously. Commissioner Lukins further moved, seconded by Commissioner Kempf, based on findings of fact and conclusions therefrom the Planning Commission recommend the City Council grant a special permit to the Pasco School District for the location of a Middle School at the southwest corner of Road 52 and Powerline Road with conditions as listed in the December 16, 2010 staff report. B. Special Permit Location of a Church with daycare services in a C-1 Zone (3806 W Court St.) (House of Restoration) (MF# SP 10-025) Chairman Cruz read the master file number reopened the hearing and asked for comments from staff. Shane O'Neill, Planner I, indicated a paragraph was added to the staff report relating to parking requirements. Mr. O'Neill also mentioned a condition was added to address building occupancy as it relates to the phasing of parking improvements. Commissioner Cruz closed the public hearing following three calls for comments. Commissioner Anderson moved, seconded by Commissioner Hay, to adopt findings of fact and conclusions therefrom as contained in the December 16, 2010 staff report. The motion passed unanimously. Commissioner Anderson moved, seconded by Commissioner Hay, based on findings of fact and conclusions therefrom the Planning Commission recommend the City Council grant a special permit to Oscar Perez for the location of a Church at 3806 W. Court Street with conditions as listed in the December 16, 2010 staff report. The motion passed unanimously. C. Comprehensive Land Use Designation change from Low- Plan Amendment Density Residential to Mixed Residential (3300 Block of Wernett Rd.) (Vinh Pham) (MF # CPA 10-001) Chairman Cruz read the master- file number and asked for comments from staff. Shane O'Neill, Planner I, briefly explained the nature of the application and the reasons for staffs' recommendation of denial. Chairman Cruz opened the hearing and asked if anyone wished to speak to the matter. Arnie McReynolds, 2220 Road 34, Pasco, spoke in opposition to the proposal based on his negative experiences with past residents of a nearby duplexes. He discussed traffic incidents, graffiti and other vandalism and criminal activity he felt were associated with the nearby duplexes. He would rather see the site developed with single-family residences. Lynn Hall, 2216 Road 33, agreed with Mr. Reynolds that a majority of the nuisance issues are generated by residents of the nearby duplexes. He spoke in opposition to the proposal and supported staffs recommendation of denial. He would rather see the site developed with single-family residences. -3 - Rick Russell (owner of Worley Surveying), 501 N. Quebec Street, spoke on behalf of the applicant. He stated the applicant wishes to construct 22 units (11 duplexes) on the site. He pointed out that the proposed density is similar to the density if the site were developed with single-family residences. Lynn Hall, 221b Road 33, stated that the previous property owners did not desire to develop the property. Chairman Cruz closed the hearing after three calls for comments. Commissioner Lukins moved, seconded by Commissioner Greenaway, to schedule deliberation, adoption of findings of fact and develop a recommendation for City Council for the January 20, 2011 meeting. The motion passed unanimously. D. Comprehensive Land Use Designation change from High- Plan Amendment Density Residential to Industrial (Corner of Pearl St. and 4th Ave.) (Terry Brown) (MF# CPA 10-002 Commissioner Anderson recused himself from the hearing because his employer (Pasco Housing Authority) owns the land involved in the proposed Comprehensive Plan amendment. Chairman Cruz read the master file number and asked for comments from staff. Shane O'Neill, Planner I, reviewed the written report which included information related to surrounding zoning and land uses. Mr. O'Neill indicated the original proposal to extend the industrial designation south into the Housing Authority property was not being recommended by staff. The recommendation was for the commercial designation along 4th Avenue to be extended to the east to include the Housing Authority property over to 3rd Avenue. Terry Brown (applicant), 5402 Jackson Lane, stated he was requesting the change to enable future development of the property for a coffee shop. He stated his timeframe for completion was roughly two ,years, but indicated he intends to begin site development in Spring of 2011. Chairman Cruz closed the hearing after three calls for comments. Commissioner Gemig moved, seconded by Commissioner Hay, to close the public hearing and schedule deliberations, the adoption of findings of fact and to develop a recommendation for the City Council for the January 20, 2011 meeting. The motion passed unanimously. -4 - E. Comprehensive Urban Growth Area Expansion (Road 52 & Plan Amendment Powerline Road) (Farm 2005, LLC) (MF # CPA 10-003 Chairman Cruz read the master file number and asked for comments from staff. David McDonald, City Planner, provided background information on the Growth Management Act as it applies to Pasco. Urban Growth Areas are the principal tool which communities around the State use manage growth. Urban Growth areas are to include enough land to accommodate population growth as estimated by the State Office of Financial Management (OFM). The OFM estimates indicate that over the current planning horizon from 2007 to 2027 the City will grow by an additional 30,000 people. The 2008 Comprehensive Plan was updated to include an additional 1,100 acres to accommodate the project population increase. Mr. McDonald also discussed utility constraints and future street improvements within the UGA. It was pointed out that the current sewer system east of Road 68 cannot accommodate any additional development north of the current UGA boundary. Without new population projections there is no justification to expand the Urban Growth Area. Chairman Cruz opened the public hearing. Jason Maddox, Meier Architecture and Engineering, 8697 Gage Blvd., reviewed the Office of Financial Management projections and explained they underestimated Pasco population growth. Mr. Maddox explained the City of Pasco's Comprehensive Plan states the size of Urban Growth Areas can vary due to regional settings and should be adequate to promote viable economic strategies, promote choices in housing accommodations and ensure adequate lands are available for associated open spaces and public purposes. He then explained how expanding he UGA boundary would support viable economic development strategies in the area by creating additional housing to support commercial development on Road 68. Mr. Maddox also discussed water rights and transportation improvements that would be associated with development of the site. Mr. Maddox felt that the site was the last viable piece of land to potentially develop for single-family homes. Chairman Cruz called for further public comment and with no response, the public hearing was closed. -5 - Commissioner Lukins questioned the special permit approval for the middle school and mentioned the housing to be built surrounding the school. He questioned why the area to the north was not being included in the Urban Growth Area. Mr. McDonald stated the School District was encouraged to find another location which was not on the border of the Urban Growth Boundary when they were looking for a school site. The area to the north was not included in the current UGA boundary because of the lack of capacity in the sewer system east of Road 68. Mr. Maddox provided some additional comments about septic systems and other options for sewer. Sewer lines east of the airport are reserved for industrial development. Commissioner Anderson moved, seconded by Commissioner Hay, to close the public hearing and schedule deliberations, the adoption of findings of fact and develop a recommendation for the City Council for the January 20, 2011 meeting. The motion passed unanimously. F. Comprehensive Land Use Designation change from Low- Plan Amendment Density Residential to Mixed Residential (Corner of Charles Avenue and Clark Street) (Beacon Development) (MF # CPA 10-004) Chairman Cruz read the master file number and asked for comments from staff. Rick White, Community & Economic Development Director, reviewed the written report for the Planning Commission describing the property, surrounding uses and various Comprehensive Plan policies related to the proposal. Chairman Cruz opened the public hearing. Paul Purcell, 3408 19th Ave South, President of Beacon Development, was present to speak in favor of the proposal. Mr. Purcell reviewed a number of slides explaining his proposal and why Beacon Development was seeking the Comprehensive Plan amendment. Mr. Purcell noted the proposal would provide a transitional buffer between low-density residential development to the east and commercial development to the west. Gracie Chacon, 323 N. Charles Avenue, captain of the neighborhood watch group, spoke in opposition of the proposal. The neighborhood was concerned -6 - about potential increases in traffic and crime. She noted these are problems associated with existing apartments. Mr. Purcell, cited police report statistics indicating a reduction in crime following the development of Tepeyac Haven. He followed by mentioning the family oriented characteristics of the proposed development. Chairman Cruz asked Mr. Purcell how apartment resident applications are screened. Mr. Purcell responded by saying criminal and rental history background screening are part of the screening process. Chairman Cruz asked the applicant how the site would be accessed. Mr. Purcell indicated the preliminary points of access on the overhead screen development and acknowledged traffic volumes would increase regardless of the access configuration. Daniel Jimenez, 323 N. Charles Avenue, asked Mr. Purcell if traffic will increase. Mr. Purcell responded affirmatively. Mr. Jimenez stated his opposition to the development of apartments on the site. Chairman Cruz asked Mr. Jimenez how many people were in the neighborhood watch group which Mr. Jimenez was speaking on behalf of. Mr. Jimenez responded "seven". Mr. Purcell added that his staff intends to join the neighborhood watch. Gracie Chacon, 323 N. Charles Avenue, reiterated her opposition to the proposal. Commissioner Anderson stated that while in his position with the Pasco Housing Authority, his experience with Beacon Development has been a positive one. In his opinion, Beacon Development screens their applicants thoroughly and their facilities are well maintained. Commissioner Anderson moved, seconded by Commissioner Greenaway, to close the public hearing and schedule deliberations, the adoption of findings of fact and to develop a recommendation for the City Council for the January 20, 2011 meeting. The motion passed unanimously. OTHER BUSINESS: -7 - With no further business, the Planning Commission was adjourned at 8:42 P.m. --------------- David McDonald, Secretary -8 - MEMORANDUM DATE: January 20, 2011 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Shane O'Neill, Planner I SUBJECT: Comprehensive Plan Amendment (Vihn Pham) (MF# CPA 10-001) The applicant, Vihn Pham, has applied to amend the Land Use Designation indicated on the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map from Low-Density Residential (1 unit/7,200 square feet) to Mixed Residential with the intent to rezone the site to R-2 (Medium Density Residential) (1 unit/5,000 square feet) thereby allowing the site to be developed with duplexes. The subject property is approximately 5.1 acres located on the north side of Wernett Road at the northern termini of Roads 33 & 34. The subject parcel is zoned R-1 (Low Density Residential) which conforms to the Plan's current Land Use Designation. Properties to the west are zoned R-S-1 (Suburban), RS-12 (Suburban) to the south and R-1 to the east. The sites' current zoning allows for relatively higher residential density development than surrounding parcels. With regard to surrounding land uses, the neighborhood is developed primarily with single-family homes interspersed with duplexes. The adjacent parcel to the west contains two duplexes while three more duplexes on separate parcels are located directly to the southeast. The duplex units are legal nonconforming and were constructed while under Franklin County's jurisdiction prior to annexation. The site is bordered to the north by Highway I-182. Wernett Road provides direct access to the site. Wernett Road connects to Road 36, Road 32 and other roads for access to the community. The site is located in a larger area bounded by SR 395 on the east, I-182 and Argent Road on the north, Road 68 on the west and Court Street on the south. Except for a narrow band along Court Street and Road 68 this larger area is designated for low- density development. This designation has been applied to the area for about 30 years. Zoning for the area has been established to be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan Designation. It should be noted, approval of the application at hand would open the site to the possibility of being rezoned to R-3 (Medium Density Residential). The following table illustrates the potential maximum residential densities as they relate to parcel size and zoning. 1 LUD Zoning Units/acre Units on site* Low Density Res. R-1 b 30 Mixed Res. R-2 8.7 44 Mixed Res. R-3 14.5 74 * Number of units on site is based on existing site square footage (222,156) and does not account for any potential right-of-way dedications. Based on the figures above, approval of the proposed Plan amendment could potentially result in a density increase of 44 units on the site; more than doubling the current allowable density. The chart above illustrates the maximum potential effect of the Plan amendment. The applicant has stated intent to rezone the property to R-2 only. It has been a long standing policy of the City to place High-Density Land Use Designations on or near major streets. By doing so, the City can encourage the development of multi-family projects to be conveniently located on or near major transportation routes. This helps prevent the need for higher density apartment traffic from traveling on local access street through low-density neighborhoods. High- density development located along or near major streets can also take advantage of the larger utility lines that are often located in major streets as well as the availability of transit service. Higher density residential Land Use Designations have also been used to provide buffers between high intensity commercial uses and low intensity residential uses. In this case the creation of a higher density residential Land Use Designation will not serve as a buffer because there are no nearby commercial uses and zoning districts or Land Use Designations. The following Comprehensive Plait Goals and Policies are applicable to this application: LU-3-E Policy: Designate areas for higher density residential development where utilities and transportation facilities enable efficient use of capital resources. H-1-A Policy: Medium and high density housing should be located near arterials and neighborhood or community shopping facilities and employment areas. H-1-B Policy: Encourage the location of medium and high density housing in locations that will avoid the need for access through lower density residential neighborhoods. The long standing practice of locating higher density residential Land Use Designations along major streets is supported by Comprehensive Plan Policies LU-3-E and H-1-13. Policy LU-3-E encourages designating areas for higher density residential 2 development where utilities and transportation facilities enable efficient use of capital resources, in other words, where utilities and streets have the capacity to absorb an added load from the high-density development. Policy H-1-B encourages the location of medium and high density housing in locations that will avoid the need for access through lower density residential neighborhoods. The establishment of multi-family dwelling units at the north end of Roads 33 and 34 would undoubtedly foster increased traffic on Road 32 for access to Court Street. In this respect the proposal is not supported by the Comprehensive Plan Policy H-1-13. This long standing policy would need to be modified before a Mixed Residential Designation could be applied to the property in question. A review of the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map indicates the nearest land with a Mixed Residential Land Use Designation is approximately 1.2 miles to the west. If the Plan amendment were approved, the site would appear as an isolated spot on the Land Use Map. Typically the concept of "spot Zoning" is viewed as an unsound planning technique and should be avoided. Planning Staff is recommending the application be denied particularly for the three main points listed above. Again, they are: 1) Policy Goal H-1-13 discourages creating the need for traffic to and from medium high density residential development to flow through low density residential neighborhoods; 2) the application proposes to establish an isolated Land Use Designation where no similar Land Use Designation exists in the immediate vicinity to which the site may be connected; 3) the amendment will not serve as a buffer between high intensity and low intensity Land Use Designations. The Planning Commission will need to determine if the proposal materially alters the general intent of the Comprehensive Plan and whether or not it can be supported by the recommended goals and policies. Findings of Fact The following are initial findings drawn from the background and analysis section of the staff report. The Planning Commission may add additional findings to this listing as the result of factual testimony and evidence submitted during the public hearing. 1. The site is currently identified for a low-density development on the Comprehensive Plan Land Use snap. 2. The site is part of a larger area bounded by SR 395, I-182, Argent Road, Court Street and Road 68 that is designated for low-density development. 3. The site and surrounding properties that have been identified for low- density development for 30 years or snore. 4. The site is in an area that is generally developed with low-density suburban lots. 3 5. Policy Goal LU-3-E encourages designating areas for higher density residential development where utilities and transportation facilities enable efficient use of capital resources. G. Policy goal H-1-B encourages the location of medium and high density housing in locations that will avoid the need for access through lower density residential neighborhoods. 7. Wernett Road is not a major street. 8. Wernett Road is not on a transit route. 9. Access to the site is through low-density neighborhoods along Road 36, Road 32 and Wernett Road. 10. No other properties within the general vicinity are designated for mixed residential uses. 11. The Mixed Residential Land Use Designation includes R-2 (Medium Density Residential) and R-3 (Medium Density Residential) Zoning districts. 12. Existing duplexes in the vicinity are considered legal nonconforming. 13. There has been no change in condition to warrant the proposed change. Conclusions The site in question is located in an inappropriate location to be considered for a Comprehensive Plan amendment. Wernett is not an arterial street and the encouragement for permitting multi-family development on the site in question may lead to higher density traffic through a low-density area which is discouraged by the Comprehensive Plan. Approval of the Plan amendment may lead to residential development of a density which is inconsistent with the surrounding vicinity. The proposal will not advance health, safety and general welfare of the community. Recommendation MOTION: I move to adopt findings of fact and conclusions therefrom as contained in the January 20, 2011 staff report. MOTION: I move based on the findings of fact and conclusions therefrom, the Planning Commission recommend the City Council deny the proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendment. Vicini Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Map Applicant. Vihn Pham•t File #: CPA 10-00.1 —A-4 SITE or 1 72 c} •'` — „r WERNETT R �SEABROOK CTOO - cCA s. - IF D Current Land Use Legend Commercial High Density Residential Industrial Low-Density Residential Mixed Residential/Commercial Parks/Open Space O Legend Commercial Illlli High Density Residential moll Industrial Low-Density Residential Mixed Residential/Commercial Parks/Open Space IWO I _1111111 11111111 - Overview Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Applicant: Vihn Pham Map File #: CPA 10-001 4 ips��� � �♦f�R+�. ,rrr■HU■ ■� s �.� sal gas air ry � ��```��� �s� 111r�Ir■i6iarra a ��A� �!#fir +�.l��•.r •�.♦# ♦♦�♦ a Aa.-�°� err. .� '��♦a ��.�1E►�♦♦l�i.� err .n` ��� - ■ �[ 11 t r,aw ■a I ■ � �� !I���; ■!��" I,��:►�' �• 111 �11:�111 �I�IITIIIIIILI ■11� - =mom �;� �1�1111 1111■�1111 =■I�' ���� ■��� �1 _ — _ .- �■ �IN1111 .�1111l1111■ 1111111111 .■■■1 , 1-11 EM no "1�1 ■ 11111111�1� �1 11111111 -'r Ill II ■, ■I, � ■■ ■� � tl ' - ,.. .11■ 1.1/II ITIITI �I r■�■�I � 1 ■ ..I. .�.. � a>• ■■ng armor I1r■11 1ai111 M111s■ in i rr■ry, ■aI,N■ a aaaa M1ur1 ■ ,II�� I��+ ■ a S a11ia1:lrrsr■ �� aii�i ■11�s,a 1� win 1�1�k1�1 + 119, 1 1 ■� � ■ rlrlriri■_ln w�rr r�.♦� � r�■i■ rl■irl,rrr i t l l� � 1 ■�r♦I ■�i ,\I�IjI►.. ■■■ ■� ■ �� • , 1� w. IBIS Hors■ V Joe_ :: : lrr■■6 I j� k.■ ■��, ...■ ■ ... j i�11111�11: 1111! - -■i,. ■srnl ah-.rt ■ I'� .� I�I� ��� ■ a ■■rllaaa■ ■aaMar 11a1a1 :;I.0 ■Ir1sI 1■� l rl i� _ ■ �.�_ •-rNfl/ 71■1nn8 rrrla■ also■. w. ■■ r■I11� / r�� I11■���1111� ■ru ar1lrl J�nrraM ■nnu �r in _i% I�- 11,� # � r�■■�" rru■r �: :: :: ■ 4uI!< ■noJi i 111111 1 ,I`� gwnr �■g" ffim 11r'on -: _:: iieiii'�.1 111%,240 �1 ,r��l� ■I� � rnsrr ■,__. • =1�1�■ ! fir• ■■�1 ■���r ��, -rn,r n�1r>f' rn ■■rI■I In■ur r - � ��is RIO ��- ■Iw,1� rl■111 ■11Mar I„ •1rral 1161/111 I COMMERCIAL w J�■! *� ■�� .fur■ iii ■rrra■ Iati6t,1 ■1a1rr 1aMM11 nu .�. w i■ nlarr 1nu1� rAluil■ �nsr■ ■■�.r GOVERNMENT �Ir.�_����`I�it��l��'�� t�� anuu ■1 r'lrii �Ynren•7 1n 1r1rIr1 .�. PUBLIC; ■�■ rr �i■ � ■_.11111" ]I HIGH alr�l■l lr�t,�■■�Aw•�wrs I �rr1Mr 1■r I'.J ■ �I.,nl il�l�l''� �.1■INL• 11� E INDUSTRIAL f ■■ i■■■■ 1 .www■,�r _ Ilil/ sl■■11r■r W■IN1+ � _ 9*■ �Inu�uk r ■ I:��'� ',.� • a .■■ ■ � ��■.■ ■::�■ is.22�. ■liar �: � �I� r son lifting LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL . . •111■Illl���■■ ' r rarer asria■ I'm M111.11- M=>D�I ■� \■! ■.■■■ I �a■Ma Ia1111 ■Misr■ ■■il��r■��11 rri 11.■ ■�'� ■ MIXED-RESIDENTIAL ■���_■"� I 4rralr raalal 41111111 �� ■■pro rra444 =f■■M, ,� �� ■� ■ III, ■>tsra■ 4raaM1 1aarlr _ nlll■1 11111■ /• wi■ra• • i a r �aNr■■ It man smog rill= ■ 11IIn■ ■4■r1u1■ •� M■11.■ � �� r• 1�a//�■1 la1 smog 10tx ■ arr,ll■ aa���1M1■ �� rrrlar ` �■rr1■=�.■ ■ate - iilri■ ■1 pommel I�� -iuii� !1� j ■1 MEMORANDUM DATE: January 20, 2011 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Shane O Neill, Planner I SUBJECT: Comprehensive Plan Amendment (Terry Brown) (MF# CPA 10-002) The applicant, Terry Brown, has applied to amend the Land Use Designation indicated on the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map from High-Density Residential to Industrial with the intent to rezone the site to C-1 (Retail Business) to allow the site to be developed with a drive-thru coffee shop. The site, located on the southeast corner of Pearl Street and 4th Avenue, is owned by the Pasco Housing Authority and only involves the undeveloped land to the northerly of the Housing authority play field. Lying along the southern portion of the site is an old roadway belonging to the former war-time housing complex from the 1940's. With regard to zoning and land uses, the subject site is currently zoned R-3 (Medium Density Residential) which does not permit commercial development. The site directly to the north is zoned C-1 and contains the Shamrock Tavern. The Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) shops and offices are located directly to the west across 4th Avenue from the site. The WSDOT property is zoned C-3 (General Business). To the east lie BFSF owned railroad tracks/right- of-way. In terms of the originally advertised site (extending the full length of the parcel to the railroad tracks), an industrially zoned parcel also lies to the north and contains a building previously used for agricultural produce packing. There has been some recent commercial development within the general vicinity. A gas station, convenience store and laundry facility was constructed at 1949 N. 4th Avenue. Action Towing at 1948 N. 4th has expanded with a new office and shop building. The existence of new or expanded commercial establishments demonstrates the viability of the neighborhood for commercial activities. These changing conditions lend valuable insight to the potential level of utility and need for retail businesses in this area of the community. The following Comprehensive Plan Goals and Policies are applicable to this application: LIT-1-C Policy: Encourage cluster coininercial development and discourage strip corninercial development. 1 LU-1-B Policy: Enhance the physical appearance of developinent within the coininunity through land use regulations, design guidelines, and perforinance and maintenance standards including landscaping, screening, building facades, color, signs, and parking lot design and appearance. LU-3-D Policy: Encourage mixed-use developinent including neighborhood scale shopping areas within planned residential developments to promote walkable coininunities. CF-?-A Policy: Encourage growth in geographic areas where services and utilities can be extended in an orderly, progressive and efficient manner. UT-3 Goal: Assure the provision of adequate and efficient storm water ?nanagetnent (are ?net). TR-3 Goal: Beautify the ?najor streets of the City. Commercial development of the site is supported by a variety of Policies and Goals in the Comprehensive Plan. Plan Policy LU-3-D encourages mixed-use development to promote neighborhood scale shopping areas and more walkable communities. The proposal would contribute to the advancement of this Goal due the site's close proximity to a large residential neighborhood to the west and multi-family residential development on and to the south of the subject site. Additional Policies and Goals (TR-3, UT-3, LU-1-B & CF-2-A) also support the proposal in the way that infrastructure improvements such as storm water management, sidewalks and landscaping are standard requirements of commercial development projects in the City. Encouraging commercial development on the site advances Plan Goals related to economic development and enhances the physical appearance of the community. To the north of the site, Pearl Street serves as a physical boundary to delineate land uses of different intensities and in a sense creates a buffer. If commercial/industrial land uses are permitted to extend south of Pearl Street the buffering provided by the street will be eliminated. The Municipal Code (Zoning) however, incorporates buffering standards in the landscaping regulations by requiring enhanced landscaping where a more intense land use, such as a commercial business, is constructed adjacent to a less intense use, such as a residential complex. It should be noted the Comprehensive Plan Amendment request originally proposed changing the Land Use Designation from High-Density Residential to Industrial. Upon further evaluation and analysis of the Land Use Map, it appears 2 to be more appropriate to extend the Commercial Land Use Designation from across 4th Avenue east to include a portion of the site in question. The remaining area east of 3rd Avenue could remain under the current High-Density Residential. This modification to the original request will address the applicants' needs for commercial development while maintaining control over the potential inappropriate location of industrial uses on 4th Avenue and adjacent to the Housing Authority play field. The site staff is recommending for a Commercial Land Use Designation can be considered part of the 4th Avenue Corridor area identified in the City's Corridor and Gateway Plan of 2008. Allowing the property to develop for commercial uses rather than industrial uses will support efforts envisioned in the Gateway Plan due to the fact commercial development requires more landscaping than industrial development. The Planning Commission will need to determine if the proposal materially alters the general intent of the Comprehensive Plan and whether or not it can be supported by the Goals and Policies of the Comprehensive Plan and the Corridors and Gateway Plan. Findings of Fact The following are initial findings drawn from the background and analysis section of the staff report. The Planning Commission may add additional findings to this listing as the result of factual testimony and evidence submitted during the public hearing. 1. The site is located on North 4th Avenue. 2. The site is current designated for high density residential development under the Comprehensive Plan. 3. The site is zoned R-3 Medium Density Residential. 4. North 4th Avenue is an arterial street. 5. North 4th Avenue south of I-182 is included as a gateway street in the City's Corridors and Gateway Plan. b. Commercial landscaping standards require landscaping in parking lots. 7. Industrial landscaping standards do not require landscaping in parking lots. 8. A convenience store, gas station, laundry facility and automotive service facility have located a block north of the site between 2007 and 2010. 9. The site has remained vacant for the past 65 ,years. 10. An Industrial Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation permits future rezones for industrial activities. 11. A Commercial Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation permits future rezones for commercial activities. 3 12. The west side of North 4th Avenue is designated in the Comprehensive Plan for Commercial uses. 13. Both the east and west sides of North 4th Avenue, generally between Court Street and 3rd Avenue, are identified for commercial development in the Comprehensive Plan. Conclusions Commercial development along North 4th Avenue north of Court Street will better support the Corridor and Gateway Plan and will complement other commercial development that has recently occurred in the neighborhood. The Commercial Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation of the site, or a portion thereof, would permit rezones for commercial uses which would be more compatible with the residential uses located to the south. Recommendation MOTION: I move to adopt findings of fact and conclusions therefrom as contained in the December 16, 2010 staff report. MOTION: I move based on the findings of fact and conclusions therefrom, the Planning Commission recommend the City Council approve the proposed Comprehensive Plan amendment. Vicini Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment - Terry Brown N a ty Applicant: File #: CPA 10-002 4- �,j 4-,; LU Ir o W Ut ap ;;, •-- tY `. PEARL ST .A ' PLAIRL�fST - SITE *6 1 uj _ r Q Q F Q Lip ore - SAGA S, ' " ' :.