Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023.04.22 Council Workshop Handout from S McFadden�C v"4V'fi, G+ 66�cl i Us TARGETED URBAN AREA (TUA) TAX EXEMPTION PROGRAM OVERVIEW • This program is a recruitment tool to help the City compete v�+ith other states. • Company must attest that they would not have located in Richland if not for this program. • Property tax exemption is only on new improvements for manufacturers located within the TUA boundary. • Property tax on the land and non - manufacturing improvements are paid during the exemption period. AREAS DESIGNATED FOR TUA EXEMPTION Chapter 84.25 RCW; COR Resolution 2023-150 • Exemption period is ten years starting after project completion. • Current legislation offers the program until 2030. • Established by Chapter 84.25 RCW (2021 Amendment). • Benton County is offering the same exemption for the County's portion of property tax through a separate application process. Min. 25 living wage jobs: $23/hr and 2,080 hrs/yr Project Valuation $800K or more Manufacturing uses by NAICS code 10,000 sqft of improvements 3-year construction timeline CITY OF RICHLAND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 625 Swift Boulevard, MS-19 Richland, WA 99352 Telephone (509) 942.7595 WWW.RICHLANDBUSINESS.COM C1.11ICHLANDMA.US • 509-942-7390 11111111111111111IRiChland G'j,/G�Laz �Y Informational Sheet: TARGETED URBAN AREA TAX EXEMPTION LOCATION: HORN RAPIDS TRIANGLE AREA and North Horn Rapids in Richland, Washington KEY FACTS: 1. The TARGETED URBAN AREA PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION (TUA) PROGRAM is authorized by Chapter 84.25 RCW. 2. The purpose of the program is to encourage new industrial and manufacturing uses on undeveloped or underutilized lands zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses. 3. GENERAL PROVISIONS and REQUIREMENTS: a. "Industrial and Manufacturing uses" means building improvements that meet the following: i. 10,000 square feet or larger of new improvements/buildings. ii. Buildings must be on undeveloped property (building additions do not qualify). iii. representing a minimum improvement value of $800,000 for uses categorized as "division D: Manufacturing' or "division E: transportation" by the United States Dept. of Labor. b. The value of new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities is exempt from property taxation. i. The value is exempt for 10 successive years. ii. Beginning January 1st of the year immediately following the calendar year of issuance of the certificate. iii. The exemption does not include the value of the land or non-industrial/manufacturing related improvements. c. The exemption does not apply to county property taxes unless the county adopts a resolution to allow the exemption from county property taxes. d. At the conclusion of the exemption period, the new industrial/manufacturing facilities must be considered as new construction. e. Property owners seeking an exemption will apply online for approval and are required to do include the following upon agreement: i. Sign a statement that the applicant is aware of the potential tax liability involved when the property ceases to be eligible for the incentive. ii. Certify that they would not have built in this location but for the availability of the tax exemption. iii. Certify that a minimum of 25 new family living wage jobs will be created on the subject property as a result of new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities within one year of building occupancy. 1. "Family Living Wage Job" means a job offering health care benefits, an average wage of $23/hour or more, and working 2,080 hours per year on the site. 9 _ 11 Vol mrL �4#0�- _��''A. r 'i •_�'�'� - z_ NORTH RICHLAND - TARGETED URBAN AREAS j (MANUFACTURING TAX EXEMPTION) TUA TIMELINE 1) Application 90 days to approve/deny from date of receipt Approve through Council action / Staff initial review 2) Contract and Issue Conditional Certificate of Acceptance of Tax Exemption (within above 90 day approval period) Send to County Administrative (per resolution) 3) Completion of Project Construction 30 days to audit statement and approve program compliance Report to City from Owner (Owner's statement, CofO) 3 years maximum to complete construction *From Certificate Date 4) Issue certificate of exemption to the County 10 days from expiration of 30 day audit period Send to County Administrative 5) Effective Date of Exemption January 1 following project approval 6) Annual reporting 30 days from anniversary date of approval of the Certificate of Exemption (items) Produced by the property owner County sending exemption reportiong to the City annually for tracking 7) Annual report to Commerce COR Administrative Report December 31 of each year Chapter 84.25 RCW TARGETED URBAN AREAS —EXEMPTION Sections 84.25.010 Findings. 84.25.020 Purpose. 84.25.030 Definitions. 84.25.040 Exemption —New construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities. 84.25.050 Application requirements for property owner. 84.25.060 Targeted area designation requirements. 84.25.070 Exemption application procedures. 84.25.080 Application approval —City governing authority review requirements. 84.25.090 Application —City governing authority approval or denial Appeals. 84.25.100 Application fee. 84.25.110 Certificate of tax exemption —Requirements. 84.25.120 Annual report. 84.25.130 Improvements. 