� Land Use Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Map Applicant: Terry Brown N File #: CPA 10-002 - Cu rrent Land Use IF 111 ILI L__i_J > W LEOLA ST ,Q a Ell PEARL SJT PEARL ST ITE LU Ll U Q Legend ® COMMERCIAL M5 Ilk � HIGH-DENSITY-RESIDENTIAL INDUSTRIAL LOW-DENSITY-RESIDENTIAL ® MIXED-RESIDENTIAL Land Use Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Map . App ll c ant: Terry Brown N File #: CPA 10-002 Proposed Land Use W 1 I I L I L--L-J LEOLA ST [I< < fa `PEA I--- SST PEARL ST SITE Legend COMMERCIAL ' HIGH DENSITY _RESIDENTIAL INDUSTRIAL LOW_DENSITY_RESIDENTIAL ® MIXED-RESIDENTIAL Eva� 14f,E �'T CNN i - INDUSTRIAL LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL MIXED RESIDENTIAL 11`IEMORANDUNI DATE: January 20, 2010 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Dave McDonald, City Planner SUBJECT: Urban Growth Area Expansion (MF# CPA10-003) (Farm 2005 LLC] Farm 2005, LLC., the owner of 160 acres of farm land directly north of the City limits, has applied for a Comprehensive Plan Amendment that would revise the Urban Growth Area (UGA) to include 160 acres currently outside the Pasco UGA. The property in question is located at the northeast corner of Road 52 and Powerline Road. The following provides the historical background on Urban Growth Areas and may help with arriving at a recommendation on this request. The 1990 Growth Management Act (GMA) required the establishment of Urban Growth Areas (UGA's) around urban centers throughout the State. Urban Growth Areas have become a key component in managing urban growth within Washington. Urban Growth Areas define the area in which a community is to encourage higher density urban development and the area in which urban services can be supported and promoted. Land located outside UGA's are to be reserved for the promotion of rural density and functions. By directing growth to UGA's natural resource lands such as farm lands and forest lands can be conserved and the character of rural areas can be maintained for future needs. Pasco's first Urban Growth Area was established in April of 1993 and has been modified only three times since then. The designation of the Pasco UGA was not only guided by the GMA Goals (see attachment #1), but also by the provisions of RCW 36.70A.110 the most pertinent portions of which are as follows: • Each county that is required or chooses to plan under RCW 36.70A.040 shall designate an urban growth area or areas within which urban growth shall be encouraged and outside of which growth can occur only if it is not urban in nature. • Each city that is located in such a county shall be included within an urban growth area. • An urban growth area may include territory located outside of a city only if such territory already is characterized by urban growth I whether or not the urban growth area includes a city, or is adjacent to territory already characterized by urban growth, or is a designated new fully contained community as defined by RCW 36.70A.350. • Based upon the growth management population projection made for the county by the Office of Financial Management, the county and each city within the county shall include areas and densities sufficient to permit the urban growth that is projected to occur in the county or city for the succeeding twenty-,year period, except for those urban growth areas contained totally within a National Historical Reserve. • Each city must include areas sufficient to accommodate the broad range of needs and uses that will accompany the projected urban growth including, as appropriate, medical, governmental, institutional, commercial, service, retail, and other non-residential uses. • Each urban growth area shall permit urban densities and shall include greenbelt and open space areas. • An urban growth area determination may include a reasonable land market supply factor and shall permit a range of urban densities and uses. In determining this market factor, cities and counties may consider local circumstances. • Urban growth should be located first in areas already characterized by urban growth that have adequate existing public facility and service capacities to serve such development, second in areas already characterized by urban growth that will be served adequately by a combination of both existing public facilities and services and any additional needed public facilities and services that are provided by either public or private sources, and third in the remaining portions of the urban growth areas. Urban growth may also be located in designated new fully contained communities as defined by RCW36.70A.350. • In general, cities are the units of local government most appropriate to provide urban governmental services. In general, it is not appropriate that urban governmental services be extended to or expanded in rural areas except in those limited circumstances shown to be necessary to protect basic public health and safety and the environment and when such services are financially 2 supportable at rural densities and do not permit urban development. Based on State law, the Pasco UGA is to include all lands within the city and may include lands outside the City if the lands are urban in nature. Development within the UGA is to occur first on lands that currently have adequate public facility and service capacities and secondly on lands that will be served adequately in the future. The UGA needs to contain a sufficient amount of land to accommodate expected growth for the 20 year planning horizon. The expected growth is determined by county wide population projections prepared by the State Office of Financial Management (OFM). In addition to the population projections the city must also considered land needs for parks, school, retail businesses, offices, industrial buildings and other land uses. In the determination for UGA land needs local market supply factors may also be considered. The population projections provided by the State Office of Financial Management for Pasco's 20 year planning horizon (2007-2027) indicates Pasco's UGA population could be about 87,300 by 2027. Adjusted for growth since 2007 the OFM projections indicate an additional 24,600 people need to be accommodated within the UGA by 2027. The UGA will therefore need to include enough land area to accommodate another 24,600 people by 2027. Housing needs are the main contributors to the need for expanding the UGA. Various land use studies [APA Memo (Bringing land use ratios into the 90's) 1992] show that approximately half of all developed lands within American cities are devoted to residential uses. The other half is occupied by streets, open space, schools, and parks, industrial and commercial activities. Approximately one third of Pasco's land area is zoned for industrial development, and as much as 65 percent of the designated industrial lands are currently vacant. The eastern boundary of the current UGA includes an additional 1,000 acres of sparsely developed industrially designated lands east of the City limits. Approximately nine percent of Pasco is currently zoned for commercial development. In 2003, the City Council commissioned a study of future commercial land needs. The study prepared by Huitt-Zollars (2003) indicated the City of Pasco had enough commercially designated (by zoning or Camp. Plan designation) land in the main growth corridor (I-182 Corridor) to fulfill future commercial service needs through the year 2050. With considerable industrial/commercial land available for future needs the primary need for additional lands within the Pasco UGA is for the accommodation of residential development. 3 As a part of the 2007 Comprehensive Plan update it was estimated, (Appendix III-Urban Growth Area Expansion) based on the OFM population projections, 9,300 to 9,500 new housing units would need to be constructed in Pasco by 2027. In 2007 it was determined that the then existing Pasco UGA could absorb an additional 6,400 single-family dwelling units. To accommodate future growth as determined through State mandated population projections the Pasco UGA was expanded by approximately 1,100 acres. This expanded UGA includes about 730 acres for additional housing, 150 acres for schools, parks and other community facilities and 220 acres for market supply factors. A local market supply factor is permitted under (RCW 36.70A.110 [2]). The Office of Financial Management has not provided any addition population projection since 2007. As a result no justification exists on which to base the need for an expanded UGA over and above the expansion that occurred in 2008. The actual growth rate (based on housing starts) for Pasco since 2007 has not exceeded the State population projections. Population projections are only one of the factors which must be considered in establishing an UGA. Another important factor is the availability and capacity of the City's utility system. The proposed UGA boundary amendment is located east of Road 60 and north of I-182. The main sewer trunk line serving properties generally east of Road 60 and north of I-182 was designed to accommodate development within the UGA established by Franklin County in 1992 and re-established in 2004. This trunk line can serve approximately 1,000 more residential housing units. The three major developments (Loviisa Farms, Northwest Commons & First Place) ,yet to be built in this area will consume the reserve capacity in the trunk line. There is little capacity available for the trunk line to serve property beyond the existing UGA at Power Line Road. The sewer service capability beyond the current UGA east of Road 60 is further complicated by topography. The ground elevation north of the present UGA (in the area of the applicant's property) breaks and falls off sharply to the east. Providing sewer service in this area would be problematic. A major lift station would be needed. However, lifting waste up to a trunk line with no capacity is not an option. In 2001 the City of Pasco installed a significant sewer trunk line west through the southern portion of West Pasco to the intersection of Court Street and the I-182 bridge. This line was designed with excess capacity to serve properties west and north of Road 100 (Broadmoor Blvd.). The trunk line extending north from Argent Road in the vicinity of Road 72 was also designed to serve properties to the north of Sandifur Parkway west of Road 68. The current sewer system has capacity to serve additional growth west of Road 68 but little to no capacity to serve additional properties north of the existing UGA east of Road 60. 4 The City's domestic water system has more flexibility for expansion with a couple of water reservoirs close to the northern UGA boundary. However, emphasis has been placed on expanding the system to serve properties west of Road 68. A new water filtration plant and reservoir was constructed on Court Street near Road 111 this past year. The 2008 expansion of the UGA boundary on the western edges of the community was based in part on the increased water capacity that would be provided by the new plant on Court Street. The Franklin County PUD and Big Bend Electric built a new substation north of the Columbia Place subdivision (west of Road 68 north of Snoqualmie) in 2004. This substation was built to provide additional electrical capacity for the area west of the substation and generally north of Sandifur Parkway. In addition to population projections and utility service capacities, transportation facilities was another factor considered for the 2008 UGA expansion west of Road 68. The Comprehensive Plan has long called for the extension of Road 100 (Broadmoor Boulevard) to the north. Franklin County has included this extension in its six year street plan and has designed the extension. The Broadmoor Boulevard extension to Dent Road will be completed in 2012. The completion of the connection north to Dent Road and the planned connection to Dent Road to the west will increase traffic capacity on Broadmoor Boulevard north of Sandifur Parkway. This increase in capacity will generate interest in development near the Road 100/1-182 Interchange. Additionally, the completion of signalization and slip ramps on the Road 100/I-182 interchange in the summer of 2007 combined with the construction of the west bound on ramp increased the capacity and safety of the interchange. The GMA requires internal consistency between City planning documents. While planning is currently underway for utility expansion westward and near Broadmoor Boulevard there has been no planning effort related to expanding water and sewer plans beyond the current eastern UGA to the east of Road 68. Findings of Fact The following are initial findings drawn from the background and analysis section of the staff report. The Planning Commission may add additional findings to this listing as the result of factual testimony and evidence submitted during the public hearing. 1. The GMA (RCW 36.70A.110) requires the establishment of Urban Growth Areas. 2. The goals of the Growth Management Act related to UGA's include: i) Encouraging development of urban areas where adequate public facilities and services exist or can be provided in an efficient manner; ii) Reducing the inappropriate conversion of undeveloped land into sprawling low-density development; and, iii) Maintaining and enhance 5 natural resource based industries, including productive timber, agriculture, and fisheries industries. 3. Each city located in Franklin County must be included within a UGA. 4. UGA's are to encompass lands within the City's recognized utility service area. 5. UGA's may include portions of the County already characterized by urban growth. 6. Designated Urban Growth Areas are to include enough undeveloped land to adequately accommodate forecasted growth for a 20 year planning period. 7. Forecasted growth is determined by population projections provided by the State Office of Financial Management. 8. The GMA mid-range population projections for the County anticipate Franklin County will grow to over 100,000 people during the 20 year planning horizon for Pasco. 9. For planning purposes during the development of the 2007 Comprehensive Plan update, City and County Planners assume 85 percent of future population growth in Franklin County would occur in the Pasco UGA. 10. Pasco's UGA population is expected to be about 87,300 by 2027. 11. The Pasco UGA was increased by over 1,100 acres in 2008 to accommodate the population growth eliminated by the Office of Financial Management. 12. The 2008 UGA expansion included acreage for housing, parks schools, streets and other public facilities. 13. The 2008 UGA expansion included 220 acres of additional land for local market factors. 14. The Office of Financial Management has not provide any additional population projections since 2007. 15. The main sewer trunk line that runs north of the freeway (I-182) west of Desert Plateau (in Madison Ave.) was designed to serve only those areas within the current UGA. 16. Housing units approved with preliminary plats east of Road 60 and north of I-182 will consume the line capacity of the Madison Avenue trunk line. 17. Topography at the north end of Section 11, Township 9 North, Range 29 East makes it impossible to install a gravity flow sewer system in that part of the community. 18. The sewer trunk line running along the north side of the FCID irrigation canal west of Road 72 has additional capacity. 19. The main West Pasco sewer trunk line running west along Sylvester Street, the Columbia River shoreline and Court Street currently has excess capacity. 20. The West Pasco sewer trunk line extends west on Court Street to the Richland Bridge. 21. The West Pasco trunk line at the Richland Bridge is 13 feet deep. 6 22. The City Public Works Department has undertaken studies for sewer routes and needs for areas west of Road 76. 23. Franklin County will be extending Broadmoor Boulevard north to Dent Road next year 24. Franklin County will also be connecting Broadmoor Blvd with Dent Road to the west. 25. The Road 68 to Broadmoor Boulevard connection along the north city limits may be built within the next 5 ,years. 26. The Road 100 Interchange is located at the geographic center of the Tri-Cities. 27. The City's Public Works Department has begun preliminary planning for the location of a new waste water treatment plant to be located west of Road 100. 28. A new electrical substation is located just north of the City limits west of Road 68 Conclusions Based on the GMA population projections for Franklin County the City of Pasco must plan for an additional population of about 31,0 00. The City and Franklin County properly considered state population projections and increased the Pasco UGA in 2008 to accommodate urban growth. Utility capacities, construction of a new water plant and planning for a new sewer plant along with planned street network improvements factored into the 2008 UGA was expansion west of Road 68. Utility and street planning has not changed since 2008. Absent new or additional population projections from the Office of Financial Management there is no justification to expand the Pasco UGA. Recommendation MOTION for Findings of Fact: I move to adopt the findings of fact and conclusions as contained in the Urban Growth Area Expansion Staff Memo dated January 20, 2010. MOTION for Recommendation: I move based on the findings of fact and conclusions therefrom the Planning Commission recommend the City Council deny the request for the Urban Growth Area expansion under Master File number CPA 10-003. Overview Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment City Applicant: I Kidwell Limits - # ' A 10-00 'r 16 a• � rs�1lxa� ° •`• R t fD11► RR,� 1I °iri; CiQfu Es Ir aw—r ai 6i s �� •• � tv Nix „r' •.�—iii � +f _. _ Q. PIT v V - ��.• ` . a AR • v • ,. .a � 7 fAS ii°'�O'°?°`4 �"'dal !'.,��c>�1��►r� �� � ���` Overview Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment N Applicant: I Kidwell UGB File # ' A 10-00 I ✓ �4•�I w �r ^r' 23 1 -� - It r At- "r x - a �'� � , i F•BSI e �*�y�,�;'c ti,��r�� ';i�RMi��EY�' 4►!i �.. � � ��L_1. � �• � _ 0 i f � .. r • �Rld-y % ``�+� ����s.w I b* i!sr 7•,i•� 'K�iy,+a�l E 1;6r3 Ri?fl13 Is���i3� Item: Comprehensi* ve Plan Amendment Vl* cl*nl*ty Applicant- Thomas Kidwell N Map File # -. CPA 10 -003 Ll �■FA Via Ph IN C ► �.. ■■ °•. nup ts �a. � r. i . " p X11 IEa ■ ■V a ■Ii ��c: o _ ai ' •° u�d or. Irrx S�ysri�y ...�:#.. � .t i'1■(. '`�M�'.� `- � i +�,� • q FEN ar s.w� ir7i s•r j t. a age 171■R M � = .y OIIIIGai iR�� . ,rftiD,liiitlfii f.KsGilfw►. <ril►� ��,. e � � r, o i • �7'-i iiii:i» 91�1��ra iia[3fYU�� � �.!■iYrlri t /_ '�' �"�' ri,ilirY1ei �Udli,a 1v►■yf�tsaar■1-+ . w■ r■ w■ //s>+s y to �Gi�inilii iiak a i/ �li■.ei��■i:I.�� a a„s sr aw ■s '� � - I w �` ■rrw�2�ar�(�„arai •h.14 tC:b ■ ar 411,w s �� a G71ir,r.eiirr,a �'f 31 aw+.s;ate +i ♦. /UEEE�EIIIE�:Li�l.Yll Lt �7� ri ,i ■ + �y u.� ,Rw �r •a ♦I��i lEE'.a���ir■ ��� �iiaR.i i.+rd .r' . � � c V� aai�iESlfiG■■w �---� : u�wr+.■ y ar ■�fN A J 1 r1 r i � / 1 ars�rrrr,..rr a �... a ,,e w�y� ■i �� : a i rrT�� ..., lJaEi� �iive 'i' a.�a�i w r.. r�.+.w. ;� �• . iEECiI 113YI1IGIl� - LE/l 646 *IdFie?r1�1�o�a 11 a 1 `_ cte °`�I,...�ild��r�Ei 119.a,r •iin�s■r ailiaiisr 7i.irlai/ •vs wr w ■ sr�.�`+� :: + solve .. ..r.s..�r �wyY/ii■I�iJAMx Urban Item: Comprehensi* ve Plan Amendment Growth Appli" cant: Thomas Boundary File # -. CPA 10 -003 kill a � Its Y �� M, foil _- 4ii9 Ads am -sip ;: a • _ 7Gritlf ��� ]r _ i. ra a N an 11 lr11n C- ` air— I Li r � i� wC lill�iY � / • wrrr G Y� r a t '•' �.=.Id oa .ra •rye ru ..w<. 1� R � ar s.r ty '.ni �� /'�:'3'- J °�" '. �.E �, i !!!!A1■R 11O�r" � l ire ar +� i7wGi i r.; !�► � -6 .���iE��l !R�♦ /� IOUG� - - iGrfw►. <iil►�� Qty � �'� � t .-+�, i r!liitiitlri tiG � ° � v rot•Kati w rr ��nv���' � - -+M \ . w P� � _ r riirrrllei+�Uliliraw►.rf�t.,au..+ •.. wr aw ww ■rwe�sa - •- ;y '* lirini�i:ru l i/ r,,.ei,ni:..r o Arai sb s�OEM rrie►q�= "� sriiEr! ! I°1 ',: �rrrr+�2�ar�irl�rri •h,.. tC�'• r i ur~� a� riOE�iR��• y- !� nrAlIEElEE�a:� rer ■ q IS 'S Orion 7�=i ��7 .itla Rat ...rJl i a c V w �---� : r wa sy r.,N ♦ `aw ♦ u • v tErrll��E1�E1a�11 >• i re. •. ��' ,lss cra i+�wi ♦ v rrT� .., ® lr�Ei�: aiAiai�. '.eun3�.� r wr .. r. .a :t♦ v 4 �'r ` cr °`�I,.;.�ild lrl�r�� »9ii�! •i�..s.r ailiaiisr 7i.irlai/ w ti,ss a+r +. a sue..♦♦�®�,r : + YiiC iiil�J!!i Cx Ua �Y MEMORANDUM DATE: January 20, 2011 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Jeffrey B. Adams, Associate Planner SUBJECT: Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map (MF# CPA 10-004) Beacon Development, the developer of two multi-family Housing developments within Pasco (Tepecyac Haven on 22nd Ave. & Bishop Topel Haven on Wehe Ave.), has submitted an application for a Comprehensive Plan land use map amendment. The amendment involves changing the land use designation for slightly more than two blocks of land south of Highland Park from Low-Density Residential to Mix-Density Residential. Tepecyac Haven has 45 units on 3.05 acres, or slightly over 14 units per acre; Bishop Topel Haven has 43 units on approximately 3.5 acres, or nearly 13 units per acre; the proposed development will have approximately 60 units on a 3.2-acre parcel, calculated to be over 18 units per acre. The applicant is in the process of planning this third Housing complex and has submitted the Comprehensive Plan Amendment application on behalf of the property owner (three additional properties where included in the proposal by staff to create a more uniform boundary for the proposed land use designation in the event the proposal is recommended for approval). The site is located east of California Avenue, west of Charles Avenue, north of Clark Street, and south of Highland Park. It is currently zoned R-1 and is identified on the Comprehensive Plan map as a location for future low-density residential development. Most of the land encompassed by this request is vacant and undeveloped. The six lots at the northwest corner of Charles Avenue between George Street and Clark Street are zoned C-1 (Retail Business). These six lots, plus some additional lots to the north, were used in the past for an automotive repair shop and storage facility. The vacant shop building is still located on the property. The only other building on the subject property is a house located at 209 N. Franklin Avenue. Properties surrounding the site to the west have commercial land use designation and are zoned C-3 (General Business) and properties to the east and north are designated for low-density development and are zoned R-1 (Lozv- Density Residential). In 2007 and 2008 La Clinica Self-Help Housing assisted with construction of seven self-help homes in the 300 Block of Charles Ave. Many of the existing homes in the surrounding blocks were constructed in the 1950's and 1960's. Other changing conditions in the immediate neighborhood include an expansion to Highland Park and the construction of the Bishop Topel housing complex north of Whittier School. The Bishop Topel complex was constructed on a site that was rezoned R-3 (Medium Density Residential) following a Comprehensive Plan amendment in 2008 that designated a band between Whittier School and James Street for Mixed Residential uses. The following Comprehensive Plan goals and policies are applicable to this proposal: Goal LU--1 ("Improve the community's quality of rife") and Policy LU-I-B ("Enhance the physical appearance of development ruithin the community") xuill be applied by this proposed project as the oruner- has a track record of using high quality bu ilding ma teria Is, co lor- va ria do ns xuithin the project, a rid a ttractive landscaping. The goal LU 2 ("Maintain established neighborhoods and ensure new neighborhoods are safe and enjoyable") xuill be supported xuith this proposed amendment by creating a buffer- between low-density residential areas to the east and general commercial zones to the ruest, and by establishing a nice "enjoyable," high-density housing complex. Policy LU--2-A (" . . . encourage the individual identities of neighborhoods.") ruill be reinforced by building more mixed residential units similar- to the existing Bishop Topel Haven property to the north. Policy LU--2-D ("Require all development to be landscaped") quill be maintained as the developer- ruill be required to landscape the project according to City regulations. Goal LU--3 ("Strive for long term reduction of energy consumption") ruill be supported as the applicant proposes a project similar- to that of the existing Tepeyac Maven property, which met Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) gold standards, and the Bishop Topel Haven property, which is expected to receive LEED certficadon. Policies LII 3-A, (Reduce vehicular- movement . "), B (Encourage infill and density including planned unit Developments"), and E ("Designate areas for higher- density residential development where utilities and transportation facilities enable efficient use of capital resources.") xuill be met as the applicant locates a high-occupancy residential infill project close to schools, shopping, and transportation. Goal H-1 ("Encourage housing for all economic segments of the city's population") xuill be supported by alloxubV a land use designation and zoning which support the proposed low-income housing project. Policies H-1-A ("Medium and high density housing should be located near- arterials and neighborhood or community shopping facilities and employment areas") and H-1-B ("Encourage the location of medium and high density housing in locations 2 that xuill avoid the need for access through lower- density residential neighborhoods") xuill be partially supported as the main access for the proposed project xuill be near- both Oregon Avenue and East Lexuis Street, and near- commercially zoned areas which could support more community shopping facilities and employment opportunities. Policy H-1-C ("Support dispersal of special needs housing throughout the community") and H-1-D ("Avoid large concentrations of high-density housing") ruould not be supported since the development ruould concentrate more low-income population density near- another high-density, low-income project. Goal H-2 ("Strive to maintain a variety of housing consistent zuith the local and regional market") ruould be partially met, since there ruill alruays be a demand for loxuer=income housing units, but the "variety"for- this area ruould be limited to loru- income occupants, thus maintaining an "East-Pasco/west-Pasco income imbalance. Policy H-2-A (Alloxu for a full range of residential environments including single family homes, torunhouses, condominiums, apartments, and manufactured housing") ruould be supported, albeit focused on low-income residents only. Goal H-4 ("Encourage housing design and construction that ensures long term sustainability and value") ruould be met because of the aforementioned LEES design standards. Goal H-5 ("Support efforts to provide affordable housing to meet the needs of loxu and moderate income households in the community.") xuould be generally supported, as the proposed units are to house low-income residents. However- Policy H-5-C ("The city shall tuo rk ruith public and private sector- developers to ensure that lower- income housing is developed on scattered sites") ruould not be supported, as the complex ruill be ruithin a block of another high-density, loru- income complex, all of which xuould be located xuithin a low-income area. Analysis The site in question is located at the edge of an area designated by the Comprehensive Plan for Low-Density Residential land use. The site borders a parks/open space strip to the west and a park to the north, with commercial to the west. Best planning practices call for a separation of commercial uses from low-density residential uses. This is typically done with "buffer" areas consisting of higher density uses and open spaces. This amendment proposes to designate the specific area noted as Mixed Residential. The proposed Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map amendment is designed to allow the applicant to develop high-density low-income housing between general commercial and low-density residential Land Use designations. The proposed development would generally be in harmony with the intent of the Land Use and Housing goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, with a caveat that the proposal will not encourage lower income housing to be developed on "scattered sites" throughout the City. The applicant's proposal has the following 3 characteristics: 1) it will be located near arterials, some shopping and employment opportunities, with potential for more commercial development nearby; 2) main access to the site will be through commercial zones and not through low-density residential areas; 3) low-cost housing will allow residents to better afford support services and possibly save for future home ownership; 4) housing types will be diversified from the single-family homes and manufactured/mobile homes typical to the area, albeit within a limited price range; 5) judging from two similar projects by the same developer, the construction and materials of the proposed development will be appealing; 6) based on the two prior projects by the same developer, the proposed development will most likely be far more energy efficient than the surrounding single-family development. In sum, most of the points listed are supportive of the Comprehensive Plan amendment, although this particular development proposal would not disperse low-income housing evenly throughout the community. However, neither the proposed Land Use designation nor a high-density rezone in and of itself would guarantee any particular development or income level for the site. The Planning Commission will need to determine if the Beacon Development proposal materially alters the general intent of the Comprehensive Plan and whether or not it can be supported by the recommended goals and policies. The attached material provided by Beacon Development provides a further explanation of the various goals and policies that impact the proposed land use modification (See Exhibit 1). Findings of Fact The following are initial findings drawn from the background and analysis section of the staff report. The Planning Commission may add additional findings to this listing as the result of factual testimony and evidence submitted during the public hearing. 1. The site was originally platted in the 1880's 2. Four houses were built on the site and one remains. 3. An automotive repair shop and storage yard occupied approximately three-quarters of the east half of Block 2 of Charles Avenue. 4. The site is zoned both R-1 (Low -Density Residential) and C-1(Retail Business). 5. Properties directly to the west are zoned C-3 (General Business). 6. Properties to the south are zoned C-1 (Retail Business). 7. Properties to the east are zoned R-1 (Low-Density Residential) 8. The Housing Authority duplexes located on Wehe Avenue half a block east of the site are zoned R-2 (Medium-Density Residential) 9. The site is currently identified for a low-density development on the Comprehensive Plan Land Use map. 10. Highland Park is located directly to the north. 11. The Comprehensive Plan was amended in 2008 to include a mixed- use buffer area between the low-density areas north of Whittier School and the commercial land uses to the west. 12. A Mix-Density Residential Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation permits future rezones for multi-family development. 13. The site is one block north of Lewis Street. 14. Access from the south is through commercially zoned areas. Conclusions The site is currently located in a transition area between a low-density area and a commercial area. Changing the land use classification of the site to mixed residential is consistent with accepted planning practices and will provide a buffer between the low density to the east the commercial area to the west. Recommendation MOTION for Findings of Fact: I move to adopt the findings of fact and conclusions as contained in the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map MF# CPA 10-004 Staff Memo dated January 20, 2010. MOTION for Recommendation: I move, based on the findings of fact and conclusions therefrom, that the Planning Commission recommend the City Council approve a Comprehensive Plan Amendment under Master File # CPA 10-004. 5 E:XI--I€6IT #1 Contact: Beacon Development Group on behalf of Catholic Housing Services of Eastern Washington Contact's Address: Beacon Development Group 1 1221 East Pike Street, Suite 300/Seattle.WA 93122 Contact's Phone Numbers: Paul Purcell 206-360-2491,ext.206, 206-473-1153 Brian Lloyd 206-360-2491,ext.210 206-390-:1049 Aidan Poile 206-360-2491,ext.211 40-4-245-6716 Legal Description: MdrebouseAddirion all of Block 3. W drebouseAddirion. Lots 1 1 to 17.S ions 15-24 wirli 10'vacared. See attached site near. 1.Proposed Comprehensive Plan amendment: Tlii.s proposed arnendrnenr concerns rile Land Use Designations in rile Coniprelzensive Plan,{or rile areas noted in legal description below and.shown on rile arraclied neap (generally rile area South o{E. Adelia Sr. and Nor•rll E. George Sr. between N. Franklin Ave and Cliar•les Sr. and rile area Sourli o{E. George Sr. and Norriz o{E.A/vina Sr. West o{ Cliarles Sr and rile niid-blk-)ck allev). As .shown in rile plan rile area is designated for Low-Densiry Residential land use. Tlii.s amendment proposes to designate die.specific area noted is Alixed Residential. 2.How will the proposed amendment advance and support the policies and goals of the Comprehensive Plan? Tlie Conipreliensive Pkin identifies 7 Elements, all parr of rile Stare's Growrli Alanagernenr Ala Ware. T11 proposed arnendrnenr,its within these Elements and advances and.supports .sreciff c policies and goals of the Conipreliensive Plan in rile{ollowing manner: Land Use Element: While this proposed amendment addresses general kind use patterns and designations, it is worth noting that rile applicant and its client, Carbolic Housing Services o{Eastern Washington, have developed two orlier properties in rile City o{Pas co - Tercvac Haven and Bishop Topel Haven. Tlii.s arnendrnenr would allow ,for rile developrnenro{another project seeking to house Pasco's work{orce. Tile goal(LU-1)andpolicv(LU-1-B)o{ increasing rile giialiry of life within Pasco will be rner by this proposed project as rile owner bas as a priority, rile enliancernenr o{ rile cornrnuniry with high givaliry building materials, color variations within rile project, and attractive Landscaping. Tbegoal(LU-2)o{rnainraining esrablislied neigliborizoods and ensuring new neigliborizood s are sa fe and enjoyable will be mer with this proposed amendment. A Mixed Residential area would provide a transition lone between rile -C-1 and C-3 areas to rile West o{rile .subject area and R-1 areas to rile east o{.subject area. Additionally it rein{orces rile Mired Residential area to rile North o{Whittier Elernenrar;v, rile location o{rile applicant and client's Bishop Torel Haven property. This use rein{orces rile identity at rile existing and new neigliborbood, aligning with policv LU-2-,A.As noted previously, rile arrlicanr's,{ocus an lzigli qualiry landscaping.surror•rs policy LU-2-D. Tile goal (LU-3) o{ reducing long-term energy consurriprion and creating cornrnuniry health will fit with this proposed amendment. Tile applicant proposes a project .similar to that o{rile eri.sring Tepcvac Haven property, wliicli mer LEED goki .standards, and rile Bishop Torel Haven property, wliicli is expected to receive LEER certi fication. Policies LU-3-A, B, and E will be mer with this arnendrnenr. Tlie result will be on inf,11 devek-?rmenr and an area o{liiglier density residential use close to.scbools and transportation. Housing Element: As .stared, rile applicant is .seeking a general land use amendment. Specifically, rile applicant is proposing rlii.s amendment for rile purpose o{devek--+ring q(fordable housing. Tlii.s is applicable to rile proposal in Mat Pasco and rile Counrryw•ide Planning Policies acknowledge rile need,{or a-Irdable hoicsing in rile area and encourage rile construction o{a-Irdable hoicsing, "...particularly,{or k?w• and moderate income .segments o rile Population." Tile City endeawn-s to encourage housing,{or all economic.segments o{rile population (H-1), .strives to maintain a variery o{hoicsing consistent with rile kcal and regu-+na1 marker(H-?), encourages lioicsing design and construction Mat ensure long-term.susrainabiliry and value(H-1), and.supports efforts to provide a fordable hoicsing to meet rile needs q k:lw-and mid-income households in rile area(H-S). Many of die.specific policies.supporting these goals will be vier by a project.sucli as that proposed by rile applicant. In .sum, a change to rile Camp Plan will ally?w rile applicant to devek?P a project that is k?cared near arterials, coininuniry fiaciliries, and eniplo?vnienr areas (H-LA). Tile locaru-+n is.sucli that access will not be rlirougli rile lower density areas to rile.south and east o{rile site(H-1-B)but rather via rile coniniercially designated and public areas. As with rile applicant's previoics developments, rile a-Irdabiliry to renters will allow ,{or .savings and .surporr .services,{or residents, encouraging eventual home ownership Porenrial,{iom rile Population (H-1-E). The creation o{ a liiglier densit y project in this area will encourage diversity in housing types in rile area (H-?-.A)wliileproviding character and variery (H-4-A). As with rile Terevac Haven and Bishop Topel Haven properties, rile proposed development will be o{aPPe.7ling giialiry (H-S-A) and k?cared .sucli that it blends in wirli rile neigliborhood, not creating a monotonous Landscape�?