84.25.140 Application-2015 1st sp.s. c 9. RCW 84.25.010 Findings. The legislature finds that: (1) Many cities have planned under the growth management act, chapter 36.70A RCW, and designated and zoned lands for industrial and manufacturing use; (2) The industrial and manufacturing industries provide family living wage jobs; (3) In the current economic climate the creation of additional family living wage jobs is essential; (4) It is critical that Washington state promote its continued strength in the fields of aerospace, technology, biomedical, and other industries that will provide family -wage job growth; and (5) Planning for industrial and manufacturing use is inadequate to attract new industry and manufacturing and an incentive should be created to stimulate the development of new industrial and manufacturing uses in the existing inventory of lands zoned for industrial and manufacturing use in targeted urban areas through a tax incentive as provided by this chapter. [2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 1.] RCW 84.25.020 Purpose. It is the purpose of this chapter to encourage new manufacturing and industrial uses on undeveloped or underutilized lands zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses in targeted urban areas, thereby increasing employment opportunities for family living wage jobs. Cities that plan under the growth management act meeting the criteria of this chapter where the governing authority of the affected city has found there is insufficient family living wage jobs for its wage earning population may designate a portion of the city's industrial and manufacturing zoned and undeveloped land to receive an ad valorem tax exemption for the value of new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities within the designated area. [2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 2.1 1 1 1 RCW 84.25.030 Definitions. The definitions in this section apply throughout this chapter unless the context clearly requires otherwise. (1) "City" means any city or town. (2) "Family living wage job" means a job that offers health care benefits with a wage that is sufficient for raising a family. A family living wage job must have an average wage of $23 an hour or more, working 2,080 hours per year on the subject site, as adjusted annually for inflation by the consumer price index. The family living wage may be increased by the local authority based on regional factors and wage conditions. (3) "Governing authority" means the local legislative authority of a city or county having jurisdiction over the property for which an exemption may be applied for under this chapter. (4) "Growth management act" means chapter 36.70A RCW. (5) "Industrial/manufacturing facilities" means building improvements that are 10,000 square feet or larger, representing a minimum improvement valuation of $800,000 for uses categorized as "division D: manufacturing" or "division E: transportation (major groups 40-42, 45, or 47-48)" by the United States department of labor in the occupation safety and health administration's standard industrial classification manual, provided, a city may limit the tax exemption to manufacturing uses. (6) "Lands zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses" means lands in a city zoned for an industrial or manufacturing use consistent with the city's comprehensive plan where the lands are designated for industry. (7) "Owner" means the property owner of record. (8) "Targeted area" means an area of undeveloped lands zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses in the city that is located within or contiguous to an innovation partnership zone, foreign trade zone, or EB-5 regional center, and designated for possible exemption under the provisions of this chapter. (9) "Undeveloped or underutilized" means that there are no existing building improvements on the portions of the property targeted for new or expanded industrial or manufacturing uses. [2022 c 172 § 1; 2021 c 218 § 1; 2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 3.1 Effective date-2022 c 172: See note following RCW 82.04.294. RCW 84.25.040 Exemption —New construction of industrial/ manufacturing facilities. (1)(a) The value of new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities qualifying under this chapter is exempt from property taxation under this title, as provided in this section. The value of new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities is exempt from taxation for properties for which an application for a certificate of tax exemption is submitted under this chapter before December 31, 2030. The value is exempt under this section for 10 successive years beginning January 1st of the year immediately following the calendar year of issuance of the certificate. (b) The exemption provided in this section does not include the value of land or nonindustrial/manufacturing-related improvements not qualifying under this chapter. [ 2 1 (2) The exemption provided in this section is in addition to any other exemptions, deferrals, credits, grants, or other tax incentives provided by law. (3) This chapter does not apply to state levies or increases in assessed valuation made by the assessor on nonqualifying portions of buildings and value of land nor to increases made by lawful order of a county board of equalization, the department of revenue, or a county, to a class of property throughout the county or specific area of the county to achieve the uniformity of assessment or appraisal required by law. (4) This exemption does not apply to any county property taxes unless the governing body of the county adopts a resolution and notifies the governing authority of its intent to allow the property to be exempted from county property taxes. (5) At the conclusion of the exemption