{stereotypical q fordable hoicsing(H-S-C). Capital Facilities, Utilities, and Transr%?rrarion Elements: While this amendment is nor.specific to these elements, it is worth noting that proposed amendment and project itself reinforce rile goals and policies within rile ConiPreliensive Plan. Namely, rile area is well .served wirli existing utilities and rransporraru-?n. Tile City andlor developer would be able to capitalize on existing.services by making this a Mixed Residential area. 4.How will the proposed amendment advance the health, safety and general welfare of the community? Manv o{rile benefits o{rlii.s amendment are.srared above and align perfectly wirli rile City's ConiPreliensive Plan.As .such, rile welfare of rile coininuniry a.s,forecast in rlii.s Plan and Proposed in rlii.s specific amendmenr,ir hand-in- hand. Tile creation o{an area o{Mixed Residential.serves to reinforce rile Mixed Residential area to rile Norrh o{ Whinier ElenienrarY and acts as a transition between liiglzer and lower intensity land use types in area. In.sum, rile k7nd use patterns envi.su+ned by rlle Ciry{a1cyr and encourage rile type ?{development proposed by rlle aPp[icanrarnd .souglir in rlii.s application. Tile examples q{TePevac Haven and Bishop Topel Haven make rile best case fiar liow rlii.s proposal will advance rile Health, .sef{ery and general welfare of rile community. TePevac (again -a .similar project is envisioned by rile applicant if allowed under rile Camp Pk7n) ha.s been well received by rile Pasco community with a.significant wait list (hundreds o{families), a clean and gw7liry appearance, a fordable hoicsing In an area that needs Ir,{or its burgeoning workforce population, and a neigliborhood anchor in what was an area in transition. Tile local police mini-station lia.s told rile owner of rile significant change in rile area .since Tergac'.s development. While.still under construction, we expect rile .some response and .success ,{iom rile Bi.slioP Topel Haven property. We envision acceptance o{this Camp Pkin proposal will allow,{or creation o{anorlier development that will bene r rile Pasco community. • Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Vc*n'tY i Appli can Beacon Development N Map File # : CPA 10-004 . , - RRQA BLVD _ OWL WNf y -moo I �# t � f '10 SITE :h:. ., GEORGE ST a. w a d ui s 17' A 7 itual. I. � 'Y v• f�t �- o o his kt k WES - �-�_ � � c�� �� r is ��•� P Land Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Use Applicant Beacon Development Map File CPA 10-004 Mi� ■ � � r rte, � � Land Item: Comprehensive Plan Amendment Use Applicant Beacon Development Map File CPA 10-004 • .._ .- REPORT TO PLANNING COMMISSION MASTER FILE NO: Z 10-004 APPLICANT: Howard Rowell HEARING DATE: 1/20/2011 4709 Hilltop Drive ACTION DATE: 2/17/2011 Pasco, WA 99301 BACKGROUND REQUEST: REZONE: Rezone four parcels from RT (Residential Transition) to C-1 (Retail Business) 1. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Legal: Blocks 9 & 19, Washington Addition General Location: Northeast corner of"A" Street and Heritage Boulevard Property Size: 243,600 square feet or 5.6 acres 2. ACCESS: The property has access from "A" Street, and Heritage Boulevard. 3. UTILITIES: All municipal utilities currently serve the site. 4. LAND USE AND ZONING: The subject property is currently zoned RT (Residential Transition) and contains a single-family residence with accessory structures which the property owner has slated for demolition. Surrounding properties are zoned and developed as follows: NORTH- R-1-A - Vacant SOUTH- I-1 - Vacant EAST- RT - Vacant lots/residential dwellings WEST- C-1 & R-1-A - Vacant lots/residential dwellings 5. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The Plan designates this site for Mixed Residential/Commercial uses. The proposed zone change would allow uses that would be consistent with the Plan. 6. ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION: The City of Pasco is the lead agency for this project. Based on the SEPA checklist, the adopted City Comprehensive Plan, city development regulations, and other information, a threshold determination resulting in a Determination of Non-Significance (DNS) has been issued for this project under WAC 197- 11-158. 1 ANALYSIS The site is comprised of four adjacent parcels totaling approximately 5.6 acres located at the northeast corner of Heritage Boulevard and "A" Street. Platted rights-of-way and alleys currently divide the site into ten (10) pieces. The total area used in this report assumes rights-of-way and alleys will be vacated prior to site development. The applicant, Howard Rowell, has applied to rezone the property from RT (Residential Transition) to C-1 (Retail Business) in order to develop the site with commercial business(es). The RT zone is commonly described as a "holding zone" and is assigned to lands for which municipal sewer and water services are unavailable. Once municipal sewer and water services become available, the zoning is converted, via application, to a zoning designation most consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Establishing C-1 zoning on the site would appear, on the zoning map, as a continuation of the existing C-1 zoning along "A" Street to the west. Developing the site with regularly permitted retail businesses would serve as a physical buffer between the residences to the north and the industrially zoned land to the south. Examples of permitted uses in the C-1 zone are: restaurants, banks, retail sales and service stores, hotels and motels, etc. The initial review criteria for considering a rezone application are explained in PMC. 25.88.030. The criteria are listed below as follows: 1. The date the existing zone became effective: The current zoning classification ruas established when the property ruas annexed in 1994. 2. The changed conditions, which are alleged to warrant other or additional zoning: The Tentage Boulevard connection xuith "A" Street ruas completed in 2007 along xuith utility extensions that ruere part of the Sunrise Estates development to the rues t. The large tracts of Sunrise Estates fronting "A" Street to the rues t ruere rezoned from R-T to C-1 in 2005. "A" Street ruas improved to arterial street standards in 2010. The "A" Street improvements also included installation of ruater- and server- lines along the frontage of the subjectproperty. In addition to the recent infrastructure improvements near- the site, the City, Port and property oxuner- have been ruorking together- in an effort to establish the Heritage Industrial Center- along the south side of "A" Street directly south of the subject property. Similarly, the Tierra Vida development to the east involved a rezone to C-1 for those properties fronting "A" Street. 3. Facts to justify the change on the basis of advancing the public health, safety and general welfare: Recent development of the Tierra Vida and Sunrise Estates residential subdivisions directly to the east and xuest of the site has presented the opportunity to sustain some general retail businesses. Both Tierra Vida and Sunrise Estates are similarly configured xuith commercially zoned lots along "A" Street and residences to the north. Approval of this application ruould create consistency along "A" Street between the tuo subdivisions; thereby advancing the general welfare of the community. Additionally, rezoning the site to C-1 ruill alloxu the establishment of a less intense buffer- area between the industrially zo ned Heritage Indu s tria l Center- to the sou th a nd fu to re u ses to the no r-th. 4. The effect it will have on the value and character of the adjacent property and the Comprehensive Plan: The proposal is supported by the land use designation of the Comprehensive Elan. Rezoning the property to C-1 xuill create a buffer- between the more intense industrial area to the south and less intense future uses to the north. S. The effect on the property owner or owners if the request is not granted: The property owner- purchased the property based on the Compressive Plan designation which suggests commercial uses could be developed on the property. Developing the property under- the RT zone is not cost effective and is inconsistent xuith the Comprehensive Plan. 6. The Comprehensive Plan land use designation for the property: The Comprehensive Plan shorus the site to be designated for Mixed Residential/Commercial uses. The Mixed Residential/Commercial Land Use Designation permits rezones to residential (RS-20, RS-12, R-S-1 and R-1 thru R-3) and/or-commercial (C-1 and "O"). STAFF INITIAL FINDINGS OF FACT Findings of fact must be entered from the record. The following are initial findings drawn from the background and analysis section of the staff report. The Planning Commission may add findings to this listing as the result of factual testimony and evidence submitted during the open record hearing. 1) The site is within the Urban Growth Boundary. 3 2) The site is comprised of four parcels. 3) The Comprehensive plan designates the site for Mixed Residential/ Commercial uses. 4) The site is zoned RT (Residential Transition). 5) The site is approximately 243,600 square feet or 5.6 acres. 6) The site is located in the Washington Addition which was platted approximately 100 years ago. 7) The Washington Addition has never been improved with street and utilities and is largely undeveloped 3) The site is located at the intersection of"A" Street and Heritage Boulevard. 9) "A" Street and Heritage Boulevard are major streets. 10) The Comprehensive Plan (LU-4-A) encourages the development of commercial land uses near the intersections of major streets. 11) Property owners along East "A" Street participated in support of recent utility extensions and street improvements through an LID. 12) Properties to the east and west along the north side of East "A" Street have been rezoned to C-1 within the last 5 (Sunrise Estates) to 7 (Tierra Vida) years. 13) The site contains a single family residence and accessory structures. The property owner has been issued a demolition permit and is in the process of removing all structures and debris from the site. 14) The property to the south is zoned I-1. 15) The City, property owner and Port of Pasco are working jointly to establish the Heritage Industrial Center on the south side of East A" Street. CONCLUSIONS BASED ON INITIAL STAFF FINDINGS OF FACT Befor-e_ recommending approval or denial of a rezone, the Planning Commission must develop its conclusions from the findings of fact based upon the criteria listed in P.M.C. 25.88.060 and determine whether-or not. (1) The proposal is in accordance with the goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan. The Comprehensive Plan designates this site for Mixed Residential/Commercial uses. The Comprehensive Plan (policy ED-2-A) encourages a ruide range of commercial uses strategically located to support local and regional needs. Policy LU--4-A encourages the location of commercial businesses at major- street intersections. The site is located at the intersection of a minor- arterial and a major- collector- which qualifies the site to be supported by Policy LU-4-A. The proposed rezone is supported by both the goals and land use map of the Comprehensive Plan. 4 (2) The effect of the proposal on the immediate vicinity will not be materially detrimental. The proposal should have a positive effect on the neighborhood by providing a retail services area for nearby residential neighborhoods and by providing a buffer- between future industrial development to the south and future development to the north. The C-1 zone is designed to include uses based on their- compatibility ruith potentially nearby residences. The proposal has potential to foster- development of the neighborhood and to provide needed services. It is unlikely the proposal ruill be a detriment to the community. (3) There is merit and value in the proposal for the community as a whole. Rezoning the site to C-1 xuill aHow greater- ease for utilization of the site under its current condition considering the surrounding uses. Retail businesses located in close proximity to residential neighborhoods have the potential to offer- needed goods and services. There is merit and value because the proposal supports the Comprehensive plan and provides a buffer- between industrial and residential uses. (4) Conditions should be imposed in order to mitigate any significant adverse impacts from the proposal. The site is at the intersection of two major- streets and rezoning to C-1 is consistent xuith the Comprehensive plan. The proposal may lead to opportunities for the development of needed neighborhood services and it tuill assist xuith the creation of a transition buffer- between industrial activities to the south. As a resu It there is no need far- conditions. (5) A concomitant agreement should be entered into between the City and the petitioner, and if so, the terms and conditions of such an agreement. A concomitant agreement is not needed in conjunction with this application. RECOMMENDATION MOTION: I move to close the hearing on the proposed rezone and initiate deliberations and schedule adoption of findings of fact, conclusions and a recommendation to the City Council for the February 17, 2011 meeting 5 Vicinity Item: Rezone (RT to C- 1 ) Map File # iii 4 —----- " :CUSTER Wit Cn • w U. do � ■ D ,r i\lam .0 . ..- 'A S ,` y i O � • � logo's IN AN Vacant Vacant Vacant O � I i ON IN MIN I IN 1 ( Light Industrial) Administrative & Community Service Department January 20,2011 Memorandum To: Planning Commission Members From: RickTerway, DirectorA&CS Subject: Parks and Recreation Comprehensive Plan Once again, it is time to update the Park and Recreation comprehensive plan. The plan was last updated in 2005. The following is a brief overview of the plan: Purpose of plan The purpose of the comprehensive parks and recreation plan is to help the City of Pasco invest in its parks and recreation system wisely, providing new facilities and designing its range of programs to meet the community's needs overtime. The planning process and plan structure are also designed to meet the requirements of Washington State's Recreation and Conservation Office, sponsor of a multitude of parks and recreation grant programs. By having a plan that is no more than six years old and by following RCO's process and content requirements, Pasco remains eligible to compete for and receive RCO grant funds. This current draft plan updates the one adopted in 2005. That earlier plan is arranged slightly different than this one, primarily because it was also designed to keep the City eligible for Urban Park and Recreation Recovery(U PARR) grants. That program has since been abandoned by the federal government, so this current plan is designed completely around RCO guidelines. The City of Pasco hired Studio Cascade late this summer to update the plan and produce a draft by year's end. The process since its beginning included a range of parks and recreation stakeholders, an inventory and analysis of existing facilities and programs, an assessment of anticipated community demand and a comprehensive update of the 2005 plan. The City also developed and administered a parks and recreation questionnaire, seeking community comment on Pasco's parks facilities and recreation programs. Pasco's Parks and Recreation Advisory Council also participated in the process, meeting first in August to review and adjust the community's parks and recreation vision and then again in December to review the draft plan and suggest revisions priorto production of the final draft. Su rvey The questionnaire distributed as part of this process was not intended to provide a statistically valid picture of the community's parks and recreation needs, desires and demand. Even so, it produced some interesting results. The City distributed the questionnaire by mail to a randomized selection of its residential utility customers. In all,the City mailed more than 1400 questionnaires. Fifty were returned, demonstrating a 3.5% return rate. In reviewing all responses, it is clear that the results reflect the respondent age distribution. More than one-half of the questionnaire's returned were from individuals older than 45. Preferences for facilities and programs tended toward the senior center,the baseball stadium and walking and trail facilities. When the responses are disaggregated by respondent age, however,the results get more interesting. The different age groups appear to preferdifferent types of facilities. But the popularity of some facilities transcend age differences. Memorial Park, Chiawana Park and the baseball stadium were identified by all age groups as favorite facilities. Older respondents also identified Cable Bridge Park,the Senior Center and the MLK Center as important places. When asked which types of facilities they would most agree to fund through additional tax, respondents identified an aquatic center across all age groups. Younger respondents would also choose to fund improvements to existing or the development of new sports facilities,while older respondents would also choose to fund hiking and walking trails. The questionnaire asked respondents to identify if they lived east or west of Highway 395. Responses were generally similar between the two groups, but those east of 395 tended to learn about Pasco's recreation programs through word of mouth more than did residents west of 395. Plan update This plan update makes some policy changes that will impact how the City goes about its parks and recreation planning. The plan proposes changing the minimum neighborhood park size from five acres to something that can be as small as 2.5 acres, provided it is well designed and establishes a unique neighborhood identity while providing usable recreation space. Another policy shift indicates that the City's recreation programs may operate at a profit, particularly if the programs are popular and offering services at market prices. The plan's policies also are strengthened to ensure that recreation programs are located and scheduled to meet the community's ability to access them. While the aggregate level of programming may appear adequate to serve community need, potential participants may be excluded because the programs are too distant or are scheduled at inappropriate times. The updated plan provides suggested guidelines for levels of service. Where the previous plan asserted that these level of service indicators were"standards,"this plan terms them as"guidelines," acknowledging that measurements for particular types of facilities, at a facilities to population ratio, may not always be appropriate. Community demand patterns change over time. The guidelines included in this plan draft, however, will be the subject of future study. These are now intended as statements of scale, but they will most likely need to be adjusted as the City reviews and modifies its park impact fee ordinance. Trends shaping the adopted levels of service when they were created in the late 1990's have changed, and the park impact fee ordinance—and the levels of service guidelines—will need to be revised, as well. The plan suggests that the City prioritize several new parks and recreation facilities, consistent with the results of the questionnaire, changes in community demographics and the need to provide another community park. New soccer fields are essential. Population growth to the west and north make it imperative that a new community park be constructed there, and the community desires increased river access. At least these three facilities needs will take priority over the coming years, and the plan's implementation chapter includes them in the proposed capital improvements list. Facilities Inventory The plan includes an inventory of each parkfacility, noting what opportunities are available at each site. Each facility inventory also includes some suggested improvements to each location. The suggested improvements are not prioritized and are only to be used as a guide, with the understanding that the needs of each facility may change over time. What's Next The City Council will consider the parks and recreation plan in January,taking action based on recommendations from the Parks and Recreation Advisory Council and Planning Commission. Once the plan is adopted, Pasco will remain eligible for grants through RCO. Draft Parks and Recreation Plan for the Litt Pasco Y of '-J R S . vivo y Revisions Corrections to draft plan Location Comment Action Varicos "Parks"not always clear to include other facilities,too 4.5 Low questionnaire response-riot bilingual 5.8 "Recreation Services"as heading title 5.8 Access to recreation programs-distance and time Various Page numbering Figure 5.x Park inventory map Figure 6.x New facilities map Table 6.02 Add impact fee study and community park visioning Figure 6.03 Westside community park symbol Appendix A Miscellaneous facility corrections p. 5.7 Aquatics facility drawirg p. 2.2 Regional planning area location map Summary Acknowledgements 70C Table of contents,tables&figures P. 3.4 Criteria for sizing and locating neighborhood parks p. 5.6 County to set aside parkland to help with total need p. 6.2 Identify point agreement with school district Cr 5 Include demand radii for neighborhood parks Ch 4 questionnaire response graphics, aggregate and by category ,r Summary Purpose and Intent This plan establishes policies for park and recreation services, and it identifies parks and recreation facility needs for the City of Pasco. It also updates the 2005 �- Comprehensive Park and Recreation Plan p and strives to balance community needs :• �- with the financial realities of the City's parks 00o- and recreational program. By making the plan sensitive to Pasco's current conditions Figure 1.01-Pasco''sparKsa?drecreaticn system isdiverse. and needs, the plan helps position the City and it has tot+eto meet thede mandsoF i's diverse co,nmunrty. This pian presents a deiiberate and measured approach to to win grant funds for park improvements providing For parks and recreat'n,services, (Image source; and to target capital and operational studio Cascade,Inc.) spending more strategically. Public Involvement demographics Pasco has experienced rapid growth over Public participation in plan development is the last six years growing from 40,840 to both crucial to plan success and required 56,300, an increase of more than 37 0l0. by the State of Washington. Pasco sought Pasco's population is diverse and trends out public participation as part of this plan toward younger with 36% of the population update by conducting focused interviews being under age 20. Pasco projects the with representatives of parks and recreation continuation of rapid growth adding over user groups, by working very closely with 37,000 people over the next 20 years for a its Parks and Recreation Advisory Council total population of 93,663 residents in 2030 and by designing and administering a citizen questionnaire examining parks and recreation needs and desires. Responses Vision, Goals, and to the parks questionnaire helped the City identify and prioritize specific park system Objectives improvements and operational policies. New to the 2010 update is a vision for the Pasco parks and recreation system. The vision presents a snapshot of what Pasco's parks and recreation system will be 20 parks and Recreation years from now. The vision also underpins the plan's goals, objectives, and policies. Demand and Issues The goals in the plan address Pasco's parks and recreational issues, deficiencies, needs and aspirations. Generally the goals This plan identifies Pasco's various parks propose: and recreation issues into physical, management, program and service, and • To provide physical facilities fora rehabilitation issue categories. Section variety of activities, 4 describes those issues in detail, • Maintain and rehabilitate existing emphasizing the need for rehabilitation and facilities, and maintenance of parks facilities as well as the need for acquiring and developing new sites • To operate a variety of programs to to serve a growing population. Table 4.01 meet the community's needs. lists the level of service (LOS) guidelines the Each goal is also attached to several City will use to assess how well its residents objectives that elaborate on and help are provided for, and Table 4.02 identifies quantify the goal statement, for example, the specific recreation deficiencies and the plan's objectives include: establishing a needs this plan is intended to address. neighborhood park system and other park facilities, continuing to provide organized recreation programs for all age groups, Park System Inventory and enacting a maintenance program that maximizes the service life of existing parks and Needs and recreation facilities. Parks and recreation has accounted for approximately 3.50/b of the City's Policies overall budget, funding the acquisition, development and maintenance of This plan's policies are designed to guide parks facilities, and the operation and the agency's day-to-day behavior in a vvay management of the City's recreational that ensures meeting the plan's objectives. programs. There are also neighboring If the policies are followed, the City will County and State parks in the urban growth achieve the objectives and satisfy the area that serve Pasco residents. Figure 5.01 overall parks and recreation goals. These locates the community's parks, and the text policies will: in that section describes the neighborhood parks, community parks, large urban parks, • Prioritize and guide investment regional parks, linear parks, trails, and • Prioritize and guide programming special use areas that serve Pasco. Table 5.03 provides a comprehensive list of park • Assist budgeting facilities, ranging from one-acre Peanuts • Create expectations Park to the 65-acre baseball, soccer and The policies are separated into categories softball athletic complex. matching the type of park developed in Pasco. There are policies for neighborhood Departmental and parks, community parks, large urban parks and so on, each one suggesting a Contracted Services direction the City take in the development or maintenance of that particular type of facility. Table 5.03 identifies the levels of use for each of the recreational services Pasco provides. Table 5.04 identifies the non- city organizations with which the City 2 Summary coordinates to ensure comprehensive ;�•} recreational activities are available to Pasco residents. Pasco's recreational services offer programs in aquatics, special events, _ =� adult and youth classes, adult and youth sports, senior classes and activities, and golf. The city also contracts with the YMCA and various non-profit youth athletic organizations like Pasco Youth Football to round out its program offerings. The Pasco Unified School District is another partner, collaborating with the City on the joint siting , s and use of various recreational facilities. Implementation Section 6 details the implementation strategy for the parks and recreation plan, outlining and identifying specific tasks the City can pursue in terms of its management, program offering, facility provision, citizen participation, and interagency coordination efforts. This section emphasizes the cooperative nature of providing comprehensive recreational Figure 1.02-The pldnis only as good as its innpiernentation, services, identifying specific administrative andthis plan includes a list of prioritized capital projects to actions the City can take, or continue to en sure the parks andrecreaticn system continuestomeetthe con'rnurity's needs. (Image source:studio cascade,Inc.] take, to ensure that its provision of services continues to attain the high levels of resident satisfaction even as the community continues to grow. Project Priorities Pasco has limited funds to expend on park Recommendations and recreation system improvements, so it needs to prioritize the various projects Table 6.01 and Figure 6.01 represent by relative importance. In some cases, recommendations for new park facilities, however, it is difficult to compare different and much of the text outlines specific types of protects to each other, resulting in project actions the City may consider an "apples vs. oranges" type of quandary. for each of its park facilities. The The prioritization section provides a process recommendations identify a variety of that helps to compare different protects improvements and renovations to existing based on six criteria. Table 6.02 and 6.03 park and recreation facilities and include present a prioritized list of capital projects. eight proposed nets parks and one new trail. The parks would constructed to Capital Improvement serve new residential development and/or increased community or regional demand plan for specialized recreational facilities. A capital improvement plan identifies the means and timing for making various investments in the acquisition, development City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 3 or improvement of parks and recreation facilities for the next six years. Table 6.03 summarizes the capital improvement plan, identifying the expense, timing and funding source for each project. Generally these projects are those that received the highest priority through the prioritizing process but may include projects whose grant funding cycle occur earlier than a higher scoring project. The section also recommends that the capital improvement plan be included in the comprehensive plan and be updated annually as projects are developed. 4 Summary i Setting 4' rl ' Purpose and Intent This plan establishes policies for park and recreation services, and it identifies parks and recreation facility needs for the ;'�� City of Pasco. It also updates the 2005 Comprehensive Park and Recreation Plan "'• and strives to balance community needs with the financial realities of the City's parks 4 and recreational program. By making the plan sensitive to Pasco's current conditions Figure 2.01-Pasc o's parks mventcry mixes the old and new, and needs, the plan helps position the City tvitn some facriides,n need ofrehabrirtabon to ensure they continue to meet the ccmmunity's needs. The iegacy or big trees to win grant funds for park improvements in old parks teshhestothecomm unity's consistent appreciahon and to target capital and operational britsopenspaces (Image source:Studio C3scade,lnc..) spending more strategically. This 20-year comprehensive parks plan is ■ Inventory the guide for future decisions related to the City of Pasco parks system and park ■ public involvement facilities. The Pasco Park and Recreation ■ Demand and need analysis Advisory Council uses the plan to advise ■ Capital Improvement program the City Council on matters of policy, programs, and projects for the development ■ Adoption and operation of City's park system. The This plan follows a process that uses parks plan must be updated at least every existing conditions and involves the six years to be eligible for Washington community to update the plan including State Recreation and Conservation Office population, facilities, and programs, while (RCO) funding, and this plan is prepared complying with RCO requirements. The consistent with Washington's Recreation and process includes: stakeholder interviews, Conservation Office's planning guidelines, policy review, public outreach, capital resulting in a parks and recreation plan programming, public review, and adoption. eligible to compete for grants managed by RCO. The City's park planning process incorporates the following six elements required by RCO: ■ Goals and oNectives Public Involvement and the railroad town of Ainsworth relocated to Pasco in 1886. Public participation in plan development is The cities of Pasco, Kennewick, and both crucial to plan success and required Richland remained relatively small until by the State of Washington. Pasco sought 1940, containing fewer than 1600 people. out public participation as part of this plan The1941 completion of the Grand Coulee update by conducting focused interviews Dam and the Columbia Basin Irrigation with representatives of parks and recreation Project brought a stable and prosperous user groups, by working very closely with agricultural industry to the area. Its vast its Parks and Recreation Advisory Council power and abundant river water also allowed and by designing and administering a citizen the siting of the Hanford atomic energy questionnaire of parks and recreation plant and the housing of the Manhattan needs and desires. The City mailed the Project. The U.S. government projects questionnaire to 1,320 randomly selected transformed the Tri-Cities, causing explosive households from the utility billing address growth during and after World War II. Their list with a return rate of approximately influence continues to impact the area. 3.5%. The questionnaire helps the City identify and prioritize specific park system Pasco is now an important center for several improvements and operational policies. transportation systems and a node for trade and agriculture. The questionnaire covered general preferences for facilities and programs, asked for specific facility use, and asked Study Area for which facilities users would be most willing to fund through tax dollars. The Pasco is the County Seat of Franklin County survey results indicate some mixed feelings and is one of three major cities that make about park facilities and services offered up southeast Washington's Tri-City Area. but overall the survey results indicate that The parks and recreation planning area park facilities are very important to the includes the area within the city limits of respondents. Questionnaire results are Pasco plus surrounding unincorporated discussed in Section 4. lands within the urban growth area (UGA). History Geography and Climate Pasco is located at the confluence of the The Cascade Mountain Range creates a rain Snake, Yakima, and Columbia Rivers, shadow of low precipitation extending into a historical meeting ground for Native the Pasco region. The dry climate produces Americans and early explorers. The area's about 7-6 inches of precipitation a year abundant fish and mild climate encouraged with half of this occurring in November, settlement. The Lewis and Clark expedition December, and January. Late June, July, camped at what is now Sacajawea State and August are very dry months and usually Park in 1805, and in the following years, receive less than a half-inch of rainfall. explorers, fur trappers, and miners settled Snowfall averages 12-16 inches for the the area. entire winter. The arrival of the Northern Pacific Railroad Winters are moderate with slight snowfall brought more settlers to the Washington and temperatures seldom below 0 degrees Territory and Pasco region. Virgil Bogue, a Fahrenheit. Summers are dry and warm construction engineer for Northern Pacific with extremely high temperatures (up Railroad, named Pasco after Cerro de to 115 Degrees Fahrenheit) occurring Pasco in the Andes Mountains of Peru after periodically. Afternoons are hot, but the dry building a railroad there. The county seat air results in a rapid temperature fall after 2 Setting sunset and the nights are cool with summer time lows in the 50's. Southwest winds are common to the area and can be quite strong in the spring, gusting from 18-30 miles per hour. Pasco lies approximately 340 feet above sea level and has a flat to gently rolling terrain. It slopes south toward the Columbia River through glacially created channels. The soil is a wind blown or lake bottom sediment with native sagebrush and bunch grass ]- creating a ground cover. The area to the north of the City steps up in benches to x { " elevations above 1600 feet. Demographics Population characteristics Since the 2005 update to this plan,the population has increased from 40,840 to 56,300, an Increase of more than 370/c (Table 2.01), Most of this growth has continued to develop in the northwestern quarter of Pasco. Pasco expects to add 37,663 people over Figure 2.02-The Tn-Cities'climate is consistent with a variety the 20-yea r plamvng horizon of this plan fora total of outdoor recreation activities. The new aquatic center at 93,663 living within the City of Pasco by 2030 Memorial Park is a big hit,with use far exceeding anticipated levels,(Image source:studio Cascade,Inc) In addition to rapid growth, Pasco is also a diverse community, with a population covering the social spectrum, According totheAmerican Community Population Projections Survey,forthose people claiming one race alone, Table 2.04 shows projections developed by the 55 percent are white; 2 percent are Black or African Washington State office of Financial Development American; 1 percent are American Indian and Alaska (0 FM)for Franklin County and resulting increases Native; 2 percent are Asian; less than 0.5 percent a re for the Pasco study area using the ratio from the Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander, and 38 2007 comprehensive plan. According to the 2007 percent are some other race Fifty-four percent of the people in Pasco Identified themselves as Hispanic. Forty percent of the people in Pasco are white non- Table 2.01 -Populabon trends Hispanic, (Table 2 02) People of Hispanic origin may be of any race. zoos 44,190 Generally, Pasco has a youngerthan average population when compared to othercommunities 21005 47,610 7.7 in Washington. Nearly 40 0/a of the population is between the ages of 20 and 44, over 31 of the 2007 51 53 population is u rid erthe age of 20. Elderly residents 2CC8 52,2910 4.1 age 65 and overcomprise about 6.74'0 of the population and 22.43'0 are underthe age of nine 2009 54,490 4.2 (Table 2 03) 21010 56,31010 3,3 Source; City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 3 Table 2.02- Race and ethnic origin 2000&2008 Economy Much of the land around Pasco was unused winite 15,919(52.8%) 28,169 (54.5%) before the Federal Columbia Basin Irrigation Project brought water from reservoirs American 1,033(3.29°) 939(1.9%} created b the Grand Coulee Dam. Today,Am arlcan Y Y, variety of crops, such as apples, asparagus, Asian 567 f,1.8°re} 835 (1.7°/6) alfalfa hay, beans, grapes, wheat, corn, Arnencan Incfian 248(0 Feb) 364(0,7%) cherries, onions, potatoes, and numerous seed crops are grown in the immediate area. Some other race 12,050(37.9°/0) 19,570(37.9%) Wheat is the most economically important of these crops, although the emergent wine 2 or more races 1,249(3.5°/0) 1,644(3 2°!°) industry has won international acclaim. Total 32,066 51,571 Pasco's economy is based on transportation Hispanic or Latino(of 18,041(56.3%) 23,037(54.4°16) and agricultural dependent industries. any race) Pasco functions as the regional distribution Not Hispanic or Latino 15,255(43 7°!°) 23,534(45,6°16) center for much of south central Washington white Alone 11,865 (37.0916) 20,832(40.5 0/6) because it is a meeting point and hub for major transportation systems (rail, air, and Source: ground transportation). Hanford is also a comprehensive plan forthe City of Pasco,the City Table 2.03 -.4 accommodates approximately 88% of all Franklin Age and gender distribution Cou my growth. Further,the plan states that Pasco expects to accommodate from 80%to 850/a of Franklin County's growth from 2006-2D30 Using the Age Number Percent Number Percent upper range of this percentage,the City will g row to Q-4 3,555 11.1% 6,313 12.2°!6 87,300 people by 2030. 5-9 3,319 10.41/c 5,264 10.214 10-14 2,849 819% 3,847 7.5% 15-19 2,791 8.79/0 3,592 709/0 20-24 2,656 8.3% 4,501 8.7% 25-34 5,009 15.60/6 9,604 19.00/6 35-44 4,122 12.9% 6,027 11.7% 45-54 3,134 918% 5,227 101% 55-59 1,023 3.2% 1,822 3.5% 60-64 BIB 2.6% 1,730 3.49/0 65-74 1,483 4.6% 1,913 3.7% 75+ 1,302 4.09/o 1,511 3.09/6 14a]e 16,550 26,661 F ern aIe 15,515 24,910 Sou rce: 4 Setting Table 2.04 - Populabon forecasts for Franklyn County and Pasco,%Urban Growth Area Low 57,323 64,742 72,582 79,853 85,402 92,010 Medium 50,500 69992 80,424 90,741 100,750 110,192 High 54,255 75,395 90,135 104,352 118,822 133,168 Low 48,725 55,031 61,695 67,875 73,442 78,209 Medium 51,425 59,493 58,350 .7 7,130 85,545 93,553 High 54,625 64,937 75,615 88,699 100,999 113,193 Scurce: major employer and brings visitors to the Management and area. Operations Land Use The Parks and Recreation planning area City Organization includes the area within Pasco's city limits plus surrounding unincorporated The City operates under the Council/ lands within the UGA. The UGA stretches Manager form of government. There are from the Columbia River on the south seven elected Council Members who appoint to a line that is generally parallel to and a City Manager to oversee the operations approximately 1/2 mile north of Sandifur of the City. Pasco's operation is organized, Parkway, and from Sacajawea State Park under the City Manager, through six on the east to the I-182 Bridge on the departments including: west. Approximately 25% of the area is for residential uses, 150% for commercial, a Executive 15% for industrial uses, and roughly a Administrative and Community 10% devoted for public uses. Some of Services Department (A&CS) the publicly owned property is used for industrial purposes (Port of Pasco land). a Community Development Some of the vacant property is farmed Department (leased by the Department of Natural a Fire Department Resources) and was included in undeveloped rather than the public use category. ■ Public Works/Engineering Department a Police Department Regularly scheduled interdepartmental meetings are held as a means of coordinating the various activities of the city government. The A&CS Department is usually involved in specific neighborhood targeted improvements. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 5 Parks and Recreation Two divisions within the A&CS Department are responsible for the development, maintenance, and operation of all recreation facilities within the city (Recreation Services for activities and programs and _ Facilities for maintenance and operations). Administrative personnel, recreation program leaders, and a small maintenance crew are full time employees. During the summer, seasonal employees are hired to assist with maintenance, recreation program rigure delivery, and swimming pool operations. bUdget ngc - ides requiredcisthance, an important Volunteers assist with various recreational budgeting ccnsideraticn...and cis that impacts design,as well. (Irragesource:Studio Cascade, Inc) programs and limited park maintenance. City employees conduct most recreation programs. The City Council makes final decisions regarding policy and fiscal matters. Several Budget advisory committees assist the City Council and staff. They include: The City operates on an annual budget • The Planning Commission: prepared in the fall and adopted before Composed of nine members who the first of the year. Departments prepare are chosen by the City Councii and and submit budgets based on City Manager Aiayordealing with matters affecting developed guidelines. Each departmental long range planning and policfes budget details estimated revenue and related to urban growth expenses for the past and upcoming • Senior Citizens Advisory Committee: operating year. The City Manager refines A nine-member committee these budgets and submits an overall appointed by the mayor and City city report to a budget committee. The Council responsibie for identifying budget is then forwarded to the Council needs of the senior populatfon where recommendations, review, and and offering recommendations for public meeting discussions are considered operating the Senior Center before final adoption. Park and recreation service financing comes from the City • Park and Recreation Advisory General Fund, from revenue generated by Council: Composed of seven recreation programs, and from state and members appointed by the Aiayor federal grants. Park and facility rentals and and City Councfl for identifyfng other miscellaneous sources create some recreation needs in the community, additional revenue. recommending poiicies related to park and recreation operations and reviewing proposals presented by the staff. In addition to park and indoor facilfties, they also deal wfth the city owned cemetery and golf course. 6 Setting Vision, Goals & Objectives Vision -` r This vision statement presents a snapshot of Pasco's parks and recreation system in the year 2030. It underpins this plan's goals, objectives and policies, implying a direction and specifying what Pasco hopes its parks and recreation system will be 20 years from now. The City of Pasco provides a comprehensive and 11111qure3.02-Taking the long view requires that Pasco plan accessible system of parks, recreation prog rams and for its parks facilities to adapt to utianges in de,nandand use. Ideally,raciVties wili serve multiple uses,as happens at Mergorial open spaces to serve all segments of its community. Park, (7magesource:Studio Cascade.Inc.) The system provides active and passive facilities, taking advantage of its environment and proximity to attractive naturaIfeatures. Its recreational programsareamongti,e state's best, uiithprogram General Priorities offerings responsive to community need and providing excellent value for dollars spent. Open spaces,whether conserved to preserve habitat or- Urban recreation services are vital In left indeveloped for other reasons, often provide community development and urban opportunities for trails, interpretive experiences revitalization. A successful parks and or other recreational outlets that enhance the recreation program brings the community community's connection to the outdoors, many assets and relates policy goals to identified issues. It helps to knit the This vision was generally confirmed by the community together and leads to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Council at provision of needed facilities and programs. its August 5, 2010 meeting and through responses to the community questionnaire, The City of Pasco develops plans to underscoring Pasco's desires to serve all of guide municipal services decisions. The Pasco's residents as well as practical given comprehensive plan and the Comprehensive budgetary and facilities constraints. Park and Recreation Plan recommend strategies for providing services in new neighborhoods and for upgrading service in older neighborhoods. There are also plans that address specific facilities or target specific neighborhoods. The plans are generally multi-scope in nature with the purpose of providing trail corridors, preserving proposals for revitalization of streets, riparian habitat and protecting the natural landscape. utility systems, sidewalks, parks and other facilities. Targeting Neighborhoods The City applies and receives HUD grants The plan identifies needs and recommends to upgrade neighborhoods located in low- park improvements for specific areas of the income areas. The development of park community. As revitalization efforts occurin specific and indoor recreation facilities is a part neighborhoods, park improvements will be part of of revitalization. The renovation and that overall revitalization effort. rejuvenation of park facilities brings new life to the surrounding neighborhoods and preserving Facilities of Historic or attracts families and other individuals pursuing recreation activities. This Architectural Significance neighborhood revitalization will continue. The plan notes that there are no parks or unique The City is focusing on several areas structures within parks of historical or architectural that directly impact parks and recreation significance and as a result, does not address this planning including: issue. Services to Specialized Encouraging Recreation Services Populations by Private Organizations Pasco currently provides park and recreation service The plan encourages private organizations to provide to special populations such as the disabled and recreation and related services in the community. persons with special needs. The Comprehensive Park Some methods to encourage private services include and Recreation Plan recognizes this need and places direct financial contributions for public services by special emphasis on upgrading the park systems in private entities, making facilities available on at no Pasco's neighborhoods. In addition, all park and cost for needed services, and developing shared recreation facilities will conform to the requirements Programs. of the Americans with Disabilities Act(ADA). Using Other Public Lands Park and Recreation Services The plan recommends new sites for park and The plan recommends park and facility improvements open space areas. Some of these sites are non- as well as programs. Upgrading and providing more recreational land owned by the City or another facilities will improve access for minonty groups, low- Public agency. The plan also encourages the use income populations, and people with disabilities. of school facilities for recreational use and the joint development of elementary school sites/neighborhood parks where possible. Employment Opportunities The City's policy has been to encourage employment Preserving, Restoring and of minorities and low-income residents on public Developing Waterfront Areas works projects. As urban revitalization projects continue, it is anticipated that these population The City has considerable ri ver frontag e along its groups will benefit from the employment southerly border, adjacent to levees constructed by opportunities that become available. the U.S. Army Corp of Engineers. A specific riverfront study has been developed that recommends new Protecting the Natural development and public access along a portion of the Columbia River. Environment Underopen space and linear park categories, recommendations have been made to acquire land for 2 Vision, Goals & Objectives Goals and Objectives Goals and objectives create the framework for a plan. A goal is a broad statement that gives the community a sense of direction. Goals typically do not change over time. Objectives are a more precise statement that when accomplished, help achieve a goal. There are multiple options MAL for achieving goals and therefore objectives may change based on new information, community value shifts, technology, or other ideas. Modification of objectives is a continuous process. These goals are statements of the City's aspirations as they relate to park and recreation services. Goals are long range and usually remain unchanged throughout the practical life of the plan. Objectives are working and measurable targets that, when achieved, indicate goal fulfillment. Individual goals may contain several objectives. Figure 3.02-Efficient use of public spaces to rneet connnn unity /� needs,reinvesting in parks to update them and keep then. Goa 1 ■■ Physical enjoyable-even as Pasco's demographics change-is an important priority (Image source;Studio Cascade;Inc j Provide physical facilities that offer youth and adults a broad variety of passive, active and organized recreation opportunities Goal 2: Rehabilitation Objectives: Maintain and rehabilitate park and • Maintain a capital rrnprovement program, recreation facilities to provide the highest which specifies a six-year schedule for quality of service level to the community acquisition and development of park and recreation lands Objectives: • Establish a neighborhood parks system that . Enact a maintenance program that maximizes serves a1!viable residential areas of Pasco the service life of parks and recreation • Develop large community parks to serve the facilities various regions of the City (i.e. East Pasco, . Rehabilitate or replace existing facilities that Centra!Pasco, North Pasco and west Pasco) cannot be maintained at desired service levels • Encourage private.sector development to share in the provision of recreation facilities that serve specialized community or regional Goal 3: Management and interests Operations • Preserve recreational opportunities afforded tunities aorded by unique natural or rnan-made features of the environment Establish and maintain a planning area • Take advantage oftheriverfron tag e as a and process within which the coordinated recreational, natural an d.scenic asset delivery of parks and recreation facilities may occur City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 3 Objectives: 604Beloped (measured by either land • Develop a profile ofneighborhoods that mass or population) assesses physical and demographic characteristics 2• Neighborhood parks should vary in • Establish forma;planning partnership size, ranging from two and a half (2.5) to between the City of Pasco, Franklin County seven (7) acres, with spaces programmed and the Pasco schoolDi.strict according to park size, topography and orientation. However, as a practical point, the City may be forced to accept available Goal 4: Programs and parcels for neighborhood parks in those Services areas where little vacant land is left. To the greatest extent practicable, neighborhood parks should adjoin neighborhood Operate recreational programs that allow (elementary) schools, reducing cost for opportunity for participation by all citizens both local agencies. They should also of Pasco be designed and developed in a manner that establishes and communicates Objectives: neighborhood identity. • Provide organized recreation programs for 3. In portions of the planning area men and women in both youth and adult ages where population densities are lower (i.e. • Assist citizen groups and organizations within 2-3 dwelling units/acre), the service area of the greater Pasco area with the design of a neighborhood park should be extended to programs for special population groups such a mile radius as the handicapped 4. At least 50 — the site should be Planning Policies pat and usable an vide space for both g active and passive uses The development of new park facilities and 5. Facilities can include: practice fields the continuous fine-tuning of recreational for softball, soccer, and youth baseball, program offerings necessitates more lighting, children's playground, unstructured specific criteria. These policy guidelines open play area for pick-up games, paved create the general standards for new parks games court, picnic area with shelter and recreation programs. The policies have building, trail system, natural open space, several purposes: trees, and drainage corridors • Guide day to day behavior to help 6. Neighborhood parks should be achieve objectives central to the area they serve, be adjacent • Prioritize and guide investment and to a green belt or trail system, be walking distance, 112 mile, for the area they serve, programming avoid the need to cross major arterial • Assist budgetfng streets or other physical barriers, be readily • Create expectations visible from adjoining streets, gain access from a local residential street or if on a busy • Define terms for interagency arterial street, use appropriate fencing and coordination other safety precautions Neighborhood Park Policies 1. A neighborhood park should be provided when the area it serves reaches 4 Vision, Goals & Objectives Community Park courts, open free play area, restrooms, PO�ICIeS children's playground, indoor recreational areas, outdoor sand volleyball courts, and space for special outdoor events 1. A community park should be developed when the area it serves reaches 3. Parking requirements: dependent about 70% developed upon the activities offered, but access should be from an arterial street if traffic 2. Acquisition of community park sites volumes will be high should occur far in advance of actual need 4. Location criteria: features should 3. Minimum size should be 15 acres determine location and if the site attracts with the optimum being about 25 acres large volumes of traffic and access should be via a collector or arterial street 4. At least ten acres of the site should be usable for active recreation use Regional Parks Policies 5. Facilities can include: formal lit ball fields-softball, baseball, and soccer, tennis 1. The Regional Park can be designed courts, open free play area, restrooms, to meet a wide range of activities and picnic facilities, paths and trail systems, interest but should emphasize the one landscaped areas, outdoor basketball feature that makes it unique courts, children's playgrounds (if needed to also serve the neighborhood), natural open 2. Facilities can include: viewpoints, space, indoor recreational areas, outdoor trail systems, special facilities for the sand volleyball courts, and space for special physically disabled, picnic areas, open play outdoor events areas, nature interpretative areas, and 6. Parking requirements: dependent group picnic areas upon the activities. Use 50 spaces per ball 3. Parking requirements: dependent field or 5 spaces per acre of active use upon the activities offered 7. A community park should be 4. Location criteria: determined by the reasonably central to the area it serves, be features it can offer, access from arterial located on an arterial or collector street, street if high traffic volumes are expected, some of the site should have a natural environmentally sensitive sites are area or heavy landscape setback to help appropriate if protected from active visitor buffer active uses from residential areas, use or from potential visitor damage environmentally sensitive sites can be included if protected from active uses Linear Parks Policies Large Urban Parks 1. The Linear Park should provide Policies activities that are generally passive in nature and should generally follow drainage 1. A large Urban Park can be designed corridors, natural vegetation or other to meet a wide range of activities and special feature strips interest but should emphasize the one 2. If possible, linear parks should be at feature that makes it unique least 100' wide 2. Facilities can include: viewpoints, 3. Paved pathways should be designed trail systems, special facilities for the to accommodate maintenance and patrol physically disabled, picnic areas, open play vehicles. (See trail design policies.) areas, group picnic areas, formal ball fields — softball, baseball, soccer, etc., tennis City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 5 4. Where general public use is Recreation Program promoted, adjoining uses should be protected by fences or other features Policies 5. Wherever possible, trails corridors 1. Pasco's range of recreational within linear parks should be designed to programs should be accessible to all, provide a pleasant aesthetic experience regardless of age or economic, social and to the user through proper design and cultural status. landscaping 2. Recreation programs should charge Trails Policies only as much as is necessary to cover program costs. 1. Trails should provide access and 3. Recreation programs may operate at be interesting and attractive to the user. a net profit if they are popular and charging Trails traversing scenic or landscaped areas market-rate user fees. provide an interesting and enjoyable user experience 2. Trails should be looped and interconnected to provide a variety of trail lengths and destinations including small and large loops for a broad range of experiences and ability levels 3. Trail routes should take into account soil conditions, surface drainage and other physical limitations that may impact or cause over-use 4. Bicycle trails should provide opportunities for recreation, touring, and commuters 5. Bicycle routes and paths should minimize the conflicts between motorists, bicyclists and other user groups 6. Trails should be routed to provide visual and physical access to natural areas and to the river Special Use Areas Policies 1. Prior to the addition of any special landscaped area, the City should prepare a detailed maintenance cost analysis to determine its impact upon the maintenance system 6 Vision, Goals & Objectives Demand This chapter describes community parks t and recreation demand, relating the community's composition (as described in the appendix in more detail) to the types of recreation facilities the community wants. It can also include references to the NPRS recreation system planning guidelines and other sources. Most of the new housing development in Pasco is occurring within the urban growth area (UGA) along the I-162 corridor. Figure4.01-Usepatternsdefioethescopeanddes,gre otthe Neighborhoods are well served by parks, parks and recreation system. Thisp,anwri;he;p ensure facii,t,es are avai,abie meet corgrquoity demand. pr9age source:Studio although many sites are old and showing cascade,Inc) signs of deterioration. Replacing these older parks is not financially feasible or desirable because the City invested considerable time and money to develop and maintain them. plan. It is also a difficult task because To abandon a site or completely construct many different variables influence public a new park on an existing site makes little recreation participation. What is common sense when the basic infrastructure is in one community may not be common for already in place. another. Underestimating the need can result in over-utilization of facilities while The extent of city investment is not the only overestimation results in expenditures thing at stake in focusing on rehabilitation. for unneeded facilities. The 2005 The community habits, patterns of Comprehensive Park and Recreation Plan development, and orientation are all identified existing recreation facilities and affected by the direction of development activities along with usage information and that Pasco chooses. developed level of service for the facilities needs (Table 4.01). Those services levels are a guideline for measuring what will be Park and Facility needed into the future, but they should not be considered inviolable standards. Demand Communities change, and preferences for certain facilities may vary over time. Identifying recreation demand and need is a very important part of a park and recreation Issues Soccer fields have eroded at the goals and Z 1 near center field providing an uneven play surface. Based on the community's adopted ■ The trail system has areas in need of widening standards and on comments received and lowering to provide safe routes. through this process, several demand- related issues will drive this plan. Accessibility ■ Pfany of the existing parks are not fully Safety accessible. Many play equipment areas do • Many older play equipment installations have not have an accessible route serving the features that currently do not meet the safety equipment. standards for play equipment, for example, ■ 5 on?e playgrounds and other facilities do not slides with lnsufflcient run out, compacted have an accessible route of travel serving areas below equipment, and insufficient depth them. of bark. ■ many of the parks need improvements in • Some neighborhood park recreation fields accessibility to site amenities such as drinking have little or not maintenance at bases fountains, picnic shelters, play courts, resulting in eroded areas at home plate and barbeques, tables and Benches. the bases. • Sorne basketball courts have had soil erode Maintenance onto them resulting in a possible slip hazard. ■ Paint is needed for some courts and other Other courts are in need of new surfacing. paved activity areas. Table 4.01 -Adopted park ratios Neighborhood Parks 1,64 acres,/1,000 population 2.00 acres/1,000 population Community Parks 0.41 acresj1,000 population 2.10 acres/1,000 population Large Urban Parks 2,99 acresil,000 population Maintain 1998 ratio Regional Parks 3.93 acres,11,000 population Maintain logs ratio Linear Park 0.75 acres/1,000 population 156 acres/1,000 population Special Use Areas 7.34 acres,/1,000 population 5.80 acres,/1,000 population Total Park Land 22 06 acres/1,000 population 23.38 acres;1,000 population Softball fields 1 field per 12,650 population 1 field per 3,000 population (275-300'outheld for men's slari pitch; 250' outfield for men's fast pitch, wornen's slari pitch) Youth baseball 1 field per 3,533 population 1 field per 2,900 population (200'foul line for major and minor leagues, 250'-300'foul line for pony league and colt league) Soccer fields 1 field per 1,060 population 1 field per 2,000 population (Youth soccer 55 x 100 yards; adult soccer 55 x 110 yards; charnplonshfp soccer 75 x 120 yards) Tennis Courts 1 court per 1,223 population 1 court per 1,500 population Trails 41 miles per 1,000 population 50 miles per 1,000 population .Source:Adopted 1998 recommendations developed by JC Draggoo tf Assoclates 2 Demand • Users hanging on the rims have damaged f basketball hoops. • Graffltiand vandalism evident on many park - features such as picnic tables,park signs, play - equipment and other areas. Concrete picnic tables should be replaced with expanded metal tables to reduce writing surfaces. Crawl tubes, current target of vandalsm, should be removed from play structures. • Many site amenities are broken, damaged or aged. Drinking fountains, benches, garbage cans, signs and other site furnishings need to �-- be replaced if broken or decaying. d, • Maintenance ofp Ian tmaterial and trees is necessary. Many shrubs and trees are dead %W.....`A or dying and in need of replacement. • Kurtzman and Richardson pools are growing z ` maintenance problems and need to be removed or replaced. Demand • Current demand for play fields, soccer fields in particular,is much higher than the current fields can accommodate • Demand is creating a need for lighting on fields in order for them to be used more hours flpure4.02-Pasco's residents use the community's parks of the day. for pick-up sports and other types of spontaneous recreation. (image source:Studlo Cascade,Mr.) Management • The City's park and recreation budget has fluctuated from 3% -4 0i8 of the general fund ■ parks and Recreation works closely with over the past 10 years(funding availability is man,v private and non-public organizations to stable but not growing with new growth) coordinate programs and activities • Close coordination between parks and ■ The lack of indoor recreation spaces(primarily recreation operations and other city indoor swimming) severely limits certain operations now exists through a departmental types of programs the City can offer. This management organization. is especially critical in a climate where cold inclement weather occurs at least five months Programs and Service of the year. • The lack of an indoor swimming pool in the Tri-City area restricts swimming in the winter Rehabilitation months. As a result, swimming instruction, ■ While many of the parks are old, they still competitive swimming, or general recreation have the basic infrastructure in place and are swimming is limited to about three summer conveniently located to most neighborhoods months . Rehabilitating parks in some of the older • The City relies on school facilities For many neighborhoods will indicate a positive effort programs operating around set schedules, and by the City to upgrade facilities in those is limited to certain times and places neighborhoods • The number of participants could be increased ■ Nlany of the older parks need only minor ifadditional recreational facilities were improvements to bring them to an acceptable provided or expanded especially indoor level facilities. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 3 • Upgrading a specific park indicates a positive recreational facilities within the Pasco attempt to improve the living environment in city limits, although the State and County that neighborhood facilities are in need of rehabilitation too, • Most of the parks needing rehabilitation are the responsibility for renovation to these found it) the oldernelghborhoods. This will areas will fall upon those agencies. directly affect the appearance and livability of the neighborhood • Rehabilitation can create new recreation Community opportunities and reduce the need to travel to other park sites Preferences • Rehabilitation can result ui a more en)oyabie recreation experience by providing new and more interesting facilities While the survey response rate was 3.5°/0, more interesting indicates an attempt to some interesting trends emerged. Overall • preserve a facility rather than discard it. there was a desire for a wide variety of facilities and services, consistent with expectations based on the community's Summary of Demand cultural and economic diversity. Except for community parks and general The questionnaires were mailed to a random sampling of Pasco's household open space the City is well served by its utility customers. This was not intended existing facilities. Neighborhood parks to be a random sampling of the entire are found close to most residents, and community, just a sampling of households. the community centers serve the resident The age range of respondents is needs. Most of these facilities are old consistent with this type of limitation, and many of the parks do not have all of with very few young respondents and a the elements traditionally found in parks, disproportionately high number of older though. respondents. The questionnaires also Rehabilitation of existing facilities required a certain degree of follow-up once is much more cost-effective than completed. Respondents could return the complete replacement because the questionnaires by mailing them to City Hall, basic infrastructure is already in place. including them in their utility payments or Rehabilitation looks at preserving as much delivering them in person. This second as possible and only replacing items that step in the process may have contributed to have either lived beyond their useful life the response rate and further discouraged or are not serving their intended function. younger respondents to participate. Rehabilitation is an ongoing process that Nonetheless, the responses received is scheduled to continue, creating an illustrate a range of priorities and expanding but maintainable parks system preferences as expressed by those in the for Pasco. community who would most likely be asked The process of rehabilitation has begun to support the parks and recreation system. in Pasco. Existing parks in Pasco and the The respondents are householders and older community centers are being rehabilitated. members of the community, those who Because of age, many of these parks and would be asked to support new facilities by buildings had facilities that outlived their special levy if one were proposed. They useful life. Generally, rehabilitation needs are also the ones who, by and large, pay for include: the installation of new playground participation in the community's recreation equipment; the renovation of turf areas, programs, supporting themselves, children (including irrigation and reseeding); the or grandchildren enrolled in those activities. installation of new security lighting and the renovation of rest rooms. Rehabilitation efforts have been confined to park and 4 Demand Question 4: Please indicate which of Pasco's major park and recreation facilities you use, placing a mark in the box on the left side of your choice(s): Memorial Park 40,8 ? Riverview Park 16.3 0,10 Sun Willows Golf Cojrse 24.5% Baseball Stadum 40.a% City Hall Activity Center �_ 12.2% Road 36 Soccer Fields �_ 14.3% Voluriteer Park 16.3% Soccer Conipler, 26.5% Library Park 18.4°/n `hLK C:en ter 6.1"/n Wayside Park 2.0°10 Softball Complex 14.3% Chi av;ana Park 79.6% Senior Citizens'Center 26.5% Cable Bridge Park 8.2% Other 12.2% FIgure4.03-Appendix D contains a full question mire report, Results Its ideritifying key trends and prcvidirig more infornnatian on conrrnunity preferences,in total and by age and resident location. (Image source:Studio Cascade,Inc.