period, the new industrial/manufacturing facilities cost must be considered as new construction for the purposes of chapter 84.55 RCW. [2021 c 218 § 2; 2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 4.1 RCW 84.25.050 Application requirements for property owner. An owner of property making application under this chapter must meet the following requirements: (1) The new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities must be located on land zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses, undeveloped or underutilized, and as provided in RCW 84.25.060, designated by the city as a targeted area; (2) The new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities must meet all construction and development regulations of the city; (3) The new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities must be completed within three years from the date of approval of the application; and (4) The applicant must enter into a contract with the city approved by the city governing authority under which the applicant has agreed to the implementation of the development on terms and conditions satisfactory to the governing authority. [2021 c 218 § 3; 2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 5.1 RCW 84.25.060 Targeted area designation requirements. (1) The following criteria must be met before an area may be designated as a targeted area: (a) The area must be lands zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses; and (b) The city must have determined that the targeting of the area, as evaluated by the governing authority, will assist in the new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities that will provide employment for family living wage jobs. (2) For the purpose of designating a targeted area, the governing authority may adopt a resolution of intention to so designate an area as generally described in the resolution. The resolution must state the time and place of a hearing to be held by the governing authority to consider the designation of the area and may include such other information pertaining to the designation of the area as the governing authority determines to be appropriate to apprise the public of the action intended. [ 3 (3) The governing authority must give notice of a hearing held under this chapter by publication of the notice once each week for two consecutive weeks, not less than seven days, nor more than thirty days before the date of the hearing in a paper having a general circulation in the city where the proposed targeted area is located. The notice must state the time, date, place, and purpose of the hearing and generally identify the area proposed to be designated as a targeted area. (4) Following the hearing or a continuance of the hearing, and subject to the limit on targeted areas, the governing authority may designate all or a portion of the area described in the resolution of intent as a targeted area if it finds, in its sole discretion, that the criteria in subsection (1) of this section have been met. [2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 6.] RCW 84.25.070 Exemption application procedures. An owner of property seeking an exemption under this chapter must complete the following procedures: (1) The owner must apply to the city on forms adopted by the governing authority. The application must contain the following: (a) Information setting forth the grounds supporting the requested exemption including information indicated on the application form or in the guidelines; (b) A description of the project and site plan, and other information requested; (c) A statement of the expected number of new family living wage jobs to be created; (d) A statement that the applicant is aware of the potential tax liability involved when the property ceases to be eligible for the incentive provided under this chapter; and (e) A statement that the applicant would not have built in this location but for the availability of the tax exemption under this chapter; (2) The applicant must verify the application by oath or affirmation; and (3) The application must be accompanied by the application fee, if any, required under this chapter. The governing authority may permit the applicant to revise an application before final action by the governing authority. [2015 lst sp.s. c 9 § 7.] RCW 84.25.080 Application approval —City governing authority review requirements. (1) The city governing authority may approve the application if it finds that: (a) A minimum of 25 new family living wage jobs will be created on the subject site as a result of new construction of industrial/ manufacturing facilities within one year of building occupancy; (b) The proposed project is, or will be, at the time of completion, in conformance with all local plans and regulations that apply at the time the application is approved; and (c) The criteria of this chapter have been satisfied. (2) Priority must be given to applications that meet the following labor specifications during the new construction and ongoing business of industrial/manufacturing facilities: (a) Compensate workers at prevailing wage rates as determined by the department of labor and industries; (b) Procure from, and contract with, women -owned, minority -owned, or veteran -owned businesses; (c) Procure from, and contract with, entities that have a history of complying with federal and state wage and hour laws and regulations; (d) Include apprenticeship utilization from state -registered apprenticeship programs; (e) Provide for preferred entry for workers living in the area where the project is being constructed; and (f) Maintain