} Pool facilities were rated as very important to important by about half of the survey responses. This could be either indoor pool programming. People would improvements to outdoor facilities or an like to especially see more rest rooms, indoor pool facility. The responses show less neighborhood parks, trails, and pool interest in adult programs and skate parks, facilities, followed closely by natural open There was also less interest in community spaces. centers. More programs in exercise and leisure, About 40% of the respondents felt that outdoor recreation, and aquatics were existing park facilities were not adequate, requested the most frequently. Multiple and 27 11/o felt that programs were not respondents pointed to the unincorporated adequate. Some of the responses pointed area surrounded by the western portion of to a lack of parks in new development Pasco, neighborhood parks in the rapidly or overcrowding while other comments growing part of the city north of 1-182, suggested more improvements like lighting, and access to the river as items for further benches, and play courts/grounds. attention. Facilities that are used the most are By Age bathrooms, followed by picnic areas and playgrounds, and water access areas. Respondents youngertha i 45 tended to use the Sport courts are reported as being used baseball stadium, Memorial Park and chiawana Park the least. There were multiple requests most often, while those 45 to 54 prefer chlawana for more bicycle opportunities and Park and other recreational facilities not listed In the City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 5 questionnaire. Of those facilities listed, respondents in this age group were relatively evenly distributed. The MLh Center,Cable Bndge Park and the 5enior Center were notable in that no respondents in this age group identified them as a favonte facility. The 55 and older groups preferred the 5enior Center, Chiawana Park, Memorial Park and the baseball stadium. When it came to finding out about the City's recreational program offerings, all age groups turn to the Recreation Guide. Younger respondents tended also to identify the Internet,word of mouth and community events as sources for recreation information. Older residents tended to identify newspa pe r a rtic les and word of mouth as their primary recreation information resources. If asked to fund new parks facilities, residents you ngerthan 55 genera llyfavored an aquatic center. Those older also favored an aquatic center, but they also wanted to support walking and biking trails and nveraccess. Those respondents between the ages of 25 and 34 would also like to see and would be willing to support improvements to and the addition of athletic facilities and sports fields. By Location The questionnaire asked respondents to identify if they live east or west of Highway 355. Those east of the highway identified Chiawana Park, Memorial Park, the baseball stadium,Volunteer Park and the 5enior Citizens'Center as thei r most used parks facilities. Those west of the highway identified Chiawana Park,the baseball stadium,the soccer complex and Memorial park as their most used facilities. Generally,those respondents east of the highway spread their preferences more evenly across the facilities choices provided. Respondents east of 355 rely on the Recreation Guide, newspaper articles, word of mouth and a dverti sements to learn about recreation programs. Those west of the highway use the Guide, word of mouth, newspaper articles, advertisements and the Internet to stay informed. Households east of 355 would most likely be willing to support an aquatic facility, walking and biking trails and indoor recreation facilities. Those west would also those, and they would support sports fields,too. 6 Demand Inventory & Need This chapter compares what the city now has to what the community's need is and will likely be, Identifying existing r deficiencies and projecting need into the future. It provides a laundry list of facilities and program improvements, making Yti o4 , recommendations at a variety of levels. Park Type Figure 5.01-Comparing existing facilities tc current and There are several types of parks In Pasco. 3,1ticipated demand indicates curre,,tand brecastneed. (image Their character is defined by both size source:Studio Cascade,'Inc.) and location. The smaller parks tend to cater to smaller neighborhoods. The larger parks, while serving the surrounding neighborhoods, tend to cater to more community events. A few examples community-wide needs. The seven different include Island Park, Richardson Park, and park types are briefly described below. Centennial Park. Neighborhood Parks Community Parks Neighborhood parks include a playground Community park facilities are generally and park designed primarily for non- designed for organized activities and sports, supervised, non-organized recreation although individual and family activities are activities. In Pasco, they are generally encouraged. Community parks can provide small in size (3-7 acres) and serve a Indoor facilities to meet a wider range of radius of approximately one-half mile. At recreation interests. A community park average residential densities, this amounts can also serve the function of neighborhood to about 5,000 to 7,500 residents. Since parks, although community parks serve a these parks are located within walking much larger area and offer more facilities. and bicycling distance of most users, the Their service area is about a one-mile activities they offer become a daily pastime radius and will support a population of for neighborhood children. While it is not approximately 12,000 - 15,000 persons necessarily the rule, neighborhood parks depending upon its size and nature of sometimes provide space for organized should be designed to accommodate a large number of people. Regional Parks Regional parks are large recreational areas that serve an entire city or region. They can be large and often include one specific use or feature. If possible, they should be developed around a unique or significant resource to emphasize regional recreation interest. These types of park areas are found nearby and include Sacajawea State v - Park, Columbia Park (City of Kennewick), .}' and Howard Amon Park (City of Richland). These parks offer riverfront and boating ,, ,r �^ facilities as well as other passive recreation opportunities and are within a short travel time for Pasco residents. iii+ 4'• 1�:' ; K ' _ y : • a f Linear Parks Linear parks are land areas that generally FIgure5.02-Pasco's parks and recreation inverr-oryisueriec, follow a drainage corridor, ravine, or some with waterfront and upland parks,trails,and specialized other elongated feature such as a power line recreational and athletic facilities. (Image source,,Studio Cascade;I11c.) or railroad right-of-way. This type of park area often contains various levels/types of trail systems and sometimes includes its facilities. They require more support greenbelts. facilities including parking, rest rooms, and covered play areas. They usually exceed 20 acres in size and often have sport fields or Trails similar facilities as the central focus of the park. Memorial park fulfills the needs of a Pathways and trails are designed to community park in Pasco. provide walking, bicycling, and other non- motorized means for linking various parts Large Urban Parks of the community and connecting parks to residential areas. Trails provide recreation oriented bicycle and walking opportunities Large urban parks, like Chiawana Park, are utilizing canals, drainage corridors, designed to serve the entire community. easements, and other publicly accessible They are similar to a community park but facilities. The trail system includes much larger. They provide a wide variety unpaved foot trails used for walking, hiking, of specialized facilities such as large picnic mountain bike riding and horseback riding, areas, water related activities, indoor and paved multi-use bicycle trails designed recreation facilities, and sports fields. for bicycle riding, walking and hiking. The They require more support facilities such system can consist of both off-street and as parking, restrooms, and play areas on-street trail segments. Many off-street because of their size and facilities offered. segments already exist along the waterfront They usually exceed 50 acres in size and and Interstate 182. The only undeveloped segment stretches from the Blue Bridge to 8.2 Inventory & Need Table 5.01 - Existing parks and facilities Park Inventory f Current park facilities in the Pasco planning Meignborn°od 1i 85 85 acres area are classified by park type and/or Parks facility (Table 5.01). Figure 5.03 locates the -ommiunity Parks 1 13 13 acre= community's parks. A complete park and recreation facility inventory can be found in Large Urban Parks 1 127 25 acres Appendix A and B. Regional Park 1 284 284 acres The inventory of current facilities can be Linear Parks 1 25 25 acres compared to current population estimates and the future population forecast. To Special Use Areas 13 247 247 acres determine if these facilities adequately Total 34 791 679 acres serve the Pasco population it is necessary to use the established level of service Youtri Baseball 10 guidelines (Table 4.01). These guidelines Fields create a benchmark to measure how Adult Softball Fields a the City is doing. Using the inventory of existing facilities (Table 5.01) a comparison Soccer Fields 3o can be made between existing conditions Tennis -ourts* 29 and then extend it into a forecast future (Table 5.02). This plan assumes that the Trails 4 15 miles benchmark is good and reasonable for *-only a small number of triesefacilities are owned and future as well as current comparisons. operated by the City. Public access is limited to those Table 5.02 shows the current inventory facilities owned and operated by others• along with the present and 2030 demands and needs. Sacajawea Park, although this is now under construction. Park and Recreation Big Cross is a privately developed and Needs maintained 2.2-mile cross-country course located on 55 acres of Port of Pasco land. This site also has 1.8 acres of grass with an automated irrigation system. The facility Neighborhood Park Needs is used by two high schools and two middle schools for their cross-country meets. There are 17 developed neighborhood park sites in the planning area. While the service area of a neighborhood park is considered Special Use Areas to be a half mile radius, this does not take into account physical boundaries such as Special use areas include miscellaneous freeways, railroads, topographic features, sites that do not fit into any other category etc. which may influence the actual service such as small landscaped parcels, sports boundary. Based on the recommended field complexes, specialized single purpose standard of 2.00 acres per 1,000 population, areas, and land occupied by major approximately 28 additional acres are recreation structures. needed at the present time. Within 20 years the Pasco planning area will need over 90 acres. Using an average of five acres per neighborhood park site, this represents roughly 18 sites. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 8.3 o. V Vjj, 4 may` Y r � � r Xt o 7 { Lill t I Z Li 1 7 �;I 7 � 7 � 7 d � 1 d 4 Inventory & Need Table 5.02- SuMnIar-v nfland and fa CilltieS needs 2010 2010 2010 2030 i De h Neighbor`ood Parks 2.00 ac/1,000 pop 85 acres 113 _7,8 1%5 90 Community Parks 2.10 ac/1,000 pop 13 acres 118 105 183 170 Large Urban Parks 2.99 ac/1,000 pop 127 acres 168 41 251 134 Regional Park 8.93 ac/1,000 pop 284 acres 503 219 780 496 Linear Parks 1.55 ac/1,000 pop 25 acres 88 53 136 111 Special Use Areas 5.80 ac/1,000 pop 247 acres 327 80 506 259 Total 23.38 ac/1,000 pap 761 acre 11316 555 2,041 1,280 Youth Baseball Fields 1 field/2,900 pop. 10 fields 19 9 30 20 Adult Softball Fields 1 field/3,000 pop. 9 fields 19 10 29 20 Soccer Fields 1 teld12,000 pop. 30 t elds 28 (2) 44 14 Tennis Courts 1 court/1,500 pop. 29 courts 38 9 58 29 Trails 0.50 rniles.11,000 pop. 15 miles 28 13 44 29 Mote: Figuresthat appear ri parentheses represent a surplus quantity .Assumes a 2010 population estimate of 56,300 and a 2030 medium projection of 87,300 people 1 Includes County park. sites Includes Sacalawea Sate Park Community Park Needs important to recognize that Columbia Park, across the river in Kennewick, also serves as a large urban park for many of Pasco's Memorial Park is the only community park residents. Applying the standard for large now in the planning area. This City-owned urban parks shows that the existing park is park is fully developed. While it provides not serving the recent population growth. the facilities and functions of a community There is a need for41 more acres now, and park, it is substantially undersized. (An by 2030 there will be a need for at least analysis of the service area of this park 134 more acres. Chiawana Park should be indicated that this community park is further developed and expanded to serve currently not serving a substantial amount the population better in the future. of the planning area.) This is particularly true for the north and west portions of the planning area. At the present time an Regional Park Needs additional 105 acres of land are needed and a total of 170 acres of additional land for community parks will be needed by the end There is one regional park in the planning of the planning period. The need is critical area: Sacajawea State Park. The potential in Pasco's northwest. to develop another regional park in Pasco is very limited. The existing park should be supplemented by other regional park Large Urban Park Needs access, if possible, to help serve the Pasco area in the future. There is one large urban park in the planning area: Chiawana Park. It is City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 5 Linear Park Needs Specialized Facility The County, with assistance from the Needs City, developed a portion of the riverfront into a linear park. The riverfront offers Pasco has other facilities beyond those numerous opportunities for expansion and mentioned above, each of which contributes further development. The Franklin County a valuable dimension to the community's Irrigation District Canal (FCID), which runs parks and recreation system. The following south of I-182 through town, also presents paragraphs describe how the community's an opportunity for expansion of the linear need will impact those facilities, exploring park system. The recommended standard how community demand will drive changes: of 1.56 per 1,000 population means that the present need is for roughly 63 acres of land. By 2030 this will rise to more than 111 acres Adult Softball Fields of needed linear parkland. Within the Tri-City area, management of Special Use Areas the softball program is divided between h` the three cities. Each municipality has informally assumed the responsibility This classification includes such sites as for certain leagues or parts of leagues. Pasco's Baseball Stadium/Soccer Complex, Currently, the City of Pasco manages the Schlagel Park, Peanuts Park, Riverview entire Church League softball program, Park, the Senior Center, the golf course and which includes men's, vromen`s, and coed other miscellaneous landscaped areas. The teams. In addition to the Church League, recommended standard reflects the ratio the City also schedules the Junior Olympic as adopted in 1996. At the present time League Softball program. an additional 80 acres of land are needed, and an additional 259 acres of land will be Since many of the softball leagues use fields needed by the year 2030. all over the Tri-City area, it is difficult to assess the individual city's needs. Based on the analysis, the average ratio is 1 field per Total Park Land Needs 3,000 population. If this ratio is applied to the current Pasco population there is a need The adopted standard is higher than the for a total of 19 softball fields (10 additional current total parkland. Much of the existing fields). By 2030 there will be a need for parkland in the area is devoted to special a total of 29 softball fields (20 additional use areas, large urban parkland, or the fields). regional park category, such as the golf course and Sacajawea State Park. The Youth Baseball Fields areas currently being served by parks reveal community park and neighborhood park site needs. Parks are not serving a significant There are two private organizations that portion of the planning area, particularly the sponsor youth baseball in the Pasco area. unincorporated area to the west. There is Currently, the Pasco Little League does the a deficit of 555 acres of parkland today and scheduling for league games, which are held 1,280 acres more parkland will most likely at Little League Fields. Practice locations be needed by 2030. vary depending on the preference of the coach. The Pony and Colt leagues use three Franklin County has a role to play in the fields, two of which are on school grounds. provision of total parkland, too. It should be From the inventory of baseball fields, there planning for and acquiring parkland in the are 10 youth baseball fields available. The Riverview area, the unincorporated territory City and the School District should provide surrounded by Pasco. 6 Inventory & Need enough fields to support its population. The Walking Trails average ratio is 1 field per 2,900 population applied to the current Pasco population provides an approximate present need of There are 15 miles of walking trails in the 4 more fields. By 2030, a total of 30 fields Pasco area. They consist of a 6.4-mile (20 additional fields) will be needed. Franklin County Trail along the Columbia River, a one-mile trail around Road 68 softball fields, and a 6.2 mile paved trail Soccer Fields along the Interstate 162 Freeway. There is another 1.4 miles of trail that on the levee. The Port of Pasco is constructing The Tri-City Youth Soccer Association approximately 2 miles of trail extending sponsors the entire youth soccer program west from Sacalawea State Park and the in the region. Most of the teams originate City plans to construct another 0.6 miles from outside the Pasco area. In addition, in 2005 or 2006. There is also a 2.2-mile there is a major competitive league within cross-country course that is used for trail this club. A separate adult league also purposes. The recommendation is for off- operates at the Pasco Road 36 facility. street pedestrian and bicycle paths oriented Soccer in the Pasco area is played on a primarily to recreation use. The standard regional level. Because the teams originate shows a need for 28 miles more trails from all over the region, it is difficult to now, although there are 1.4 miles being identify only the City of Pasco teams. The developed currently, and 10 miles more as recommended standard of 1 field per 2,000 the area develops. Wherever possible, trails population means that there is an adequate should be developed in conjunction with number of fields at the present time. linear park development. However, the facilities inventory and Aquatics Facility stakeholder interviews indicate the existing q Y fields are overused, which may indicate the LOS is too low or, more likely, the A feasibility study for an indoor regional fields are being used by other user groups aquatic center was developed in April 2004. like Lacrosse. The Road 36 fields are not Public meetings were conducted with about adequate to support the level of use they've 150 Tri-City area citizens participating and experienced. By 2030 an additional 20 providing input. A consultant provided a fields will be needed. Additionally as fields concept design incorporating size, scope, are developed the City of Pasco should and configuration of the proposed facility. consider lighted synthetic turf fields that The facility would include: family leisure allow heavier prolonged use. water activities, year-round water safety instruction, and organized recreational and Tennis Courts competitive activities. The study included: There are 29 tennis courts in Pasco located 0 10 lane 50 meter competition pool at both parks and schools. Not included with bleacher seating for Soo in this inventory are the occasional tennis courts found in apartment complexes ■ 30'x75'teaching pool or other private housing projects. The 0 Childcare inventory indicates that Pasco needs an additional 9 courts to serve the present ■ Changing rooms population and 29 courts by 2030. ■ Sauna and steam rooms ■ Retaii ■ Outdoor water slides, wave pool, and a picnic areas City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 7 City Recreation Departmental Services Facilities and Areas All of Pasco's recreation facilities and programs are open and available to the The City's Park system consists of 17 general public regardless of race, color, neighborhood parks, one community park, creed, sex, religion, or national origin. and 13 special use areas. The following While the Department has not made a table summarizes the facilities at each park major effort to link its services to other site. non-recreation programs such as crime/ drug prevention, youth at risk programs, housing, or economic development, it does Other Public Facilities participate with the school district help in offering programs to minimize drug and There are also other facilities available to crime activity. the Pasco community. Appendix A and B The City offers a wide range of recreation provide a complete listing. The County services based on community demand. The has several Pasco area recreation sites Senior Center and Martin Luther King Center that are mostly developed but may not serve special population groups. New be maintained adequately. The State has facilities are now designed to accommodate one site. Schools are also an important special population needs in terms of access resource for recreation and open space. and recreation opportunity. The City does The City Parks and Recreation system not own or maintain facilities designated extensively uses school district facilities for as having historical or architectural recreation programs. This includes fields for significance. outdoor sports, gymnasiums for volleyball and basketball, and classrooms for special The residents of Pasco are the primary interest groups. beneficiaries of these recreational services, although unincorporated areas of Franklin County and the adjoining cities, Kennewick Table 5.Q3 Recreation partieination and Richland, also benefit. Table 5.03 summarizes recreation participation levels for the major activities offered by the 1996 1997 2002 2003 Department in parks and school facilities. Aquatics 37,475 37,693 39,338 43,271 /� 5pecial Events 5,936 7,630 9,239 9,952 Services for minority �y-y linority Adult Classes/ 6,707 6,957 6,975 7,038 populations and the Activities Youth Classes/ 2,416 2,555 2,735 2,917 elderly Activities Adult Sports 24,033 24,694 25,928 26,976 The City provides programs and services in areas with high minority populations, Youth sports 27,154 27,902 29,536 23,922 including hiring a recreation specialist Sr. Classes/ 37,063 38,101 37,871 38,968 located in the Martin Luther King Center Activities funded by a HUD block grant that provides Golf 61,000** 64,000** 51,344 49,362 alternate recreation programs for youth. Total 202,797 209,332 200,995 206,306 The City operates the Pasco Senior Center with state and federal grants assisting in Units of participation are equal to the number of times an with individual participates in a particular activity the areas of nutrition programs and other IVUrnbersmaybeincorrect because of the accounting system related activities. Programs are available to employed durirgtheseyears anyone over the age of 50 living in Franklin 8 Inventory & Need County. This center provides a variety of Table 5.04- Private recreation providers recreation and social activities specifically designed for the elderly population, and meets most needs of this population group. American Youth Soccer Youth soccer program Assoc ContrapcG League Recreational Babe Ruth League Baseball program Services Baptist ChurchSOftball Softball program Big Cross Cross Country running course Public Agencies Boys and Girls flub Recreation al+BducaticraI Parks and Recreation works closely with the Pasco program School District to provide a wide range of recreational Court Kids Basketball program activities. Schools are extensively utilized forvarious sports such as basketball, soccer, baseball and Pasco Youth Football Football program tennis, and classrooms are used fort ndoor recreation Pasco Little League Baseball program programs. In turn,the city permits the schools to use their facilities for mayor school events such as the Pasco Soccer Adult League Adult soccer program State cross Country Championships and use of the city pools for physical education programs. Also,the Tn-city Girls Fast Pitch Softball program Tri-City area cities work closely to coordinate various Tri-City Youth Soccer Assoc. soccer program recreatlonprograms. This is particularly true ln sports, with each city offer ng certain non-competing YMCA -ball,foot Indoor soccer, T-ball,football Instruction sports programs. Private Service Providers since 1988. A new operatortook overthe golf course management in 2001 with an Improved record and Community Service keeping system Organizations Parks and Recreation works closely with many private and non-public organizations to coordinate programs and activities. Sometimes the City provides only the facillties and the private groups operate the programs. Some of these organizations Include Grid Kids Football, National Little League and the Tin-Cities Youth Soccer Association, Many are oriented toward a specific sport but represent an area beyond the City of Pasco, There are many private service providers that offerspecific types of recreation programs and opportunities. Coordination with community service organizations is mostly Informal The City works closely with theYMCA and other service providers for provision of a full range of recreational opportunities. The YMCA, with assistance of the City, provides programs in the minority and low-income areas of the City. The City contracts with the YMCA for programs at the Martin Luther King Center. The City has also contracted Out the maintenance and operation of Its mu nicipal golf course,Sun willows, City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 9 Capital J Facilities This chapter orders and prioritizes parks and recreation system improvements, ' . _- including general cost estimates and likely funding sources. _ ,J Some important ideas and steps should be kept in mind to make this a successful plan. The following points will help in implementing the ideas developed here. Program and Services FIgure6.01-Keeping the parks and recreation systen,working requires,'Pvestmentin capita;Facilities,both in terms or" rehabilitation and in new construction. Frequ ere tly,design and development decisions,made in capital programming can help Program Evaluation reduce continuing maintenance costs, too. (Image source:Studio cascade,In C.) The Department should continue evaluation of recreation programs and make changes Lased on interests and varying instructor ability. health and fitness clubs. U ifDrtUrately, not all Pasco residents can afford these facilities. Ways to build affordaLle private facilities can include construction of Encourage Other Recreation private facilities on public land, subsidized operations, Providers and franchise operations. The City cannot and should riot provide all recreation services demanded by the Public. To meet this Evaluate the Fee Schedule demand,the City should bethe lead coordinating agency in encouraging other Public and quasi-puLlic From time to time the City should evaluate its policy agenciesto assist in meeting these needs, on fees and charges. Development of Private Sector Management Recreational Facilities The city of Pasco does not accomplish all the The small size of the Parks and Recreation recreation needs in the community. Private clubs Staff allows the department staff to and commercial interests could provide some remain connected through the structure. recreation opportunities including tennis and swim Many of the potential communication and clubs, racquet clubs, golf clubs, Lowling alleys, and bureaucracy problems found in larger organizations are not present. There is still room to make some improvements. The Cou my has implemented a park impact fee Some specific recommendations will make system that uses the same district boundaries as the Department operate more efficiently Pasco allowing for orderly tracking and transfer of Including: parks fu rids onannexation. But the pla rring for and acquisition of parkland will be key. Department Policies City/School District Cooperation To help maintain a level of consistency,a policy manual should be prepared that deals with Cooperation for 7oi nt use of areas and facilities the various operations managed by the A&CS between the A&CS Department and the Pasco School Department. Currently, policies have been developed District is formalized through an interlocal agreement for certain activities but do not coverthe entire between the District and the City. The school district operation. Cnce in place,they will help the staff to has assisted In providing Indoor facilities to support administerthe various programs it offers, the City's winter recreation programs as well as playground areas foroutdoor athletic leagues. The use of the school distnct's physical plant allows the Park Maintenance Management A&CSDepartmentto Concentrate Its resourceson System acquiring and developing recreation areas without The City should approach park maintenance on duplicating indoor recreation facilities. There is also a systematic basis by developing an operations an agreement to jointly develop and operate school program that schedules work on a yearly basis. It Playground/park facilities. should Include a complete inventory of each park site, establish maintenance and performance standards, Periodic Evaluation of Goals and develop cost reporting systems, identify maintenance Objectives priorities, and prepare a yearly work schedule By approaching park and facility maintenance on a Because values and economic conditions change, systematic basis, crisis planning can be reduced and the City should periodically reevaluate the goals and maintenance tasks spread out more evenly overthe objectives described In the leisure services program year resulting in higher maintenarce levels at a lower offered by the City. cost. City/County Cooperation Continuing Citizen The City of Pasco has the responsibility for providirig Participation recreational areas,facilities,and progra ms within the incorporated areas of the City, Franklin County's It is recommended that the City encourage responsibility forthe Riverview areas is of particular continuing citizen participation for reviewing interest to the City of Pasco because of possible and implementing this plan. The City annexation In the future Even without annexation, already has two citizen-based committees many Riverview residents presently utlllzethe City's to help keep parks and recreation park and recreation programs, areas,and facilities. programming on track: The unincorporated Riverview area could experience population growth generating a need for several neighborhood parks and additional community parks. Parks and Recreation Advisory These points show the need for cooperation between Council the City of Pasco and Franklin COL my for park and recreation provisions within the Riverview area. This The Parks a rid Recreation Advisory Council (PRAC) is of particular concern as this area may a nnex into helps staff design its recreation programs,target Pasco. It is essential that Franklin COL my act to facilities Investments and manage Issues related acquire and preserve parkland In Riverview, making to the parks and recreation system. This group is su re that new development there wl11 be adequately appointed by the City Council. served. 2 Capital Improvements & Implementation Senior Services Advisory Corn m ittee This group, also appointed bythe City CPUncil, advises the Council on programs, activities, and gm interests of senior citizens as they relate to the Senior Center. " Regional Coordination ' of Recreation Services ��� The unique Tri-City area has three cities and two counties within close proximity to each other providing varied levels of park , and recreation service. Coordination of services, especially sports programs, is very important. The Cities (Pasco, Richland, and Kennewick) all offer full park and recreation programs while Benton and Franklin Counties offer limited park programs with no recreation programs. The three titles informally decide which programs each community offers. Figure 5.02-keeping pace a-ith community demand for parks A more formal organization can be formed will require development of new parks andrehabiliteticn of for coordination of regional programs existing ones.(Image seurce:.Stu)dlo Caseade,Inc.) including: ■ Joint maintenance operations provide a more complete description of ■ Construction of majorsports these various facilities, their condition Facilities and recommendations for specific ■ Coordination of athletic field use for Improvements. regional sports competitions In 1996, the City developed a plan for ■ Planning and coordination of trail long-range development of Pasco's central systems that pass through different waterfront. The intent of the plan was to municipalities develop a multi-use waterfront development ■ Planning and coordination of that complements the surrounding regional park facilities neighborhoods, and links the Columbia River with the Central Business District. This plan ■ evaluation and coordination of establishes goals and objectives for river special recreation programs shore enhancement and a phasing program ■ Discussions on issues ofjoint for its implementation. Phase I (Road 26 to interest(School District agreement). 13th Avenue) and Phase 2 (13th Avenue to Boat Basin) development includes a paved New Park Development multi-use trail, interpretive signs, pedestrian amenities, and lawn and tree plantings along the levee. Subsequent phases will There are several proposed parks and include shoreline reconfiguration and facilities proposed, as summarized redevelopment of surrounding land uses. in Table 6.01. Appendices A and B City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 3 The Port of Pasco link from the Boat in an "apples vs. oranges" type of problem. Basin is primarily along the water. A This section aims to aid in comparison and few connections to Sacajawea Park and strategic decision-making by establishing Columbia Basin Community College will six criteria against which each project utilize on-street bike lanes and separated is judged. As some criteria are more shoulders. The City should develop several important than others, the scores under intermediate connections using bike lanes each are weighted to reflect relative value. and local streets. These routes will provide In Table 6.02, project scores have been important north-south linkages and connect totaled by multiplying each initial score and major features within the community weighting factor. including schools, parks and the downtown core. Recommendations have also been made for bringing each facility up to an (Include new information about the current acceptable level for recreational use. As waterfront collaborative planning effort.) needs for some parks are quite extensive, improvement priorities should follow those Proposed Indoor set forth in Table 6.02. Swimming Pool Criteria The Regional Aquatic Center will impact The following criteria create the basic all pool facility projects in the Tri-City framework for measuring specific projects region. There are currently no public identified in this plan. Each project is indoor swimming pools in the Tri-City area. scored on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being The swimming pool at Memorial Park was best under each criterion. That score is recently updated but the pools at Kurtzman then multiplied by the criterion's weight, Park and Richardson Park are at the point resulting in a weighted score for that of where substantial updating is needed. particular criterion. These weighted scores These pools are continuing to get more use, are then summed in the far right column, and no additional facilities have been added representing the total weighted score for to compensate for the increase. each project. This allows the projects to be prioritized according to total score and then An aquatic center will draw users from programmed over upcoming budget years. the entire region. There is a need within the large urban park and community ■ Health, Safety and Welfare - The park facilities for regional swimming extent to which the proposed opportunities, which are not available within project is necessary to meet the the Tri-Cities region. The resource and public's health, safety and welfare commitment from all jurisdictions is needed needs. to create a strong partnership for the facility 0 Resident Priority - The extent to and there will be continued discussions on which the project is supported how to make the project succeed. by the community's expressed recreation and parks preferences. Prioritizing ■ Level or Service - The extent to which the project maintains levels of service as defined in the parks plan Pasco has limited funds to expend on park or capital facilities element of the and recreation system improvements, so comprehensive plan. it needs to prioritize the various projects by relative importance. In some cases, ■ Cost-Effectiveness - The extent to however, it is difficult to compare different which the project produces the most types of projects to each other, resulting "bang for the buck." 4 Capital Improvements & Implementation Table 6.01- Existing and new parks and facilities Neighborhood Park Sites(53 Acres Proposed) 5 Sunny Meadows Park Robert Wayne Or. Existing Park 10* McGee Park (McGee) Horizon Dr and Desert Plateau Or. Existing Park 5 Heritage Park Park St and Road 44 Existing Park 6* 24th Avenue(Rowena Chess) 24th Ave, north of Sylvester Existing Park 5 Richardson Park 1910 Richardson Existing Park 2 Lucas Park 14th and Lincoln Existing Park 2 Centennial Park 5th and Pearl Existing Park 3 Sylvester Park 5th and Sylvester Existing Park 3 Mercier Park 7th and 8 Street Existing Park 7 Kurtzman Park 321 S. Were Existing Park 8* Vintage(Maya Angelou) Road 84, north of Sandifur Parkway Existing Park 5 Liberty Park About Road 92,north of FCID canal Existing Park 5 Marie Road 64, south of Court Street Proposed Park 5 Livingston Road 44, north of Viernett Road Proposed Park 5 Emerald Estates Road 40,north of Sandifur Parkway Proposed Park 5 Casa Del Sol Road 46, north of Burden Existing Park 8* Crossings Road 60,north of Sandifur Proposed Park 5 W Pasco West of Road 100 Proposed Park 5 Chapel Hill Road 60,south of I-182 Proposed Park 5 Franklin Road Franklin Rd.,at Rd.72 Proposed Park 5 Linda Loviisa Road 56,south of Burden Proposed Park community Parks Sites(55 Acres Proposed) 13 Memorial Park 1520 W.Shoshone Existing Park 5 Court&Road 48 (County Soccer) Existing Field(expansion possible) 13 Highland Park Wehe and Adeiha Existing Park 55 Cross Country Course (Port of Pasco Property) Existing(improvement possible) Large Urban Park Sites 95 Chiawana Park (County park site) Existing Park City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 5 Table 5.01 (continued) -Existing and new parks and facilities Regional Park Sites 284 Sacatawea State Park (State park site) Existing Park Linear Park Sites 25 Wade Park Along the Columbia River Existing Park Special Use Area Sites 65 Baseball Stadium,Soccer, Road 66,north of Hwy 162 Existing Fields Softball Complex 4.5 TRAC Soccer Fields Road 68,Burden Road Existing Fields 10 Road 36 Soccer Fields Road 36 Existing Field 132 Sun Willows Golf Course 1825 Sun Willows Blvd. Existing Course 1 Senior Citizens Center 1315 N.7th Existing Center 7 Volunteer Park 4th and Marie Existing Park 1 Library Park 1320 W, Hopkins Existing Park 7 Riverview Park 1760 and S."A"Street Existing Park 1 Cable Bridge Park 1301 S. 10th Ave Existing Park 3 Schlagel Park S. 4th and Washington Existing Park 1 Peanuts Park 4th and Lewis Existing Park 1 wayside Park E Lewis and Main Existing Park 3 Wade Park Boat Launch Road 56 Proposed renovation w/picnic Trails FCID Canal Proposed Troll Sacatawea Heritage Trl,(I) 20th to 13th Ave Existing Trail Sacajawea Heritage Trial.(II) 13th to Boat Basin Existing Trail Joint Park and Playground(School Name) • Multiple Use - The extent to which 5.2 identifies those projects to be completed the project will serve more than one within the next five years. Table 5.3 takes purpose, a look at the longer term, identifying and • Concurrent Project - The extent prioritizing projects from 2016 through to which this project will occur at 2030. the some time as other, potentially unrelated project(s) at the same site. The following tables provide a prioritized list of projects for two planning periods. Table 6 Capital Improvements & Implementation V `J Rte` f _ / i[ I W i4 4 'r d / i i f l City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update December 2010 7 Capital Improvement Possible Funding Plan Sources The action plan develops the strategies A list of possible funding sources is provided and alternative funding sources for in Appendix D. Of particular note, however, implementing the plan. The Capital are two potent sources for parks-related Improvement Plan (CIP) is the key revenue, component for implementation. The CIP (summarized in Table 6.04) creates the framework for acquisition, development, and Recreation and rehabilitation of park areas and facilities. Conservation office This plan represents a six-year effort and is dependent upon funding availability as well as many other variables with possible Formerly the Interagency Committee for revision if opportunities to acquire or Outdoor Recreation, the RCO oversees develop sites not on this list arise. a range of parks and recreation grant Table 6.02 Prioritized protects 2011 2015 V,'eight Kitchen remodel Levee 2-12 lowering,rest roorns andtrail East Pasco soccer Facility Linda Lcviisa Park Three Rivers Crossing Chapel Hill Park FCID Trail development Liviigston Park 4Uestside corn rnunity park vision Impact fee ordinance review 8 Capital Improvements & Implementation programs. One of the most popular is the athletic facilities, provide funding assistance Washington Wildlife and Recreation Program on a competitive basis. Upon completing (WWRP), funding parks and recreation and adopting this plan, Pasco will qualify facilities in a number of categories. These to compete for WWRP grants, both for the categories, including local parks, trails and Table 6.03- PnaribZed Pru)eets 2017-2030 vr'eight City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 9 Table 6.04- Capita);rprovernerzt p)arz 2011 - 2016 201_/85,000 Kitchen remodel Renovation Senior center CDBG 2011!30,000 Levee 2-12 lowering,rest Develo Lower levee and construct trail, rest rooms, Unfunded 2013,11,100,000 rooms and trail Development Lower and picnic area ^011/50,000 20+ acre facility allowing for development 2012/800,000 East Pasco soccerfacility Development of four soccer nelds n-ith parking and Funded facilities 2011/265,000 Linda Loviisa Park Development New neighborhood park Park devel fund 2012/265,000 Tnree Rivers Crossing Develcprnent Five-acre neighborhood park adjacent to Park devel proposed elementary school fund 2013/265,000 Chapel Hill Park Development Read neighborhood park south of I-182 at Park devel Read 50 fund 2014/55,000 FCID Trail development Development Construct trail and linear park. along General fu rid 20151350,000 Franklin County Irrigatic-1 District ROW R.CO grant 2014/80,000 Livingston Park Acquisition Purchase land for five-acre park Park devel fund acquisition and construction of recreational in the community. The Comprehensive facilities. Park and Recreation Plan can and should be used to enlist community support for its implementation. This may be accomplished Park Impact Fees in the following ways: Pasco charges park impact fees on new ■ The Plan and each major development to offset costs to acquire park recommendation should become the land intended to serve the new construction. subject of feature stories for local Fees charged to the developer are based and state newspapers on a set amount per residential unit. Pasco ■ The Plan will provide extensive charges approximately $600 per unit, but material for use by the Parks and this amount has proven too low to ensure Recreation Department in all public park land is acquired and improved to keep relations activities pace with new development. ■ Publicity given to the accomplishment of each objective of the Plan will ensure continuing Gaining Support for public interest. the Plan ■ Copies ofthe Plan can be used extensively by the Chamber of Commerce as the official guide for This plan sets forth an ambitious course future recreation development and of action requiring the cooperation and an expansion program assistance of all members of the park and recreation staff and other city departments. ■ Maps and layout plans of individual Special interest groups are also important areas can be reproduced for to implement all the recommendations of illustrated presentations this plan. They can be organized to assist in ■ Appropriate sections of the Plan the acquisition and development of facilities. can be exhibited at strategic public For this reason, it is important that the key locations such a store windows, recommendations of this plan be shared theaters, and restaurant lobbies 10 Capital Improvements & Implementation • Scale models of key areas prepared as school projects can be exhibited at the same localities • The Plan can be the subject of discussion at civic club meetings • The Plan can provide source material for special radio and panel programs • Copies of the Plan should be ✓ride;y distributed to all interested agencies and individuals • The Plan will assist the community in obtaining state and federal funding assistance. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan Update - December 2010 11 Appendix A Pasco Parks Inventory and Recommendations for Improvements Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion Contents Major Issues Safety Accessibility Maintenance Demand Specific Park Inventory, Conditions And Recommendations Baseball Stadium / Soccer Complex Cable Bridge Park Casa Del Sol Park Centennial Park Chiawana Park Desert Dunes Park First Place Park Heritage Park Highland Park Island Park Kurtzman Park Liberty Park Library Park Lincoln Park Lucas Park McGee Park Mem orial Park Mercier Park Peanuts Park Richardson Park Riverview Park Road 36 Soccer Fields Schlagel Park Senior Citizens Center Sunny Meadows Park Sun Willows Golf Course Sylvester Park Vintage Park Volunteer Park Wade Park Wayside Park Martin Luther King Community Center City Hall Activity Center Trail Systems Mich a a I T a r r a I 1 ■ Landscap. a A r o h itact 1 4 2 1 N M a a d c. w w c. c. d L a n a S u i t a 1 5 it L i k. a r t y L a k e , W A 9 9 0 1 P { 5 i) 5 } 7 1 0 5 5 5 1 m t e r r e I I (a) s c• c• c c• m . o c• m M e m b e r A m e r i c a n S o c i e t y o f L a n d s c a p e A i c h i t e c t s Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation The Studio Cascade, MT-LA team met with the City of Pasco staff m embers concerning existing park facilities, conditions, concerns and elementary school playground. This assessment is based on a tour of the individual parks and conversations with Parks staff. It is intended to provide an overview of the existing conditions in Pasco Parks. Conditions considered include: ■ Overall Condition o Excellent, Good, Average, or Poor based on: plant material, vandalism, ADA access, — field and court conditions, and ,'- playgrounds. ■ Playgrounds ■ Fields and Courts '-- .� a ■ Pools and Support Facilities rj ■ Parking and Access ,, . -Joy, ■ Irrigation Systems ■ Recommended improvements During the tour of the parks several major issues became evident and suggestions formed. The Major Issues included: Safety • Many older play equipment installations have ' features that do not currently m eet the safety ,vz standards for play equipment. For example: compacted areas below play equipment and ' insufficient depth of bark, seen at Volunteer and Richardson parks, among others. • Som a neighborhood park recreation fields have little or no maintenance at bases resulting in eroded areas at home plate and the bases. • Some basketball courts have had soil erode onto them resulting in a possible slip hazard. Other courts are in need of new surfacing. • Soccer fields have eroded at goals and near center y field providing an uneven play surface. • The trail system has areas in need of widening and lowering to provide safe routes. • Sightlines in and around parks need to be assessed, especially at Centennial and Cable Bridge Parks. Pasco parks department should consider working with Pasco Police to identify major sightline and safety issues. • Assess the safety at all parks, remove trip hazards, such as those seen at Desert Dunes Park and others. Accessib ility 2 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation • Many of the existing the parks are not fully accessible, lacking pathways to key amenities. Many play equipment areas do not have an accessible route serving the equipment. • Many of the parks are need improvements in accessibility to site amenities such as drinking fountains, picnic shelters, play courts, barbeques tables and benches. Maintenance • Surfacing is needed for the some courts and other paved activity areas. _ id • Basketball hoops had been damaged by users _ — hanging on the rims. _ • Graffiti and vandalism evident on many park features such as picnic tables, park signs, play equipment and other areas. Concrete picnic tables should be replaced with expanded metal tables to reduce writing surfaces. Crawl tubes current target of vandalism and should be removed from play structures. • Many site amenities are broken, damaged, or aged. Drinking fountains, benches, garbage cans, signs and other site furnishings need to be replaced if broken or decaying. Examples of this can be seen at: McGee, Centennial, Memorial, and Lucas parks, among others. T, • Maintenance of plant material and trees is , "+ necessary. Many shrubs and trees are dead or dying and in need of replacement. t.. • Kurtzman and Richardson pools have growing t� JIFAW maintenance problems and need in need of renovation, replacement, or remodel. • Consider the implementation of irrigation systems throughout the parks that are connected to weather stations and moisture 1- sensors to reduce overwatering. • Consider the installation of pet waste disposal areas at locationswhere problems are noticed or complaints occurs. Dem and • Current demand for play fields, soccer fields in particular is much higher than current fields can accommodate. Road 35 Soccer Fields can see around goo people for a weekend tournament on four fields. Deterioration of fields is very apparent. • Increased demand for extended hours of field use results in a need for field lighting. 3 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion 4 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Baseball ? Socecr connrslex Sottbnu comocx 65 acres s K-. 6520 Homerun Road Professional minor league stadium, 4,000 seats, 1 ,000 car parking lot, concession and restroom areas, lit for night games, 15 field soccer complex, 1 lit field with seating for 2,000, restroom/ concessions, picnic/playground, staging areas. Softball complex is 28 -- acres with six softball fields, concession building with restrooms, water playground, playground, lighted for night games, two sand volleyball courts, RV parking and parking on 3.3 acres. Overall Ceonditian The baseball complex (1995) is generally in good overall condition. There are ongoing maintenance issues that include replacement of damaged curb in parking lots. The soccer complex (1994) is generally in good overall condition. The turf was in very good shape with little damage. Late season conditions should be evaluated to - modify maintenance practices as necessary. Soccer goals, irrigation heads, valve boxes and other constructed elements should be inspected at least twice a year to check for damage, protrusions and trip hazards. The softball complex 12000) is in very good condition overall. The fields, turf and facilities have been well maintained and there are no major renovation issues. PI ayg ro u nd s The playground associated with the soccer complex is currently not ADA accessible and requires maintenance of safety surfacing, such as replacing bark and removing bark from nearby sidewalks. Fi eld s No major issues. Support Facilities No major issues. Parking and Access Parking lot signage could be improved. Irriaatian Sy sterns No major issues. necom. mended improvements • Improve entry signage and directional control signage within parking lots. • Establish a tree replacement program. 5 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion ■ Assess trees at south end near trail for replacement. These appear diseased. 6 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Cable Bridge Park 1 acre 1310 South 10'h Avenue Historical Monument describing the old bridge that was replaced by the Cable Bridge. Pathway and trail LIG connection to the River Trail. a , Overall Condition . Average overall condition with minor routine maintenance need for walks, shrub areas, trees and litter pickup. Address broken stone memorial. Topography gives potential for hiding areas. Plavarounds Not Applicable Fi eld s Not Applicable Support Facilities Walking trail, interpretive signage, and bike racks. Park-ing jand Aecess Limited parking and access. Potential for major trailhead to access the levee trail system connecting up and down stream to Sacajawea State Park and Chiawana County Park. Irrigation Systems 44 Adequate - Recommended I mDrovem ents ■ Tree replacement ■ Replace broken stone memorial. • No entry signage, include signage to match other park signs. • Trailhead improvements for connection to the River Trail. Installation of trailhead kiosk with maps and trail information. ■ Install lighting at trailhead. ■ Bicycle services — possible air compressor for :.yr r filling tires. ■ Interpretive signage as component of overall River _ Trail interpretive signage program . — Casa Del Sol Park. 5 acres 4802 Laredo Dr. Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation New Neighborhood Park with basketball court, picnic shelters, playground, restroom, volleyball court, and a walking trail. Overall condition of park is excelent. Playgrounds Playground is new and in good condition. Division of equipment by age appropriation is good and ADA ramps are present. Fields Basketball courts in very good condition. Adjustable hoops and surfacing new, court lines in good condition. r - Support Facilities - f Supporting facilities include picnic shelters, playground, tether ball, and portable toilet with shelter. Parking and Access Parking is limited to on street. Access is adequate however connection to adjacent houses to the south by path or trail would be beneficial. Irrigation Svstems Irrigation is adequate slight yellowing of turf in locations. Review head and fertilizer coverage. Recommended I mprovem ents • Develop a trail to connect houses to the south. • Remove trip hazard (metal post cut to 4" above concrete). • Connect second picnic shelter by path for ADA accessibility f e p_ _ 'I =l S Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Centennial Park 2 Acres North 5"' Avenue and West Perl Street Playground, picnic area, swings, small path and basketball court. ai � q`, t L r `e Overall Condition The park is in poor condition overall. It appears to get y heavy use and many elements show heavy wear. Vandalism, such as damage to amenities like drinking - fountains and picnic shelters, as well as graffiti is a major issue. Plavarounds The playground is in average condition. Issues include lack of an accessible route from the sidewalk to the playground, seating and vandalism in the form of writing and graffiti. Fields? Courts Existing basketball court appears to be well used and is located well away from the playground to minimize conflicts. The surfacing needs replacement along with one of the hoops which is missing. Some large cracking beginning to occur in concrete. Suriyort. Facilities Picnic shelters and benches are a target for vandalism. The shelter has holes in the roof, many bent roof slats, and graffiti on posts. Drinking fountain is not functional, �, . missing full pieces. Parking and Access y On-street parking only, adequate for size of park. Irrigation Systems No recommendations + Recommended I mprovem ents _. ■ Resurface the basketball court ■ Tree replacement r addition ■ Paint or modify fence on north property line with vines to minimize graffiti. ■ Remove asphalt path along top berm or connect path to sidewalk. Consider lowering/modifying berm to open up park to views of the north property line and fence. ■ Improve r' replace lighting. ■ Replace or re-paint park sign and benches that currently are worn and victim to graffiti. ■ Replace missing swing and basketball hoop. ■ Drinking fountain damaged and not working, replace. 9 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion ■ Replace concrete picnic table with expanded metal table. 10 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Chiaw an Park . Franklin County 127 Acres. 25 Developed 2201 Road 96 Picnic areas, access to trail, playground, and volleyball court, boat launch. Overall Condition ' _ Overall condition of the park is average with aging amenities. Playground consists of old metal equipment, parking is in good condition, and access to trail could be improved. n PIaycirounds Playground is consists of all metal equipment with sand surfacing. Playground should be replaced and addition of . accessible paths and ramps should be included. r Fi eld s Not applicable SuL]pQrt Facilities Facilities include boat launch at west end and picnic areas. No restroom s available. Parking and Access Parking is adequate. Entrance to trail and pedestrian �• circulation should be improved. Trail entry currently follows an access road, with no defined walk or sidewalk for pedestrians. - I Irrigation systems The irrigation system is average showing areas of bare and dry spots that need be assessed. Recommended improvements ■ Renovation of playground, replace play , equipment, safety surfacing, and provide ADA access. ■ Improve entry to trail ` ■ Addition of picnic benches and shelters ■ Addition of benches and trash cans r:• ■ Addition of restroom facilities II Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Desert Duncs Perk 5 acres Cathedral Drive Desert Dunes is a relatively new neighborhood park with basketball court, picnic area, playground, restrooms, and walking trail. Overall Condition Park is relatively new and condition is excellent overall. Entries are located at every corner. Wall around utilities is aesthetically appealing. No park sign is posted as of now. Plavarounds Playgrounds are new and provide ADA access. Fi eld s Basketball courts new and in very good condition. Surfacing has many years of use left. Support Facilities ` Q, Picnic shelter new and in good condition with path connecting. Drinking fountains and garbage cans are new, functional, and positioned in good locations. Parkina and Access Park is limited to on street parking. Access at every corner is good and walking path around park ideal. Steep slope potentially problematic for some users. Irrigation Systems Irrigation system is good overall; a couple of small dry spots need be addressed. Recom m ended I mprovem ents • Some protruding objects need be removed to reduce trip hazards. • Circular concrete pads currently empty. Could place picnic table or tether ball posts here. Otherwise remove. 12 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion First Place Park Acres New park not listed on city website yet. Overall Condition New neighborhood park. Good Condition. Plavarounds New playground equipment, good condition. Fields Large field area. Support Facilities Portable bathroom and shelter and picnic shelters available. Parkina and Access I rriaation Systems Adequate Recommended improvements 13 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Hcritaac Park 5 acres Road 42 and W Park Street Heritage Park includes picnic areas, play field, walking ' trail, small gravel parking lot, and a playground. _ Overall Condition gig Overall park condition good. There is room to set up practice or youth soccer fields. Lighting along path is adequate. No major maintenance issues are present. Playgrounds Playgrounds in good condition has good ADA access ramps. Fields Large grass area in good condition and would support one, maybe two soccer fields or more if used for younger children. Suaaort Facilities Picnic shelter in good condition however needs path rtt' access to comply with ADA requirm ents. Parking and Access On-street parking is available and one small gravel lot as well, however no ADA parking is available. Path connects two neighborhoods. Irricalian Gy2tcrns Irrigation system is adequate, not problems visible. Recommended improvements ■ Add park sign at west entry. ■ Barbeques would be a positive addition. _ ■ Logs at gravel parking may need replacement in near future, potential to expand lot slightly and add concrete curbing instead. 14 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Hiahl-and Park 10 Acres Wehe and Broadway 'A l J Highland Park includes basketball courts, softball field, picnic area, playground, restrooms and football fields. Overall Condition Recent improvements to the park in restoration of the football field and replacement of the playground equipment. The restroom facility is in need of renovation. m c The basketball court needs replacem ent/repair of one goal and surfacing. The overall condition is average. Plavarounds ADA accessibility to playground is good, equipment is in good condition. Access to benches could be improved. MW Fields/ Courts ; Basketball court equipment repair and surfacing needed. Asphalt in good condition. Basketball standards bent. Support Facilities Restroom facility, football equipment storage, drinking `- fountains. Restrooms are in need or renovation or 1 replacement. They are currently dirty and show signs of vandalism . Parking and Access Good parking lot and pedestrian access overall. ADA _ '�—,�; parking is available. Path leading down through # �' basketball court could cause potential conflict. f Irrigation Systems Irrigation system is satisfactory. Some browning and bare spots where heavy use occurs, review maintenance. Recommended Improvements • Resurface and repair of basketball courts and equipment. • Improve accessibility site amenities such as benches. • Renovate existing restroom facility or at least Re-paint to one color. y ■ Construct ADA accessible drinking fountains. ""°` ■ Rem ove or paint over graffiti on drinking fountains �. and other areas. • Additional garbage cans would be beneficial along path to football fields and near basketball courts. • Addition of picnic shelter would be a positive improvement. 15 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion • Additional lighting needed along pathways and football fields to provide for extended hours of use. • Wooden bleachers need to be assessed for use and size additional may be needed and some may need replacement in future. Consider replacing with metal bleachers. 16 Park and Recreation Inventory and I rn rovernents Recorn rn endation I sland Park Five Acres 8001 Wrigley Drive Playground, volleyball court, basketball court, covered picnic tables, walking path and open turf areas. o , Overall Condition N The park is a relatively new neighborhood park and is in excellent condition overall. All elements of the park have been maintained well. Plavarounds The playground equipment is in nearly new condition and has engineered wood fiber safety surfacing and an access - ramp from the sidewalk to the surface of the playground. Fi eld s The open turf areas are not configured for permanent fields and are generally good shape. Basketball court in relatively good condition surfacing beginning to crack IF however has a couple years of use left. Support Facilities Picnic shelters in good condition, only one is connected by walking path. Parking and Access On-street parking. Good pedestrian access at the four corners of the park. Each intersection has four way stop. Irri+iation Systems Irrigation system was new with the park. Recommended improvements �`� • Additional trees could be planted to provide shade in summer and to define spaces within the park - more effectively. • Installation of one or two additional trash cans may reduce litter. • Park sign is cracked and broken at corners, replace or fix. • Many exposed utilities could possibly be a safety issue. • Assess trees on site, some in need of replacement. Add to tree canopy to increase the parks shaded areas. • Addition of ADA path to picnic shelter. 1"i Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Kurtzm an Park 7 Acres Wehe Avenue and Alton Street Swimming pool, wading pool, tennis courts, basketball court, volleyball court, playground, picnic area, Martin Luther King Community Center (3500 square foot �L gymnasium , game rooms, classrooms, and offices) and public restroom s. - �L � 3 Overall Condition The park has a large number of major facilities for a seven acre park. Overall, the facilities are in average condition with recent installation of playgrounds, a small pool, courts and Martin Luther King Community Center needing renovation. Playarounds The playgrounds are in good condition but lack ADA accessibility and are situated in a good location for use. Fields The softball field is serviceable but in need of renovation. - Grass and weeds growing within diamond and bleachers worn. Soccer fields needs maintenance, showing drainage issues and large holes in turf. Field also appears much smaller than regulation. Basketball courts has no surfacing however asphalt and current court lines are in good condition. .L t Suonort Faeilitics ° `F Martin Luther King, Jr. Center Swimming Pool and Bathhouse Shelter Pasco Police Mini Station Parking and Access Parking at King Center On-street parking for pool and softball field Irrigation Systems Upgrades to softball field should include refinement of irrigation system. Recommended Imorovements •`rA ' • Renovate softball field o New backstop o Install outfield fence o Field lighting o Bleachers o Irrigation system improvements to upgrade play • Renovate basketball court o Resurface 18 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation o Install lighting • Renovation of soccer field • Serious drainage problems need be addressed along all edges of field. • Deterioration of field near goals and center ' of field • Renovate covered shelter • New roof • Resurface floor • Install lighting • Add new landscaping • Maintenance of landscaping at King Center sign ' • Tree planting and replacement _ • Pool and bathhouse o Pool and bathhouse need renovation; however construction of a new Aquatic x Center will require evaluation of Pasco's needs for aquatic facilities. • Construct paved walking paths providing accessible routes to play areas and some picnic tables. Currently no path to restroom facilities. • Picnic tables o Currently no picnic tables • Construct two accessible drinking fountains in conjunction with picnic tables and pathways. Reposition barbeques at flat areas not on steep slopes and near picnic tables. 