certain labor standards for workers employed primarily at the facility after construction, including production, maintenance, and operational employees. [2021 c 218 § 4; 2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 8.] RCW 84.25.090 Application —City governing authority approval or denial —Appeals. (1) The city governing authority must approve or deny an application filed under this chapter within ninety days after receipt of the application. (2) If the application is approved, the city must issue the owner of the property a conditional certificate of acceptance of tax exemption. The certificate must contain a statement by a duly authorized administrative official of the governing authority that the property has complied with the required criteria of this chapter. (3) If the application is denied by the city, the city must state in writing the reasons for denial and send the notice to the applicant at the applicant's last known address within ten days of the denial. (4) Upon denial by the city, an applicant may appeal the denial to the city's governing authority within thirty days after receipt of the denial. The appeal before the city's governing authority must be based upon the record made before the city with the burden of proof on the applicant to show that there was no substantial evidence to support the city's decision. The decision of the city in denying or approving the application is final. [2021 c 218 § 5; 2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 9.] RCW 84.25.100 Application fee. The governing authority may establish an application fee. This fee may not exceed an amount determined to be required to cover the cost to be incurred by the governing authority and the assessor in administering this chapter. The application fee must be paid at the time the application for limited exemption is filed. If the application is approved, the governing authority of the city must pay the application fee to the county assessor for deposit in the county current expense fund, after first deducting that portion of the fee attributable to its own administrative costs in processing the application. If the application is denied, the city's governing authority may retain that portion of the application fee attributable to its own administrative costs and refund the balance to the applicant. [2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 10.1 RCW 84.25.110 Certificate of tax exemption —Requirements. (1) Upon completion of the new construction of a manufacturing/industrial [ 5 1 [industrial/manufacturing] facility for which an application for an exemption under this chapter has been approved and issued a certificate of occupancy, the owner must file with the city the following: (a) A description of the work that has been completed and a statement that the new construction on the owner's property qualify the property for a partial exemption under this chapter; (b) A statement of the new family living wage jobs to be offered as a result of the new construction of manufacturing/industrial [industrial/manufacturing] facilities; and (c) A statement that the work has been completed within three years of the issuance of the conditional certificate of tax exemption. (2) Within thirty days after receipt of the statements required under subsection (1) of this section, the city must determine whether the work completed and the jobs to be offered are consistent with the application and the contract approved by the city and whether the application is qualified for a tax exemption under this chapter. (3) If the criteria of this chapter have been satisfied and the owner's property is qualified for a tax exemption under this chapter, the city must file the certificate of tax exemption with the county assessor within ten days of the expiration of the thirty -day period provided under subsection (2) of this section. (4) The city must notify the applicant that a certificate of tax exemption is denied if the city determines that: (a) The work was not completed within three years of the application date; (b) The work was not constructed consistent with the application or other applicable requirements; (c) The jobs to be offered are not consistent with the application and criteria of this chapter; or (d) The owner's property is otherwise not qualified for an exemption under this chapter. (5) If the city finds that the work was not completed within the required time period due to circumstances beyond the control of the owner and that the owner has been acting and could reasonably be expected to act in good faith and with due diligence, the governing authority or the city official authorized by the governing authority may extend the deadline for completion of the work for a period not to exceed twenty-four consecutive months. (6) The city's governing authority may enact an ordinance to provide a process for an owner to appeal a decision by the city that the owner is not entitled to a certificate of tax exemption to the city. The owner may appeal a decision by the city to deny a certificate of tax exemption in superior court under RCW 34.05.510 through 34.05.598, if the appeal is filed within thirty days of notification by the city to the owner of the exemption denial. [2015 lst sp.s. c 9 § 11.1 RCW 84.25.120 Annual report. (1) Thirty days after the anniversary of the date of the certificate of tax exemption and each year for the tax exemption period, the owner of the new industrial/ manufacturing facilities must file with a designated authorized representative of the city an annual report indicating the following: (a) A statement