19 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Liberty Park 5 acres 4200 John Deere Lane — New Neighborhood Park with basketball court, picnic _-- area, volleyball court and playground. Overall Condition Good condition overall with some minor issues. Playgrounds Playground in good condition overall with minor vandalism present. Sand tot lot separated from other play equipment. ADA access is good. Fi eld s Turf is in good condition. Basketball court is in relatively good condition however the surfacing is beginning to see cracking. Support Facilities � Picnic shelter has small holes in roof otherwise in relatively good condition. Picnic table coating has also been vandalized. Parking and Access Parking is on street and access is good. Path leads to picnic shelter for easy access. Irrigation Systems Irrigation is adequate. Recom m ended I mDrovem ents '' � - ■ Inventory of site trees, for species and health is necessary. Currently only deciduous trees are found in the park, the addition of evergreens r would be beneficial. 20 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Library Park 1320 W Hopkins St. Landscaping around library including memorial garden. %,erall C�nditiran -- - a The turf and trees are in poor condition with the memorial garden in significant disrepair. Playgrounds Not Applicable Fi eld s Not Applicable Support Facilities Not Applicable Parking and AcccU Parking in the Library parking lot. Irrigation Systems Adequate Recommended imr)rovements _ • Renovation of the memorial garden o Remove broken concrete • Remove weeds • Plant new perennials Consider coordination with garden club for maintenance • Tree replacement 21 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Lincoln Park 5 acres 5602 Wrigley Relatively new with basketball courts, picnic area, playground, restrooms, and walking trail connecting cul- de-sacs. Nearby bus stop, children use park walk to reach stop. f ± -K Overall Condition The park is a relatively new neighborhood park and in - excellent condition. Playgrounds The playground in divided appropriately by age specific equipment and has ADA access. Swings and other equipment in good condition. Fields Basketball courts are new and in good condition. Water from irrigation running over court could cause wear of surfacing in the future. Suooart Facilities Portable restrooms and picnic shelter available. Parking and Access On street parking only. Good pedestrian circulation connecting different areas of neighborhood. Irricatian Sy2tems Irrigation is adequate, no major problems. : Recommended I mgrovem ents ■ Addition of a park rules sign. ■ Regular maintenance of portable restroom should occur. Currently dirty and has a broken handle. ■ Currently only one light post at either end of the walking path. Consider additional lighting within park along path to provide a safe walk between neighborhoods at night. ■ Consider path leading to basketball court. ■ Assess tree condition. All trees are young, some in poor condition with dead or dying branches and damaged trunks. 22 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Lucas Park 2 Acres 14th and Lincoln Drive Playground, swings, picnic area and open turf area. O%,erall Conalition The park is in average good condition. A Playground renovation was recently completed. Heavy noise from the f' + freeway. Playgrounds Playground is new and in great condition. Noted as popular by users. Cable design ideal for addressing vandalism issues of writing and burning of tubes. Fi eld s Open turf area to west is not programmed for any activities. Best utilization is for soccer./T-ball practice for younger athletes. Currently has signs discouraging it's use for baseball related activities. Support Facilities A Shelters and tables show heavy signs of vandalism. Parking and Access 5 Access from the neighborhood is good for pedestrians ~ ; with lower levels of traffic passing by the park. Parking is on the street and adequate for the apparent level of use. Irricaticn S�+stcrr«s . Irrigation is adequate. a Recommended improvements ,. ■ Install site lighting ■ Add concrete tables and pads ■ Systematically replace evergreen trees along , street with larger deciduous trees to allow greater visual access to park and reduce sense of enclosure. ■ Provide ADA access paths to play equipment and integral benches. ■ Construct basketball court in western portion of the park with berming to provide separation from T_ open field. ■ Upgrade landscaping at park sign with separation of irrigation system, installation of mow curb, replacement of rail road tie posts and plantings. ■ Maintenance of swing set area, curbing higher than 1 2" above bark in areas with weeds becoming a problem. ■ Paint sound wall all one color. 23 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation McGee Park 10 Acres 4601 Horizon Drive Play area, soccer fields and open turf area located in '. conjunction with McGee Elementary School. Overall Condition . r The park is in average condition with the play equipment replacement completed recently. P I a v a r o u n d s The play equipment was replaced recently and bark now replaces pea gravel as the safety surfacing. There is no ADA access available. Fields The fields are in generally good condition with routine yearly maintenance required to support increasing use of the soccer fields. a $uaaort Facilitios Picnic shelter showing some signs of vandalism. Parking and Access Parking is along the street or located at McGee Elementary School. Access to the park is provided with crosswalks to sidewalks on the park side of Horizon Drive. Irrigation Systems Irrigation is adequate. Recom mended improvements • Plantings missing at entry bed. Add perennials and or shrubs in the entry planting spaces, maintain plantings at entry. • Plant additional trees to provide better delineation between park and school. ■ Addition of drinking fountain. ■ Addition of more safety surfacing for playground is needed in the near future. ■ Entry sign showing extreme weathering. Replace or re-paint in near future. -q ■ Provide ADA access pathways to both picnic shelters. 2t Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Memorial Park 13 Acres 14th Avenue and Shoshone Street Swimming Pool, wading pool, picnic shelter, playground, restrooms, basketball court, softball fields, volleyball courts I � Overall Condition '~{t �, r x 3fy Memorial Park is Pasco's most heavily used park. The ;' # � `J existing facilities are in average shape with a number of facilities requiring renovation or replacement in the next few years. P I a v a r o u n d s The play equipment is relatively new and has adequate safety surfacing. The equipment is not served by an - accessible route. An accessible route to the play equipment could be incorporated into the parks overall pedestrian circulation system . Fi eld s The existing softball fields are in need of renovation. Lighting, new bleachers, outfield fencing, and up keep of the fields should all be considered. Suoyort Facilities The support facilities include covered picnic areas, play shelters, restrooms, and the pool/concession building. A q need for an additional picnic shelter to support for groups to 30 people has been suggested. The existing covered '- play shelter is difficult to monitor by the police and - suffers from graffiti. Smaller picnic shelters are to be added in the near future. Parkins) and Access The majority of the parking is located in a lot adjacent to the swimming pool. Parking lot in need of renovation or re-organization. Additional parking is located along the perimeter of the park. Pedestrian access into the park from the adjacent neighborhood. There is a need for paved pathways within the park to make major facilities 4 s accessible. Irrigation Systems The irrigation system as with other facilities will require - increased maintenance with age. - --Yang=..-.. Recommended improvements Parking: ■ Resurface parking along north side of park. ' ■ Install perimeter landscaping at main parking lot 25 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation to extend tree canopy of the park into the NE corner of the parking lot. ■ Implement a tree removal / replacement program that results in the identification and removal of 4 hazard trees and the planting of two trees for each tree removed or at least one additional tree annually. ■ Install additional concrete picnic benches and pads. ■ Install new benches and pads ■ Construct a new open picnic shelter for groups up to 30. ■ Remove unused restrooms ■ Replace drinking fountains and provide ADA access to them . ■ Renovate existing covered shelter ' o Nev; roof o Resurface floor -- o New lighting • Modify structure to increase visibility to the interior from the adjacent parks and streets. • Ongoing routine maintenance. • Renovate softball fields o New backstops o Lighting for both fields o Bleacher replacement • Equipment / base storage box replacem ent • Irrigation upgrades • Add paved pathways connecting all park elements. • Add new landscaping as renovation ? new construction occur. • Renovate existing volleyball area and provide berming for seating and court separation. Plant additional trees to define area and provide spatial definition. Maintain sand and turf line. • Add additional park signage, currently only one at south east corner. ■ Basketball courts in need of renovation. ■ Shelters adjacent to the pool. i 26 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Mercier Park 3 Acres 7'�' Avenue and 'B' Street Basketball court, playground, soccer field, softball field Overall Condition The park is in average to poor condition with new court surfacing needed, wear of fields, and vandalism apparent. A new playground and park sign have been installed with additional trees planted. The park is well used and provides a balance of open space with active elements. - Playcirounds The playground is relatively new with good safety 1 accessible surfacing yet showing signs of vandalism. No ADA access is available for the playground Fields and Courts The soccer field is in average condition with turf maintenance to repair areas around goals and other wear and tear. The soccer goals should be replaced with moveable ones and adjusting the location of the goals to spread the wear out should be considered. The basketball court is heavily used by the neighborhood children. The court needs to be resurfaced. Supaort Facilities Picnic areas have good access. They are showing signs of vandalism in the forms of graffiti and damage. - Parking and Access On-street parking is typical with good pedestrian access from the neighborhood. Irrigation S v s t e m s The irrigation system is in good condition with a couple dry spots that may need to be evaluated in the future. Recommended improvements ■ Tree plantings - recommend two per year for the next five years. =� ■ Resurface the basketball court and replace hoops. ■ Replace the soccer goals ■ Renovate turf as necessary - ■ Remove damaged crawl tube in playground ■ Sign broken in one corner. ■ Address vandalism issues. ■ Consider lowering height of rule signs in order to engage visitors in reading them. ■ Add ADA ramps to playground equipment. 27 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion 28 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Peanuts Park 1 Acre 4t" and West Lewis Street Urban plaza spanning Lewis Street with a non-functioning _ fountain. Adjacent to the Farmer's Market. Overall Condition Peanuts Park is in need of renovation. A master plan for the park was completed in 1999. The master plan has a detailed description of the existing conditions. Plant material is greatly lacking and the water feature is no longer functional. Plavarounds Not applicable Fi eld s Not Applicable Support Facilities Restrooms: The master plan notes that the restrooms are in need of renovation and have been an ongoing concern with regards to criminal activity and vandalism in the park. Restrooms now consist of portable toilets with shelter Parking and Acccss The parking lot to the south and the parking along 4th ,, • Street are adequate for the park. Access from the main park on the south side of Lewis to the north side of Lewis � is difficult. Pedestrians need to go to the crosswalk at 4t h and Lewis. Irrigation Svstems The irrigation system needs to be completely replaced when the park is renovated. Particular attention should be paid to ensuring that the system does not cause damage to adjacent buildings and/or flooding in basements. Recommended improvements V 29 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Richardson Park 5 Acres 19th and Perl Streets Outdoor swimming pool, new playground equipment, basketball court, recreational softball field and picnic - -- area. Overall Condition The park is in poor condition with the recent installation of the new playground equipment. The pool and pool _ •ter building are in need of renovation. Maintenance and turf repair are needed in various areas and the basketball court is in need of renovation. Plavaround The play equipment is new with safety surfacing that is accessible and does have ADA access from the sidewalk. Fields and Courts' The existing softball field is for recreational use only and has significant erosion at the bases. The backstop needs to be removed or replaced. It has been suggested that the softball field be replaced with a practice soccer field or multi-use field. The basketball court is in average shape. There are some areas around the court that need renovation or modification to restore turf and/or reduce the amount of soil eroding onto the court. k A Pool and Pool Support Facilities I The potential development of a regional Aquatic Center will lead to a discussion of the role that neighborhood - pools play in Pasco's park and recreation program. The pool and pool building were identified for renovation - �t in the 1998 plan and renovation is still necessary for _f r continued operation. Talk of a potential splash pad to - replace pool in the future. Parking and Access On street parking is available and pedestrian access �.• from the neighborhood to the north. Pedestrian access from the west across N 20`" Ave via a pedestrian overpass. There is a potential for pedestrian-vehicular conflict crossing W Pearl Street due to the close _ proximity to the intersection of W. Pearl and N. 20th Ave. Irrigation Sy2tems The current irrigation system is adequate. The system will need to modified. 30 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Recommended improvements- Richardson Park • Renovate or replace softball field with a multi-use + . field. ?. • Install an accessible path from south end to access � y ' the playground and drinking fountain. • Conduct a hazard tree evaluation and replace trees identified for replacement. Replace each tree that is removed with two trees. • Renovate pool and bathhouse as determined by evaluation of neighborhood pool requirements after regional Aquatic Center is developed. ■ Post park rules sign ■ Add additional lighting near playground and swing set area. ■ Assessment of grade change between top of curb and safety surfacing in swing area necessary. 1 Change greater than 12" in locations. ■ Addition of swings that older children can use ■ Addition of ADA ramp into playground area. ■ Replacem ent of elements such as trash cans and drinking fountains. otl ■ Replace picnic table with expanded metal table. ■ Address vandalism issues 31 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Riverview Park 17 Acres 1700 South 'A' Street Picnic area, four Little League Fields, One Babe Ruth Field, concession stands, entry to trail, and fishing pond. Overall Condition The four field complex baseball fields are leased and F,,s maintained by the Pasco Little League. A single Babe Ruth field is maintained by that organization. Several projects are proposed for the remainder of the park. - These projects will increase use in the areas adjacent to the baseball fields and require higher levels of maintenance. Two fields have been taken out of service however remain on site, unused or maintained. The site is in average condition with room for many improvements. Playgrounds Not applicable Fields There have been seven fields historically, including one – adult baseball field. Two of the fields are no longer -- - used. Upgrades to the irrigation system are necessary. - Support Facilities The primary support facilities are operated by the Little League. These include the concession stands for the four field complex. Parking and Access Parking and access is adequate. Access is by car and non-motorized. Sidewalks or paths to link the park entry - to the Sacagawea Heritage Trail are not currently _ available. — Irriaatian Systems Irrigation system will need upgrades and modifications. Recommended Imarovements • Develop a master plan for this park that incorporates the trail, a trail head, play area improvements and support facilities. • Remove unused fields and consider installation of practice soccer fields. • Add drinking fountains at the trail head and fields. • Update drives and parking lots, pave and curb 32 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion ■ Upgrade irrigation system based on master plan improvements; evaluate system over watering apparent in some locations. ■ Add new identification and directional signage ■ Add picnic tables and pads ■ Construct paved pathways leading to used fields. ■ Develop swimming beach on the Columbia River ■ Construct fishing dock or pier ■ Increase management of existing trees. Conduct a hazard tree evaluation, remove hazard trees and plant two trees for every one removed. ■ Construct bridge over irrigation canal ■ Add site security lighting and ensure access to trail head for law enforcement ■ Install new play equipment ■ Install trail and trail head with information kiosks and interpretive signage. ■ No picnic shelters are available, provide shelters. 33 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Road 36 Soccer Fields 10 Acres Road 36 Four soccer fields and with gravel parking lot. Overall Condition The soccer fields are heavily used, in average to poor condition, and have significant wear at the goals and in — the middle of the fields. The goals were replaced recently and are in good condition. The parking lot is unpaved and there are no restroom facilities other than portable toilets. Plavarounds Not Applicable i Fields Four soccer fields on two terraces. The fields are heavily used (up to 900 players during Sunday tournaments) and in desperate need of renovation. Year round use makes maintenance difficult. Su000rt Facilities Water fountain is in need of replacement. Restroom facilities consist of portable toilets. Parking and Acccss Parking lot is unpaved and very rough with many pot holes. Irrigation Systems Irrigation system is adequate. l Recom m ended I mDrovem ents ■ Pave parking lot ■ Renovate turf — grade fields as necessary '4 _ ■ Provide restrooms or alternative to meet demand of practices and weekend tournaments involving up to 900 people. ■ Install drinking fountains and hookup for concession services. ■ Replace netting behind goals. ■ Assess fencing and replace where necessary. _ 34 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Schl-aale Park 3 Acres South 4`" Avenue and West Washington Street i Public boat launch, full service marina, covered boat moorage, picnic area and playground. Ago- Overall Condition The park is in average condition with signs of heavy use and som a vandalism. The trees are mature and the turf shows signs of wear in areas. Playgrounds Not applicable Fi eld s Not applicable -V Sunnort Facilitics Restrooms are in need of repair and currently fenced off. The boat ramp and dock are in good condition. The marina is privately operated. _ Parking end Recess Access to the park is through a transitional neighborhood surrounded by an industrial area. Directional signage is very unclear. The parking area seems adequate with good separation between the boat , ramp and parking lot. Irriaalian Sy sterns The irrigation system is adequate. Recommended improvements ■ Prepare a master plan to evaluate alternatives to enhance the park and boat launch ■ New directional signage from Ainsworth ■ Children's playground. ■ New picnic tables and pads ■ Addition of covered picnic shelter ■ Pave parking lot and install wheel stops ■ Install drinking fountain ,. ■ Install curbing around driveway and parking lot ■ Identify any potential hazard trees and remove, plant two trees for every tree removed. Prune �t trees as necessary. ■ Install security lighting 35 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Senior Activity Center NI A 1315 N 7th Avenue 18,500 square foot center with m eeting rooms, pool rooms, cards kitchen, dance floor reading area, health screening, and offices offering a variety of programs for seniors. p Overall Condition +- The overall condition of the building and grounds is average. Maintenance is needed in planting beds for weed control. Plavarounds Not applicable Fields "Irk Not applicable . Support Facilities Not applicable Parking jand Aeeess Parking and access are adequate. Irriaativn Svstems Irrigation system is adequate. Recommended Improvements ■ Maintenance of shrub beds would benefit grounds. 36 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Sunny Meadows Park 5 Acres Robert Wayne Drive Neighborhood park with two small picnic shelters, playground, basketball courts, field and pathways. +� Overall Condition I' The park is in excellent condition. All the equipment and site furnishings remain in nearly new condition. Lighting along path is good. There is some sign of mower damage to the new trees. Plavqround The playground is in good condition with wearing in some { locations. No ADA access is present. Fields Soccer field/open play field on the south side of the park is in good condition. Support Facilities � Two picnic shelters. Steel supports of shelters show some signs of rust and corrosion at their base. Parking and Access No dedicated parking. Access to the park is excellent with a pathway connecting to an adjacent block. Potential for � a full walking path around open field. Irrigation Svstems Irrigation system is adequate. Showing signs of runoff on to court causing erosion of court surfacing. Recom m ended I mprovem ents • Inventory trees. Protect new trees from damage caused by mowers, remove dying trees, move trees in conflict with open field. • Evaluate corrosion on columns for shelter and implement preservation to control rust. • Evaluate existing irrigation system in relation to basketball courts. • Addition of ADA access ramp to playground. 37 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion Sun Willows Golf Course 132 Acres Overall Condition Playgrounds Fields Support Facilities Parking and Access Irrigation Systems Recommended improvements 38 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Sylvester Park 3 Acres 5'�' Avenue and Sylvester Street ". Tennis courts, basketball courts, playground equipment, SYLVESTER `A' rose garden, and picnic area. Overall Condition The overall condition of the park is average. The play equipment is new. The tennis courts and basketball �a 'w ` courts were renovated in 1998 and 2000. However are in need of renovation again. The rose garden in need of renovation and circulation should be assessed. Plavaround I y" The play equipment is good condition with some paint chipping and writing on equipment. Fi eld sa: . Tennis courts are getting heavy use and have signs of weathering. Basketball courts are in relatively good condition. Suooart F:�cilitics The restroom building was locked and not accessible, one portable toilet is available located near courts. Parkina and Acccss Parking and access are adequate for the level of use in the park. Pedestrian access from the adjacent - neighborhoods is good. Circulation within the park should - be evaluated. '- Irrigation Systems The irrigation system is adequate. Recommended I marovem ents • Add concrete picnic tables and pads, replace vandalized tables. • Rehabilitate tennis court surfacing and lighting. • Ongoing evaluation of existing trees to identify major pruning and removal due to tree hazards. Plant two trees for every tree removed. • Upgrade and renovate landscaping. Evaluate _ maintenance and support for existing rose — - garden and restore. Replace plantings at park sign. Address necessity of evergreen plantings south of playground. • Add ADA ramp into playground. 39 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion 40 Park and Recreation Inventory and Recorn rn endation FA Vinta+ae Park 8 acres - 5705 Road 84 Park relatively new and connected with Maya Angelou Elementary School including walking path, restrooms, – parking, playground, and picnic area. Overall Condition Overall condition is good with new amenities and close proximity to school. Playgrounds Playground is in new and good condition with separation of equipment by age. Some paint chipping apparent. No ADA access is available. Fi eld s Two baseball fields are in good conditions with well- maintained turf. Backstops in good condition. Sight turf wear at home base. Suonort Facilities Portable restroom facility and picnic shelters are available a with ADA access. Parking and Access .- Park has very good access with a small parking at park =- entry and access from neighboring school walking path connecting all amenities. Irrigation $ystems dam~ Adequate. Recommended I morovem ents ■ Include ADA Ramps into playground areas. _ - ■ Routinely maintain safety surfacing, rake even and r - replace wood chips where level is insufficient- •11 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Volunteer Park 7 Acres 4t�' Avenue and Marie Street ��-- Playground equipment, meditation garden, walkway sitting area picnic area with historic train and caboose. Overall Condition F W t The park is in average condition with a number of maintenance issues. The location connects many key .` buildings in the area. PIayarounds The playground and swings are in good condition. The swings and playground are not connected to the walk 0 system with an accessible pathway and need ADA ramps into safety surfacing. r Fi eld s Not applicable Suoyort Facilities The new entrance gardens are in need of routine maintenance. The parking lot at the historic train in the north part of the park needs to be resurfaced and signage needs to be added. The gazebo structure in :t good condition. Parking and Access Parking along the street is adequate and pedestrian a;• ;Kr, access is good. Pedestrian access could be improved with the installation of the remaining pathway system from the master plan. -�' Irrigation Svstems > The irrigation system is currently adequate with a couple problem areas that need to be addressed. "<< Recommended improvements � • Complete installation of the improvements detailed in the master plan. • Resurface the parking lot and connection of ADA ramp to walking path. • Continue to remove hazardous trees as necessary and replace with trees identified in the tree planting master plan. Rem ove dead or dying' trees. _ k; r? • Construct a restroom facility as shown in the " �r master plan. ■ Replace / install drinking fountains. ■ Install additional picnic tables and benches. ■ Address broken concrete around swings 42 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion • Additional bark needed around play area and swings. • Address bare spots, weeds, and over growth in rose garden and perennial areas. Establish maintenance plan. • Address vandalism, writing and carving into site furnishings. • Address weathering and breaking of sign bases (tiles). • Addition of restroom facilities. 43 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Wade Park 25 Acres 601 Road 54 Walking and bicycle path, benches, parking, and boat launch. Overall Condition Park condition very good with excellent walking path and = -" access to the river. Path has good lines and way finding signage. Boat launch and dock in good condition. Playgrounds Not applicable Fi eld s Not applicable unnort Facilities Not applicable Parking and Access Two parking lots are available one paved near boat * - - launch, the other gravel. Pedestrian circulation very good, with great connections to nearby houses and neighborhood. Irrigation Svstcm .s Currently adequate. Recommcnded imnroveMonts d. ■ With the addition of picnic shelters, barbeques, and possible swimming area park would be even more popular. • Assess connection to trail that continues west to better circulation. • Additional lighting would be beneficial to provide a safe walking path at dusk and dawn hours. • Construct picnics shelter with picnic benches and barb eques. ■ Consider improvements to add a swimming area. ■ Construct kiosk at entry with trail map and other information. 44 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Ul+aysida P-a rk 1 Acre f E Lewis and Main ' Wayside Park is a small park with turf and neglected trees. It could be removed with the construction of the new Lewis Street tunnel. Overall Condition -41 tk Poor, no park sign, near high traffic road and no w amenities available. - - Playgrounds Not applicable a Fields Not applicable � p,. unnort Facilities ` Not applicable Parking and Access On street gravel parking with poor pedestrian access Irrigation Svstems Currently adequate Rc:comnjonded imnrcycments ■ Removal or intensive redesign. 