of the family living wage jobs at the facility as of the anniversary date; [ 6 1 (b) A certification by the owner that the property has not changed use; (c) A description of changes or improvements constructed after issuance of the certificate of tax exemption; and (d) Any additional information requested by the city. (2) A city that issues a certificate of tax exemption under this chapter must report annually by December 31st of each year, beginning in 2013, to the department of commerce. The report must include the following information: (a) The number of tax exemption certificates granted; (b) The total number and type of new manufacturing/industrial [industrial/manufacturing] facilities constructed; (c) The number of family living wage jobs resulting from the new manufacturing/industrial [industrial/manufacturing] facilities; and (d) The value of the tax exemption for each project receiving a tax exemption and the total value of tax exemptions granted. [2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 12.] RCW 84.25.130 Improvements. (1) If the value of improvements have been exempted under this chapter, the improvements continue to be exempted for the applicable period under this chapter so long as they are not converted to another use and continue to satisfy all applicable conditions including, but not limited to, zoning, land use, building, and family -wage job creation. (2) If an owner voluntarily opts to discontinue compliance with the requirements of this chapter, the owner must notify the assessor within 60 days of the change in use or intended discontinuance. (3) If, after a certificate of tax exemption has been filed with the county assessor, the city discovers that a portion of the property is changed or will be changed to disqualify the owner for exemption eligibility under this chapter, the tax exemption must be canceled and the following occurs: (a) Additional real property tax must be imposed on the value of the nonqualifying improvements in the amount that would be imposed if an exemption had not been available under this chapter, plus a penalty equal to 20 percent of the additional value. This additional tax is calculated based upon the difference between the property tax paid and the property tax that would have been paid if it had included the value of the nonqualifying improvements dated back to the date that the improvements were converted to a nonqualifying use; (b) The tax must include interest upon the amounts of the additional tax at the same statutory rate charged on delinquent property taxes from the dates on which the additional tax could have been paid without penalty if the improvements had been assessed at a value without regard to this chapter; and (c) The additional tax owed together with interest and penalty becomes a lien on the property and attaches at the time the property or portion of the property is removed from the qualifying use under this chapter or the amenities no longer meet the applicable requirements for exemption under this chapter. A lien under this section has priority to, and must be fully paid and satisfied before, a recognizance, mortgage, judgment, debt, obligation, or responsibility to or with which the property may become charged or liable. The lien may be foreclosed upon expiration of the same period after delinquency and in the same manner provided by law for foreclosure of liens for delinquent real property taxes. An additional [ 7 1 tax unpaid on its due date is delinquent. From the date of delinquency until paid, interest must be charged at the same rate applied by law to delinquent property taxes. (4) If, after a certificate of tax exemption has been filed with the county assessor, the city discovers that the facility maintains fewer than 25 family living wage jobs, the owner is considered ineligible for the exemption under this chapter, and the following must occur: (a) The tax exemption must be canceled; and (b) Additional real property tax must be imposed in the amount that would be imposed if an exemption had not been available under this chapter, dated back to the date that the facility last maintained a minimum of 25 family living wage jobs. (5) Upon a determination that a tax exemption is to be terminated for a reason stated in this section, the city's governing authority must notify the record owner of the property as shown by the tax rolls by mail, return receipt requested, of the determination to terminate the exemption. The owner may appeal the determination to the city, within 30 days by filing a notice of appeal with the city, which notice must specify the factual and legal basis on which the determination of termination is alleged to be erroneous. At an appeal hearing, all affected parties may be heard and all competent evidence received. After the hearing, the deciding body or officer must either affirm, modify, or repeal the decision of termination of exemption based on the evidence received. An aggrieved party may appeal the decision of the deciding body or officer to the superior court as provided in RCW 34.05.510 through 34.05.598. (6) Upon determination by the city to terminate an exemption, the county officials having possession of the assessment and tax rolls must correct the rolls in the manner provided for omitted property under RCW 84.40.080. The county assessor must make such a valuation of the property and improvements as is necessary to permit the correction of the rolls. The value of the new industrial/manufacturing facilities added to the rolls is considered new construction for the purposes of chapter 84.40 RCW. The owner may