45 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion Martin Luther Kona Comm unity Center 205 S. Wehe The current configuration of the play environment can be evaluated in terms of key design criteria for a good play environment. These are accessibility, safe challenge, diversity and clarity, graduated challenge and flexibility. Overall Condition Overall in good condition and closely connected to Kurtzman Park. Playarounds Fields Support Facilities Parkina and Access I rriaation Systems Recommended improvements 46 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom m endation Cifv Hall Activity Center 1 Acre 525 N. 3"d Avenue City offices, Activity Center (gym), two softball fields r` Overall Condition The overall condition of the facilities is good. Playgrounds Not avylicable Fields The recreational softball fields are in good shape however has no diamond. is Support Facilities Gymnasium and other support facilities located in City -_ Hall are in very good shape. Parking and Access - Parking and access are very good especially after City Hall is closed. Irriiantion Systems The irrigation system is adequate. Recommended improvements ■ Consider upgrading softball fields in the future when demand warrants. - ■ Provide drinking fountain at east end of fields. — � ■ Assess foundation plantings around building. Add - additional plantings where needed and maintain - - beds where needed. :,t ' �Ln 47 Park and Recreation Inventory and Improvements Recom mend at ion Trail Systems Key locations have been noted as in need of renovation. Sections between road 54 and 72 are in need of permission from the Army Core of Engineers to be lowered. In addition trail section from road 44 to 100 needs to be renovated and widened. Overall Condition Playarounds Fields Su000rt Facilities Parkins and Access Irrigation Systems Recommended improvements 8 Appendix B Recreational and Sports Facilities in Pasco Table 13.01 -Pasco parks and recreation facilities Professional minor league stadium, 4,000 seats, 1,000 car parking lot, concession and restroom areas, lighted for night garner, 15 field soccer complex,one tournamentIaid Baseball Stadlum/Soccer Special use 65,0 with seating for 2,000, rest rooTlecncessions, picnic area/ Complex/Softball Complex playground, staging areas. Softball complex is 28 acres with six softball fields, concessicn building with restrooms, water playground, playground, lightedfor right games,two sand volleyball courts, RV parking and parking on 3.3 acres Cable Bridge Park Special Use 1.0 Historic display,pathway, observation area Casa Del Sol Neighborhood 5.0 Basketball court, picnic shelter, playground,restroom, volleyball court, and walking trail Centennial Park Neighborhood 2.e Basketball court, playground, covered picnic area,trail Large Urban 25 acres developed, Boat Dock, Boat Launch,Covered Picnic Chiawana Park Park 127 Shelters, Horseshoe Pits,Picnic Area, Playground,Restrooms, Volleyball Court, and Walking Trail City Hall Activity Center Special Use 3.5 City offices,Activity Center(gym),two softball fields, playfield Court and Road 48 Neighborhood 5 C Developed(Soccerfield) Franklin County Park Desert Dunes Park Neighborhood 5 p Basketball court, picnic area, playground, restroom, and walking trail Heritage Park. Neighborhood 5.0 Playground, picnic areas, play field, and walking path Highland Park Neighborhood 13.0 Basketball court, softball field, picnic area,playground, restrooms,threefootball fields Island Park Neighborhood 5.0 Playground, basketball court, covered picnictables,walking path,sand volleyball, and open turf areas Swimming pool, wading pool, basketball court, 2 playgrounds, Kurtzman Park Neighborhood 7,0 picnic area, Martin Luther King Center(3500 square foot gymnasium, game roorns,classrooms, and offices),recreation center,restrooms Liberty Park. Neighborhood 5,0 Basketball court, covered picnic area, volleyball court, and playground Library Park Special Use 1.0 Library, landscaping, memorial garden Lincoln Park Neighborhood 5 e Basketball Courts, covered picnic area,playground,restrooms, and walking trail Lucas Park Neighborhood 2 C Covered picnic area,playground McGee Park Neighborhood 10.0 Playground, softball fields,soccer fields, covered picnic area Table s.01 (continued) -Pasco parks and recreation Facilities Memorial Park Community 13,0 Swimming pool, wading pool, covered picnic area, playground, restroorns, basketball court, 2 softball fields,volleyball courts Mercier Park Neighborhood 3.0 Basketball court, playground, soccer field,softball field, covered picnic area Peanuts Park Special Use 1 0 Outdoor plaza,fountain, ad)acent to the Farmer's Market Richardson Park Neighborhood 5.0 Swimming pool, playground,basketball court,softball field, covered picnic area Riverview Park Special Use i7.0 Picnic area, 4 Little League Fields,1 Babe Ruth Field, concession stands Road 36 Soccer Fields Special Use 10,0 Four soccer fields,parking Sacajawea Park Regional Park 284.0 Developed(State park) Schlegel Park Special Use 3,0 Public boat launch,full service marina, covered boat moorage, picnic area 18,5DD square foot center with meeting roorrs, pool rooms, Senior Citizens Center Special Use 1.0 cards kitchen,dance floor,reading area, health screening, and a variety of programs for seniors Sun Willows Golf Course Special Use 132,D 18 hole Golf course, with golf lessons and tournaments Sunny Meadows Neighborhood 5.0 Two picnic shelters, playground,basketball courts,soccer field and pathways Sylvester Park Neighborhood 3,0 Playground,tennis courts,picnic area,basketball courts, restroom,park building TRAC Soccer Fields Special Use 4,5 Developed(Franklin County) Playground, covered picnic area, restrooms, walking path, Vintage Park Neighborhood 8 C and 2 baseball fields This park is connectedto Maya Angelou Elementary Volunteer Park Special Use 7,D Playground equipment,meditation garden, walkway,sitting area,picnic area with historic train and caboose, gazebo Wade Park Linear Park 25.0 Public boat launch, seating areas, and walking and bike paths. Wayside Park Special Use 1 D Picnic area Franklin County Trail Trail 6.4 Miles Developed I-182 Trail Trail 6,2 miles River Trail Trail 1.4 miles Developed Rd 58 Trail Trail 1 C Trail around the softball fi elds City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft, December 2010 A•1 Table i -other recreal faClllties Captain Gray Elementary Maya Angalou Elementary Edwin Markham Elementary* McGee Elementary Emerson Elementary Robert Frost Elementary Elementary schools Longfellow Elementary Rcwena Chess Elementary Mark Twain Elementary Ruth Livingston Elementary Whittier Park Elementary Discovery Middle School Ellen Cchoa Middle School Middle Schools ]ohn McLoughlin Middle School Isaac Stevens Middle School Pasco High School High schools New Horizons Alt, High School Country Christian Center St. Patrick's School Private schools Kingspoint Christian School Tri-City Junior Academy Riverview Baptist Christian School Tri-City Prepatory School Colleges Columbia Basin College Go-Bowl Bowling lanes (Indoor) Safety Shoot Indoor shooting range(Indoor) Boys and Girls Club Gym, game room, office space, class room (Indoor) Big Cross 2.2 mile Cross Country running track(outdoor) Golf Land 9-hole Par 3 and driving range(outdoor) A•2 Appendix B - Other Recreation and Sports Facilities Table B.03 - Sports F80bbes in Pasco Adult Baseball Fields Baseball Stadlurn (Dust Devils Stadium) 1 Not available to public use Columbia Basin Ccllege 1 Pasco High School 1 RlVeFVleW Park(IN'alters Field) 1 Total 4 Youth Baseball Fields Little League Fields 5 McLoughlin Middle School 2 Qchoa Middle School 1 Stevens Middle School 1 Total 11) Adult Softball Fields Memorial Park 2 Pasco High School 1 Limited use Softball Complex 5 Scheduled use Columbia Basin Ccllege 1 Limited use Total 9 Youth Softball Fields Kurtzman Park 1 Local use only Richardson Park 1 Practice only Stevens Middle School 2 Practice only Total 5 City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft, December 2010 A•3 Table 8.03 (corttmued) - Sports facilities in Pasco Satter Fields Edgar Brawn Memorial Field 1 Colurndia Basin College 2 Mark.Twain Elementary School 1 McGee Park 1 Four also for youth Mercier Park 1 Pasco High School 1 Practice Pasco Soccer Complex 15 Ruth Livingston 1 Road 48 and Court 2 Road 36 Soccer Fields 4 TRAC Soccer Fields 2 County Total C Running Tracks(400 m) Edgar Brawn High School 1 McLoughlin Middle School 1 Ochca Middle School 1 Total 3 Football Fields Edgar Brown Memorial Stadium 1 Highland Park 1 McLoughlin Middle School 1 Ochoa Middle School 1 Pasco High School 1 Stevens Middle School 1 Total 6 Swirnrning Pools Kurtzman Pool 1 Trapezoid; 20-40ft x 60ft Memorial Pool 1 50 meters x 20 yds.,zero entry, aquatics Richardson Pool 1 Trapezoid; 20-40ft x 50ft A•4 Appendix B - Other Recreation and Sports Facilities Table B.03(continued) - Sports facilities in Pasco Tennis Courts Columbia Basin College 9 McLoughlin Middle School 4 Pasco High School 9 Ochoa Middle School 4 Stevens Middle School 4 Sylvester Park 3 Total 29 lee Rinks TRAC 1 Seasonal use Gymnasiums Captain Gray Elementary 1 1 court City Hall Activity Center 1 1 court Edwin Markham Elementary 1 1 court Emerson Elementary 1 1 court Longfellow Elementary 1 1 court Mark Twain Elementary 1 1 court Martin Luther King Community Center 1 1 court Maya Angelou 1 1 court McGee Elementary 1 1 court McLoughlin Middle School 1 2 court Ochoa Middle School 2 3 court Pasco High School 2 4 court Robert Frost Elementary 1 1 court Rowena Chess Elementary 1 1 court Ruth Livingston Elementary 1 1 court Stevens Middle School 2 4 court Whittier Elementary 1 1 court Total 26 26 courts *Outside Pasco's Urban Growth Area City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft, December 2 010 A•5 Appendix C Parks and Recreation Questionnaire Results Introduction may have skewed the overall responses, and acknowledging this issue is important to understanding the questionnaire's results. This report summarizes the responses to the Pasco Parks and Recreation questionnaire Additionally, the questionnaire was produced conducted as part of the Parks and Recreation in English only, limiting access to the questions Plan update. This questionnaire was sent to those households with English-reading to households that also receive utility bills, individuals. The questionnaire required based on a randomized sample of residential respondents to indicate preferences in writing, utility customers. Questionnaire responses and the process required that respondents take were collected through November 12, 2010, action to return the survey by either mailing it and tabulation began late that m onth. The or delivering it to City Hall. These conditions questionnaire included 9 questions. Forty-nine m ay also have contributed to the relatively low questionnaires were returned and analyzed. response rate. The questionnaire was designed by Studio Questions 6 and 7 asked respondents to prioritize Cascade, with guidance and review by City of items. This proved to be a challenge for Pasco staff. The questions were written to learn m any respondents. In response, this analysis the public's use of parks facilities and recreation concentrated on first or highest priority answers, programs, as well as their priorities for tax inferring that those items indicated as staving expenditures on parks and recreation. highest priority is a reasonable indicator of individual preference. Issues In question 6, they were given the choices"first most willing,""second most willing,"and "third m ost willing."Some responded by checking a This questionnaire was not m eant to be a level of priority for each item. Others responded statistically valid survey. The questionnaire is by choosing only three items and ranking each an instrument to roughly gauge the position of of the three. Since the responses were not the public on issues. Even though the results consistent, the most accurate way to determine of this questionnaire are not statistically valid, priorities of the respondents is to review the its important to note som a of the issues that items ranked "first most willing"to understand were discovered while analyzing the data from priorities. completed questionnaires. In question 7, the question was constructed There was a return rate of approximately 3.5%, similarly but asked respondents rank each item with 49 surveys returned from the 1400 mailed. 1, 2, and 3 by writing a number in the box. A No one under the age of 25 responded to the different problem emerged in the responses to questionnaire, and nearly half of the respondents this question. In som a cases, the respondents were age 55 or older. More than 70 percent did as the questionnaire instructed and wrote of respondents were from areas West of U.S. a number 1, 2, or 3 in the box next to their top 395. The location and age of the respondents three priorities. In other cases the respondents Questions and only checked 3 (or more) boxes to indicate their priorities. Again, as the responses were Responses inconsistent, this questionnaire report examines the"I" responses to the question added to the "Selected/Not Ranked" responses to understand y priorities. 'Question 1 The information gleaned from this questionnaire should not be considered statistically valid Considering Pasco's parks and because of the low number of responses, the sampling approach, and the method of recreation system generally, administering the questionnaire. The information please indicate your level of provided by the responses, however, is helpful — agreement With the following along with the results of other public participation activities — as decision makers set priorities for statements: future funding of parks and recreation programs This question provided the respondent with four and facilities. statements to evaluate (see figures 3-6 below). The most common response to "Pasco's parks and recreation program attracted me to the community" and 'Pasco's parks and recreation system is an im portant reason for my staying in Pasco"was"no opinion." For both statements the agree and disagree statements combined with those who felt strongly either way were less than the percent who responded "no opinion." More than half of respondents agreed or strongly agreed (59.2 percent) that"Pasco's parks and recreation system meets my needs."Similarly, m ore than half of respondents agreed or strongly agreed (67.4 percent) with the statem ent"I have used Pasco's recreation programs." Question 1:PasaYr parks and recreatlon system attracted Fnatothe cornmunhy. l 51mn�p dirgvu 4 14'. Dn�ra 2 4 3� 190 opi nin n 3 2 7% Agee 2 4 396 City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft December 2010 A•1 qt ertun 1:Pawn's parks and recreation syrtem it an important rearon for my staying in Parco. $in ngly di I-s- 41% N—Fim,- 3 fi MA AS— 2222.% Strongly agree 10 2W Question I:Pasco's parkrartd recreation rystem meets my needs. shay j a o 09'� D S— "639, N.ep,�ion 22 4W. Asrw 44 94n 1 strn nply agras 143% QLwgon 1:1 have used%srn'ss reaealion programs. $',MnOy dilaw" M 4195 Oiie,�ee �6:95 No,Fin iu 14.A Agw 4 0 Strongly as— 34.•% A+2 Appendix C - Questionnaire Results Question2 Question 2:Please let us know if you two these types of parks facilities,and if you'd like to Fee more-understand ing that budgets are limbed: 429Y. Please let us know if Neu ala�l"pen 20 bh you use these types of �IObn parks facilities, and if L—' 8� 59z,a you'd like to see more Sped Fieb, i-,- ,e d, - understanding that My C.A. I' ss�y Ime them bee +I'd Gke b see more budgets are limited. 2W 4 I me them and I'd 14.b,ee more Shade Perk Among responses about using m9x Idon'tk- _,¢ parks facilities, the majority of PicnicA� 4e 0/, responses were"Water/River Access" and "Picnic Areas."Those Commun tr Centm :52 IV. who h d d res one they would like o +�• p Y` t WdedWxrAcceu see more" of specific facilities said , they would like more "Play Courts" Other and "Skate Parks."A very low percentage of respondents indicated that they both used a facility and would like to see more of that facility. Question 3 If you've used Pasco's recreation programs, please indicate how you'd Question3:Ifyou'veuFedPdsco'rrecreation prcgrarns,pkwe irdicate how you'd rate rate them: them: [hildian't P,ognzm• --- '•-• 9z rr. Responses to this question were low due largely to the nature of w.th P-5-- 94 PA 9 Y •'cii4.^ the question. The question only TecnPn - ems• asked for responses from people gram rF� � . n,d"h P,egmmt 2ar�r. who had participated in recreation programs. Since there were only 49 pme5- , 22b/ Map?10-... ,1!', tl&celknt total returned questionnaires, the AA6,t-4p°,t. 26s n,Cood responses to this question are low q brh eFM due to the sample. In many cases, Ah.and Cro t. .m� ,uv, aFbor fewer than 50 percent of respondents 1—i,°°ndLi— �„M ,;�. 22b'16 ranked a program listed in this M,<ucaonel—d 6due eio nd �~ b�'r• Y�' question. The percentages shown in , s 21116%Figure 8 below are low because during °u"°°'s"^°"°" l7i0d^'�"`` analysis, the num ber of"no response" Aqudic,Pmg— Mn11 245h responses was also recorded. Other 8�'^ The responses show that the m ajority of respondents ranked the programs they participated in as"excellent" or "good"for all programs. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft December 2010 A•3 Question 4:Please indicate which of Pasco's major park and recreation fadlities yo u use placing amark in the box on the lefi side of your choice(r): Memadal Pods _ 90.81. 1 Question 4 Riverview Pork 11 1433. Sun Wdbwi Goff Coune 24.391. Baseball 5vdium 40.8% Please indicate which City Hall Ac6,4C-t., 12.27. of Pasco's park and Road 36 Soccer FWdr 1439. Volunteer Park 1633: recreation facilities you Soccer C—Flex 26.6% use, placing a mark in Library Pork ':. MLKCemer 617° the box on the left side Wee,id.Nrk 209. of your choice(s): 3oftbWl Complex 143% _ 79 BY.Overwhelmingly, the most used Chi--P9 k - er 26 59. park among the parks listed was Sen for al—,"Ce Br Chiawana Park (79.6 percent). The Cable idg rrc Pork r 29. Other 12.29', next m ost used parks — with 40.8 percent of respondents each — were the Baseball Stadium and Memorial Par k. Question 5:Pkceme Indicate howyou learn about the City of Palsco'r park and recreation programs,placinga mark in the box on the left ride of your choiaft Question 5 6,d ie p1N 1e Z% Imera� 16.39ii f Please indicate how you 13477. learn about the City°ice tF „9� of Pasco's park and Pads and Recreattion Guide recreation programs, placing a mark in the Advertnemenh 16311, box on the left side of eomrn—t,Event' 1439. your choices(s); Most of the respondents said that they learned about programs Other _61V, through the"Park and Recreation Guide."The next most common response was"Word of Mouth" and Quertion6:If it vuereto coneto it,what would you he most willingto fund with "Newspaper Articles." addilionalta dollar.?(°First Mos t Wdling"responses) F.A.Z paler and rpo dr field, — 12 24, Question 6 New FaN.r and ipd,field, B 291. If it were to come to it, VOalldngandtn&Zlreib 229. what would you be most willing to fund with kiveramer. 26 01. additional tax dollars? ae The issues with the responses Aquatie iditia 42.99: received to this question are discussed earlier in this report. The Indmr t-aa. 224% results shown in Figure 11 refect 0 1—. A•4 Appendix C - Questionnaire Results Question 7:Please indicateyeurtop three criteria,helping the City invest in parks those items t hat respondents faci INies w wisely as possible:{O First"ranked responses+"Sekcwd(No t Ranked" responses) were"first most willing"to fund with additional tax dollars. P.—.e h-4th-8,..b/ 42 9V, "Aquatic Facilities" (42.9 percent) showed the highest response, followed by"River Vaintsfi;nae,taa„ha 327w, Access" (26.5 percent). Strvi ng multiple us e1 with een h ftml rty 2 2.4% Question 7 Acce�ubdty to 4ht soli n cam rnu n Tj te.a1� Please indicate your 1Wa,l�ilitY G(Nntling 7S 4•Y•, top three criteria, helping the City invest in parks facilities as wisely as possible: Q4 sstion S:What i<Yom agegroup? Like question 6, the issues Under la 00% with responses to this question are discussed in the"Issues" section at the top of this report. asap 0011. The results shown in Figure 12 reflect those responses that were ranked "First" or 2s.a< 2a 5?� were selected but unranked by respondents. "Ensuring health and safety" and"maintaining IN 44 1221° established service levels"were respondents'top two priorities with 42.9 percent and 32.7 <ssa 1221° percent respectively. ss��o�er a�ovt Age and Location Question 9c Yhere in Pasco do you lives Questions 8 and 9 asked ns,tOJSM f asa respondents for their age group and where they lived. All respondents to the questionnaire identified themselves as age 25 and older. The majority of respondents (71.4 percent) said We>tofJ9115 .1.a1e they live West of U.S. 395 and 16.3 percent live East of U.S. 395. Pon'!Kmw �2 fJa City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft December 2010 A•5 Response Comparisons Park Fa cility Uvage(QuM ion 4)by Rerpondenk age 35.44 In order to learn m ore about responses to the questions, some responses were compared to Seabdc others to show how certain deco ographlc groups 4%. >, responded to these questions. Questions 4, Inuc c.��r, . 5, and 6 were compared to both the age and location of respondents. For clarity, item s that b received zero responses are not shown in the figures In this section. mk' Park Facility Usage by Age 'Wlunlmr li k a4: ow wn See a C.'w The pie charts below (Figures 13-16) show how On different age groups responded to the question of which park facilities they use. All age groups, Park Facility UMV(Qctmon4)byRjKpondentFage45-54 except ages 35-44, identified Chiawana Park more frequently. In the 35-44 age group, the .r,,.hX Baseball Stadium was identified more than any other response and Chiawana Park appeared second most frequently. 3.,akdl SSeAm L� q% ch.— Y (, - ZIV. YFJ��'r-f.Y .nl�, / yam.. Y Nc Wa(uda 4rk - 1W, Park Facility Uc ge(Qt a lion 4)by Re pondentR age 25 34 Park Facility Wage(Rumlon 4)by Rewpor7de bi age 53 and Over Cade Aridgp Perk Ofi.r P'Ia t� O!Im• kknmhf 3+t b+en'ur Park f i �, %RI.w...lyrrk Serra ri+ns+i Lva• � ! iK lddi 11n Wlgn.1., 1t4. ! rr vk -1R 1111 e.k.rh ji• I �: C•rt/HdI.ASbri4/Canl.i Abd!Complo: Nihlllltr - 14' \ ' 7.+L.n / Ras739 Ytc.r fields 24: ^road 76 Seemr7mldr 1 ��`�O• / Suer C..pler 29. ••}� e4. �.!'Lkmry Rut: VY. library'fide 4Ya 4� A•6 Appendix C - Questionnaire Results Method of Learning About tearn Ahots Par m Par kr(Question 5)by kaPondents age 1554 Pasco Parks by Age cth° Ca7u W Age was also compared to the methods by which respondents learn about Pasco Parks. "F,•� ,.., The respondents in all age groups, except those / 1N respondents ages 25-3 p g 4, learn about parks mostly from the"Park and Recreation Guide." Only respondents 25-34 cited +]ord-of-mouth" as the most common way they learn about parks. .ib:Foa.eo.t da MA In the other age groups, "word-of-mouth"and r•< / newspaper articles also ranked high. /1. Learn About Pasco Parkr(Q ueslion 5)by Rec po ndenls age 25 id _ 1 ors, Learn About Pasrn Parks(QLjestron 5)by Pwspondenu age 55 and Uver 1 f+. two 2v, 'cW w,.,ppa.a.rlw fn..n.nll ,v, NAuwl 9A. ..;od. ,CA 1%w r j JW. W.da(M..rL. / Learr About Pasco Par kv(Q uertion 5)by Hec pondonts age 35.4d 1'W In.ww Slit h•kmt IS mMa Carr. Aan.p.p•A.td.. Word City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft December 2010 A•7 First Most Willing to Fund FiM Atom\billing to Fund(Quecl ion b)by Racpordentc age 45-51 by Age All age groups were first m ost willing to fund Oho aquatic facilities with additional tax dollars, except those respondents ages 55 and older. Respondents 55 and older were most willing to fund river access and walking and biking trails. I i 1 � r,.1%.. ' Pont Abet ri�lhng b Fund(Quest un 6)by Rat pondentr age 25.31 14 1/iJli�d � F�7t:: 11tadCC64 � r.ay •�.r.n6.416, t IFirrtAtoet Willing to Fund(Querlion 6)by VArporidente age 93 and Over for t<�trRrbrad ,\ AyrN IuKir 17K 7� tndoo•ttmaoetrnmr •',� f.- t V/d.N5 Nird INA"5M.l. IN, A9��h'M•�M. First MOO lbilingo Fuld puatnon 4)by"DNA,ntfae35-44 :Jt � 1 I' ►tuer lc,ilw N !1.,' NIP.NIP. lay./ A•6 Appendix C - Questionnaire Results Park Facility Usage by Method of Learning About Location Pasco Parks by Location Chiawana Park is the most used park by For respondents east of U.S. 395, the "Park and respondents located both east and west of U.S. Recreation Guide" is the most popular way of 395. For those living east of U.S. 395, Memorial learning about Pasco Parks. West of U.S. 395, Park Is the next m ost used facility. For those respondents cited the guide and"word-of-mouth" living west of U.S. 395, the Baseball Stadium is equally (26 percent), the next most used facility. Park facilitia Urage(Question 1)by Rasporwl> ft Easf of U.S.3ss Leam.khout Pum Paris(Qrrrtion 5)by Rerpondentc East of U.S.395 Cnbl u B n dep Fmk Ai _etn- i•r k.we Idp•nnr IS S•r, r r,,t—, rtt �/w.P,—,:Aft6, �r MtwtonMMk I.< � 1(111. UT � Grzr.:e.r Pak .f: td.at.>nan. +Jt.vea NeM1 der/ f ��wMrfAdun VNd rf kv a �. tall Cnm r—d 1►:wao•:.&pl+ ttil / 3_4 1M. 3We �r 4LK Cert:r •L,e.trr ++ f � t'/ W Wlr•6V1>,k —field, Park facilities Usage(Question d)by Rerpondentr 1%'ert of U.S.395 learn Ahouf Palm Parkr(Quertion 5)by Rerpordmfr West of U.S.3% C.be Briigp PWt Rod,.arN 2i,• DrtrF 3Y f r nH F�.,h1 3Q. 1 Vth=r rn u:9Y• Rnen-eu Fark C,le•, !CA ad—a, trRyOt /• OYc �)Y. 1n. / fCtICCI�I� � �J _Mara rM: 1 IV..1�AWfa� 2S+• 1 . 3.akd1 Sk.l,r•j 644..0 V--6-6-6 ttoa J tew `` } Gh,Hd rlclr+d C—h,r :ofhall`a npl�.1 ,r 9� W-1N.Jk :Park q_4. — NLK isrrer _ 4«..fnwt4. 1 Fc�36 Field, SWi :7. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft December 2010 A•9 First Most Willing to Fund Conclusion by Location While not statistically valid, this questionnaire Both east and west of U.S. 395, respondents does provide some perspective on the parks were first most willing to fund aquatic facilities. facilities most used by residents and what For those living east of U.S. 395, river access and priorities may be highest for future funding. The indoor recreation facilities were also important. questionnaire also serves to provide a basis for For those living west of U.S. 395, indoor future research if the City does plan to consider recreation facilities and walking and biking trails finding additional funding for parks facilities. were the next most important facilities. Pool facilities were rated as very important to important by about half of the survey responses. This could be either improvements to outdoor facilities or an indoor pool facility. The responses show less interest in adult programs and skate Firs)i�4ost%l ingto Fu,d(Quwtlon 6)by Respondertr East of U.5.395 parks. There was also less interest in community rh 6nnZporhwa tpom centers. 64: About 40% of the respondents felt that existing park facilities were not adequate, and 27% VC.PDM felt that programs were not adequate. Some .�.. of the responses pointed to a lack of parks in t new development or overcrowding while other comments suggested more improvements like lighting, benches, and play courts/grounds. Facilities that are used the most are bathrooms, Q7f° followed by picnic areas and playgrounds, and a water access areas. Sport courts are reported �s+ as being used the least. There were multiple _ requests for more bicycle opportunities and indoor pool programming. People would like to especially see more rest rooms, neighborhood parks, trails, and pool facilities, followed closely by natural open spaces. First 81ocl Yhitling W Fund(Question 6)by Recpundertr West orU.S.395 More programs in exercise and leisure, outdoor recreation, and aquatics were requested the most frequently. Multiple respondents pointed oe.. row:M �d'R,t to the unincorporated area surrounded by the western portion of Pasco, neighborhood parks in the rapidly growing part of the city north of I-182, and access to the river as items for further attention. By Age *3-0ri,,,,,, Respondents younger than 45 tended to use the baseball stadium, Memorial Park and Chiawana 1 IM Park most often, while those 45 to 54 prefer Chiawana Park and other recreational facilities not listed in the questionnaire. Of those facilities A*10 Appendix C - Questionnaire Results listed, respondents in this age group were Households east of 395 would most likely be relatively evenly distributed. The MLK Center, willing to support an aquatic facility, walking Cable Bridge Park and the Senior Center were and biking trails and indoor recreation facilities. notable in that no respondents in this age group Those west would also those, and they would identi-Fed them as a favorite facility. The 55 support sports Felds, too. and older groups preferred the Senior Center, Chiawana Park, Memorial Park and the baseball stadium. When it cam a to finding out about the City's recreational program offerings, all age groups turn to the Recreation Guide. Younger respondents tended also to identify the Internet, word of m outh and community events as sources for recreation information. Older residents tended to identify newspaper articles and word of mouth as their primary recreation information resources. If asked to fund new parks facilities, residents younger than 55 generally favored an aquatic center. Those older also favored an aquatic center, but they also wanted to support walking and biking trails and river access. Those respondents between the ages of 25 and 34 would also like to see and would be willing to support improvem ents to and the addition of athletic facilities and sports fields. By Location The questionnaire asked respondents to identify if they live east or west of Highway 395. Those east of the highway identified Chiawana Park, Memorial Park, the baseball stadium, Volunteer Park and the Senior Citizens' Center as their most used parks facilities. Those west of the highway identified Chiawana Park, the baseball stadium, the soccer complex and Memorial park as their most used facilities. Generally, those respondents east of the highway spread their preferences more evenly across the facilities choices provided. Respondents east of 395 rely on the Recreation Guide, newspaper articles, word of mouth and advertisements to learn about recreation programs. Those west of the highway use the Guide, word of mouth, newspaper articles, advertisem ents and the Internet to stay informed. City of Pasco Parks and Recreation Plan update - Draft December 2010 A•11 v (IJ v CU 1. Considering Pasco's parks and recreation system generally, please indicate your level of g o Q P agreement with the following statements: t, 14 K z 0 a (A ti a) Pasco's parks and recreation system attracted me to the community Li) Pasco's parks and recreation system is an important reason for my staying in Pasco c) Pasco's parks and recreation system meets my needs d) I have used Pasco's recreation programs e) I use parks facilities and recreation programs In neighboring communities � 3 2. Please let us knoi,v if you use these types of parks facilities, and if you'd 3. If you've used Pasco's like to see more- understanding that v ! � o recreation programs, please --@ budgets are limited: : : indicate how you'd rate them: it U 2 a a) Neighborhood parks a) Children's programs (ages 3-6) b) Community parks (like Memorial Park) b) Youth programs(ages 6-12) c) Natural areas/open space c) Teen programs(ages 13-16) d) TralIs d) Adult programs e) Pool/aquatic facilities e) Seniorcitizen programs f) Sport fields f) Athletics/sports g) Play courts g) Arts and crafts h) Skate parks h) Exercise and leisure I) Picnic areas i) Instructional and educational �) Community centers ]} Outdoor recreation k} Water/river access k) Aquatics programs 1) Other: 1) Other: 4. Please indicate which of Pasco's major park and recreation facilities you use, placing a mark in the box on the left side of your choices}: a) Memorlal Park b} Riverview Park c) Sun Willows golf course d) Baseball stadium e) City Hall activity center f) Road 36 soccer fields g) Volunteer Park h) Soccer complex i) Library Park I) Schlagel Park k) Wayside Park 1) Softball complex m) Peanuts Park n} senior Citizens'Center o) Cable Badge Park p) Other: Parks&Recreation Plan questionnaire-City of Pasco, Washington-November 2D10 1 A912 Appendix C - Questionnaire Results {a S. Please Indicate your level of support for the City of Pasco's efforts to improve andlor expand its �* g a parks and recreation facilities and programs. a) Existing parks and sports fields b) New parks and sports fields C) Walking and biking trails d) River access, Including swim beaches, boat launches and viewpoints e) Aquatic facilities, Including pools and special aquatic facilities as at Memorial Park f) Indoor recreation facilities, including basketball courts and multi-purpose centers g) Other: 6 C � G Ea Gc, � a ` c U'c KGs b. If it were to come to it, what would you be most willing to fund with additional tax dollars? 'Z I (,A'¢ a) Existing parks and sports fields b) New parks and sports fields c) Walking and biking trails d) River access(for example, swim beaches, boat launches and viewpoints) e) Aquatic facilities(for example, pools and specrai aquatic facilities as at Memorial park) f) Indoor recreation facilities (for example, basketball courts and mufti-purpose centers) g) other: 5 0 7. Please indicate your top three M 8. How old are you?(circle one) 9. Where in Pasco do you live? criteria, helping the City invest in o (circle one) parks facilities as wisely as possible: c'N a} Under 18 a) Ensuring health and safety b} 18 to 24 d} East of US 395 b) West of US 345 b) Maintaining established service levels .) 25 to 34 c) Serving multiple uses with each facility d) 35 to 44 c) don't know d) Accessibility to the entire community e) 45 to 54 e) Availablllty offunding f) 55 or over f) other: Thank you for your time and effort! Please return this questionnaire to us by November 12, 2010 - simply: Mail it to the Administrative & Community Services Department at: P.O. Box 293, Pasco, Washington 99301 Enclose it with your next utilities payment, or Drop it off at the Pasco Administrative & Community Services office(first floor, City Halt) Questions? Call (509) 543-5757 for more Information orto add comments. Parks&Recreation Plan questionnaire -City of Pasco,Washington-November 2010 2 Appendix D Funding Sources Washington Wildlife and Recreation Coalition Plan A special fund created by a coalition of recreation wildlife groups with the intent of preserving wildlife habitats and open space and developing recreation areas. Approximately $45 million was allocated in its first year. It was hoped that this amount would be budgeted each year for the next ten years but it is likely that will not occur. Local agencies must match the grant amount on a 50-50 basis. Property Transfer Excise Tax A tax assessed on the sale of property and adm inistered by local counties and cities. City General Fund General City funds allocated to the Park and Recreation Budget. A significant amount of the Department's budget comes from this source. Capital Improvement Fund Money allocated from the City's General Fund to finance major capital projects. The City currently does not have such a fund. Park Impact Fees Development fees imposed by the City for parkland acquisition and development. Fees charged to the developer are based on a set amount per residential unit. Currently Pasco has this program in place. Short Term Special Levy A property tax for construction and/or operation levied for a set number of years. It is usually 1-3 years. A special levy requires a 60% voter approval. General Obligation Bond Property tax for the sale of construction bonds. The tax assessment can be levied up to 30 years. Requires a 609,16 majority approval of 40% of the voters who voted at the last election. Revenue Bonds Revenue from the operation of the facility pays for the capital cost and debt service. Does not require a vote of people unless required by local ordinance. Councilmanic Bonds Bonds that can be issued by the City Council. Does not require a vote of the people but must be paid out of the City's annual operating budget. LWCF Grants distributed from the Federal Land and Water Conservation Fund. Grants pay 50% of the cost of acquisition and development. At one time, this was a major funding program for recreation programs. Under the present administration, the program has been cut severely. The Washington State RCO administers the program locally. Park Revenue Revenue from park operations can be used to pay for capital improvements. Department of Ecology Grants from the Coastal Zone Management Account. Grants pay 50% and are primarily used for shoreline acquisition and public access. HUD Grants Grants from the Federal Department of Housing and Urban Development are available for a wide variety of projects. Most are distributed in the lower income areas of the community. Grants can be up to 100%. (CDBG) Aquatic Land Enhancement Fund This program, funding by the State Department of Natural Resources, will finance up to $80,000 for acquisition and development of waterfront parks, public access sites and environmental sensitive areas. Initiative 215 Boating Funds Funds received from boating gas taxes are allocated to marine related projects. Up to $150,000 per project is available but a 50% match is required. State Bicycle Funds Money from a portion of state gas taxes is distributed to each city for bicycle trail development. The amount is usually small and often used to help finance trails along existing streets. Certificates of Participation A lease-purchase approach in which the City sells certificates of Participations (COPS) to a lending institution. The City then pays the loan off from revenue produced by the facility or from its general operating budget. The lending institution holds title to the property until the COPS are repaid. This procedure does not require a vote of the public. City of Pasco Parks & Recreation Plan update — Draft, December 2010 A•1 Volunteer Efforts Volunteers can be quite effective in terms of contributing cash, materials or labor. Some playgrounds have been developed in this manner. Transfer of Development Rights A process wherein the development rights of a specific parcel of desired open space land is transferred to a second parcel of land more suitable for development. The second parcel is then permitted a higher level of development. If the two parcels are owned by two different landowners, the increased value of the second parcel is given the owner of the�frst parcel. Work Release Program An alternative to jail time by providing community services such as working on a park maintenance crew or providing other recreation services. Cooperative efforts should be made between the City and Coyote Ridge Corrections. Conservation Futures Levy Counties can levy up to $.065 per $1,000 assessed valuation for the acquisition of shoreline and open space areas. The money cannot be used for development or maintenance. Cities can apply for a share of this money through the County. Currently Franklin County does not have this program. A•2 Appendix D - Funding Sources City of Pasco Parks & Recreation Plan update - Draft, December 2010 A•3