appeal the valuation to the county board of equalization as provided in chapter 84.40 RCW. If there has been a failure to comply with this chapter, the property must be listed as an omitted assessment for assessment years beginning January lst of the calendar year in which the noncompliance first occurred, but the listing as an omitted assessment may not be for a period more than three calendar years preceding the year in which the failure to comply was discovered. [2021 c 218 § 6; 2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 13.] RCW 84.25.140 Application-2015 1st sp.s. c 9. This act applies to taxes levied for collection in 2016 and thereafter. [2015 1st sp.s. c 9 § 14.1 1 8 1 PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION APPLICATION FOR INDUSTRIAL MANUFACTURING USES (RCW 84.25) ALL SECTIONS MUST BE COMPLETED FOR CONSIDERATION FOR AGENCY USE Date: FEE: S500 Credit Card # Project Name Ownership Company Site Address Numkmr Name Address City, State, Zip Work Phone Email Standard Industrial Class (SIC) Project Description (Attach additional pages, if needed) I Project Cost Square Footage of Existing SIC — D: Manufacturing # Industrial / Manufacturing Uses Only SIC — E: Transportation # Total Building Costs Proposed Exemption Square Footage Total —Building Square Footage (new buildings only) T (upon completion) EMPLOYEE INFORMATION 1. Will the business offer health care benefits? ❑ YES ❑ NO 2. How many permanent, full-time (2,080 hours/year) positions will be created? 3. How many new positions created (above) be paid a minimum living wage of $23/hour or more? 4. Will the business compensate workers at prevailing wage rates? ❑ YES ❑ NO 5. Will the business procure from, and contract with, women -owned, minority -owned, or veteran -owned businesses? ❑ YES ❑ NO & Will the business procure from, and contract with, entities that have a history of complying with federal and state wage and hour laws and regulations? ❑ YES ❑ NO 7. Will the business include apprenticeship utilization from state -regulated apprenticeship programs? ❑ YES ❑ NO 8. Will the business provide for preferred entry for workers living in the area where the project is being constructed? ❑ YES ❑ NO 9. Will the business maintain certain labor standards for workers employed primarily at the facility after construction, including production, maintenance, and operational employees? ❑YES El NO 10. Is the subject parcel located within the Targeted Urban Area boundary for the property tax exemption identified by the City? ❑ YES ❑ NO I understand the potential tax liability involved when the property ceases to be eligible for the incentive provided under RCW 84.25. There are no existing building improvements on the portion of the property targeted for the tax exemption. I understand that the construction of the industriaUmanufacturing facility must be completed in three (3) years from the date of application approval. O 1 hereby certify that the project meets the industrial manufacturing requirements as described in RCW 84.25. I understand that the new construction of industrial/manufacturing facilities must meet all construction and development regulations of the city. I understand that this waiver pertains only to the City's portion of property taxes related to the building ❑ improvements excluding the improved valuation of the land and the taxing authority of other jurisdictions. 1 understand that the City of Richland's decision regarding the tax exemption is final. I understand that the value of new construction of industriaUmanufacturing facilities is exempt under RCW 84.25 for ten (10) consecutive years beginning January 1st of the year immediately following the calendar year of issuance of ❑ a certificate of tax exemption and there are no extensions. I understand that, If approved, the next step is an agreement with the city that is approved by the city governing authority under which the applicant has agreed to the implementation of the development on terms and conditions satisfactory to the governing authority. I understand that the City will require a certification of completion of the project in compliance with this document and the creation of jobs annually for the duration of the exemption. If your application is approved, the city will issue a conditional certificate of acceptance of the tax exemption within ninety (90) days after receipt of the application. The certificate will contain a statement by a duly authorized administrative official of the City of Richland that the property has complied with the required criteria of RCW 84.25. Upon denial by the city, an applicant may appeal the denial to the city's governing authority within thirty days after receipt of the denial. The appeal before the city's governing authority must be based upon the record made before the city with the burden of proof on the applicant to show that there was no substantial evidence to support the city's decision. The decision of the city in denying or approving the application is final. I certify that I am the Owner of the property, I do hereby declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the state of Washington that I have familiarized myself with the rules and regulations with respect to preparing and filing this application and that the statements and information submitted herewith are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I further certify that this project would not have been built in Richland but for the availability of the tax exemption and other locations considered. Property Owner(s) Printed Name v Property Owner(s) Signature Date